You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

The Last Five Years

There's nothing so antique as a four-poster onstage at the Minetta Lane Theater, but Jason Robert Brown's new musical, "The Last Five Years," could easily be retitled "I Do! I Don't!" Bittersweet and nearly perfect, Brown has come up with a winning combination of music and book that could run longer than the couple he so artfully dissects.

Cathy - Sherie Rene Scott
Jamie - Norbert Leo Butz

There’s nothing so antique as a four-poster onstage at the Minetta Lane Theater, but Jason Robert Brown’s new musical, “The Last Five Years,” could easily be retitled “I Do! I Don’t!” I fail to recall how long Mary Martin and Robert Preston stayed married in the 1966 two-hander tuner by Harvey Schmidt and Tom Jones, but it seemed like forever (never a plus onstage) when I saw them on tour. Life as well as the theater moves faster these days, and so the dating, marriage and inevitable divorce endures an intermission-less half-decade that lasts just 83 minutes in “The Last Five Years.” Short, bittersweet and nearly perfect, Brown has come up with a winning combination of music and book that could run longer than the couple he so artfully dissects.

The last five years is actually her story; his is the next five. Cathy (Sherie Rene Scott) begins at the end of their relationship and moves backward as Jamie (Norbert Leo Butz) sings of their first date and then goes forward to the divorce. He is a young Jewish novelist of enormous success; she is the somewhat aimless shiksa who becomes a performer at his insistence and finds herself stuck on tour in Ohio. Their respective stories meet briefly in the middle at the wedding in which they sing their first of only two duets, “The Next Ten Minutes.”

Taking the leap with such high concepts, writers usually crash-land. Brown soars, making the conceit imbue every encouraging, optimistic step forward with an anticipation of its mortality. Under Daisy Prince’s direction, that pervading sense of doom is never more poignant than during “The Next Ten Minutes,” which begins with Jamie in a rowboat in Central Park as he points out the apartment buildings of the rich and famous to an imaginary Cathy, who only later appears in the person of Scott. He proposes, she accepts, and they are married. Then Cathy steps into the receding rowboat as she remarks on the Central Park West landmarks pointed out to her by an imaginary Jamie, who is no longer present in the person of Butz.

None of this would work without a score that is replete with infectious tunes as well as a couple of patter songs that reveal a jaded showbiz humor that could not even be hinted at in Brown’s last show, “Parade,” about anti-Semitism in the South. Brown also orchestrates here, using a six-person combo of piano, percussion and strings that is nothing less than sumptuous.

Perhaps he should rethink some of his recitative, however. Maybe it’s better to have your characters talk rather than sing about choosing just the right photographer for your head shots. Also, for anyone who’s OD’d on Woody Allen movies, must the Jewish guy always save the shiksa from her own radically diminished sense of self?

As for Scott and Butz: Contrary to popular myth, they do make Broadway performers like they used to. In addition to the necessary and considerable chops required for “The Last Five Years” — it’s almost nonstop singing — these two give the impression they could walk into any straight play, not sing a note and still carry the show with considerable humor and pathos.

“The Last Five Years” is structured into 14 scenes. For clarity’s sake, Prince has wisely chosen to present them as distinct set pieces of he said/she said. Christine Binder’s elaborate lighting design provides the necessary transitions against Beowulf Boritt’s gargantuan circular set, which is as impressive as it is threatening to look at for an hour and a half. Complete with floral bouquets, an empty beer bottle and a couple of dozen white folding chairs, the scene of a wedding has been rolled on its side as if some huge marble sundial had just broken lose from its stand. The whole thing looks ready to tumble into the audience. I got the point at first glance, but my fear lingered all night.

The Last Five Years

Minetta Lane Theater; 399 seats; $60

Production: An Arielle Tepper and Marty Bell presentation in association with Libby Adler Mages/Mari Glick and Rose/Land Prods. of a musical in one act by Jason Robert Brown. Book, lyrics, music and orchestrations by Brown. Directed by Daisy Prince.

Creative: Set and costumes, Beowulf Boritt; lighting, Christine Binder; sound, Duncan Edwards; musical director, Thomas Murray; casting, Mark Simon; press, Barlow/Hartman; general manager, Roy Gabay; production manager, Kai Brothers; production stage manager, Patty Lyons. Opened March 3, 2002; reviewed March 2. Running time: 83 MIN

Cast: Cathy - Sherie Rene Scott
Jamie - Norbert Leo Butz

More Legit

  • Tootsie review

    Broadway Review: 'Tootsie'

    The new Broadway adaptation of “Tootsie” is old-fashioned and proud of it — and it’s a surefire crowd-pleaser, in this musical spin on the 1982 film comedy with Santino Fontana in the Dustin Hoffman role. Robert Horn (book) and Tony-winner David Yazbek (score) have a high old time poking fun at theatrical rituals — the [...]

  • Kelli O'Hara

    Listen: How Kelli O'Hara Brings #MeToo to 'Kiss Me, Kate'

    “Kiss Me, Kate” is one of the best-known titles in musical theater. But in this day and age, the “Taming of the Shrew”-inspired comedy’s depiction of the gender dynamic seems downright, well, problematic. Listen to this week’s podcast below: Kelli O’Hara is well aware of that, and so were her collaborators on the Roundabout Theatre [...]

  • All My Sons review

    Broadway Review: 'All My Sons' With Annette Bening

    Don’t be fooled by the placid backyard setting, neighborly small talk and father-son joviality at the start of the Roundabout Theatre Company’s blistering revival of Arthur Miller’s “All My Sons” starring Annette Bening and Tracy Letts. There are plenty of secrets, resentments and disillusionments ahead, poised to rip this sunny Middle Americana facade to shreds. [...]

  • A still image from The Seven

    How Magic Leap, Video Games Are Defining Future of Royal Shakespeare Company

    At the Royal Shakespeare Company in Stratford upon Avon, Sarah Ellis has the difficult job of figuring out where theater of the 1500s fits into the 21st century. As Director of Digital Development, a title which might seem out of place in an industry ruled by live, human performances, Ellis represents a recent seachange on [...]

  • Gary review

    Broadway Review: 'Gary: A Sequel to Titus Andronicus' With Nathan Lane

    Nathan Lane and Kristine Nielsen, two of the funniest people on the face of the earth, play street cleaners tasked with carting away the dead after the civil wars that brought down the Roman Empire. Well, a job’s a job, and Gary (Lane) and Janice (Nielsen) go about their disgusting work without complaint. “Long story [...]

  • Laurie Metcalf, John Lithgow'Hillary and Clinton'

    Why John Lithgow Worried About Starring in Broadway's 'Hillary and Clinton'

    When Lucas Hnath first conceived of “Hillary and Clinton” in 2008, he was writing for and about a very different America. Now, a total reimagining of the show has made its way to Broadway with Laurie Metcalf and John Lithgow in the titular roles. At the opening on Thursday night, the cast and creatives talked [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content