Critic rethinks Tharp

Reworked show gets improved buzz from Tribune

NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago.

Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, where it was reprinted for all of the pop star’s Long Island fans to read.

Needless to say, the producers of “Movin’ Out” were less than happy at Newsday’s decision to run the review a good three months before the show opens on Broadway.

Tharp, however, immediately set about revising the show and, in a novel turn, invited critics to come back and see it at the end of its Chi run Sept. 1. Apparently, she had only one taker, but he was the big one: Phillips.

“Tharp’s extensive revisions — focusing on act one and its problems of narrative clarity — have made for a clearer, more satisfying show,” Phillips wrote in the Tribune. “The revisions haven’t smoothed out all the bumps. But Tharp’s changes may give the show a better chance at Broadway success.”

In an unusual move, Phillips sprinkled quotes from Tharp throughout his second review of “Movin’ Out.”

Of her revisions, the director-choreographer told the critic, “The guiding principle was this: If it’s confusing, cut it out. . . . We simply had too many elements. I guess the word is ‘overload.’ ”

“Movin’ Out” begins previews Sept. 30 at the Richard Rodgers Theater, with its Gotham preem set for Oct. 24.

More Scene

  • David Harbour'Stranger Things' event, Los Angeles,

    'Stranger Things' Season 3 Is Inspired by 1985's 'Fletch' (EXCLUSIVE)

    NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago. Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, […]

  • Jeffrey Katzenberg

    Jeffrey Katzenberg on Oscars' New Popular Film Category Controversy

    NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago. Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, […]

  • Ruth Wilson

    'The Affair's' Ruth Wilson Stays Mum on Controversial Exit

    NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago. Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, […]

  • Samantha Barks, Andy Karl'Pretty Woman: The

    'Pretty Woman' Broadway Cast Recalls Performing for Julia Roberts

    NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago. Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, […]

  • Jeffrey Katzenberg Lew Wasserman

    Jeffrey Katzenberg Remembers Being Mentored by Lew Wasserman

    NEW YORK — Twyla Tharp didn’t get many takers to re-review her Broadway-bound “Movin’ Out” in Chicago. Set to the songs of Billy Joel, the show opened in late July at the Shubert Theater, where it received mixed to downbeat reviews. Michael Phillips’ negative notice in the Chicago Tribune quickly found its way into Newsday, […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content