Monsieur Batignole

In "Monsieur Batignole," a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls.

With:
Simon Bernstein - Jules Sitruk Edmond Batignole - Gerard Jugnot Marguerite Batignole - Michele Garcia Pierre-Jean Lamour - Jean-Paul Rouve Micheline Batignole - Alexia Portal SS Col. Spreich - Gotz Burger Max Bernstein - Sam Karmann Lucien Morel - Ticky Holgado

In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable behavior counteracted by human resourcefulness. In his eighth stint behind the camera, multihyphenate star Gerard Jugnot has fashioned a fine package, ready to travel. Pic was top grosser the day it bowed in Gaul.

Edmond Batignole (Jugnot) runs a small butcher shop and catering establishment in Paris. His shrewish wife, Micheline (Alexia Portal), mans the cash register. Living with them in cramped quarters on the premises are their twentysomething daughter, Marguerite (Michele Garcia), and her fiance of two years, Pierre-Jean Lamour (Jean-Paul Rouve), an aspiring playwright who admires the Germans and is only too happy to inform on Jews.

Pic opens on July 15, 1942, as the Bernstein family is about to abandon its well-appointed apartment two flights up from Batignole’s shop to flee to Switzerland. Surgeon Max Bernstein (Sam Karmann) has a wife, a daughter and a bright young son, Simon (Jules Sitruk).

Pierre-Jean tricks his future father-in-law into delaying Dr. Bernstein while he dutifully informs SS Colonel Spreich (Gotz Burger) that some wealthy Jews are about to get away. After the Bernsteins are captured, Pierre-Jean arranges for their apartment to go to him and the Batignoles.

Edmond is drafted to cater the SS colonel’s social gatherings. Things are swell until young Simon, who’s escaped, comes knocking on the door of his family’s erstwhile abode.

Edmond hides the lad first in the maid’s room, then in the cellar, where he is unexpectedly joined by two young female cousins. The butcher finds himself protecting the children and resolves to get the three to safety in Switzerland.

Pic’s characters are stereotypes, but the evolving situations are so deftly handled that the narrative accomplishes what the best mass-audience films do — entertaining the viewer while providing food for thought. Luck (both good and bad) is a huge component of the protags’ journey, which is perilous yet marbled with genuinely funny incidents.

Pic offers vivid examples of both casual and large-scale profiteering and doesn’t shy away from depicting the zeal with which some French authorities collaborated with the Germans. Period re-creations are spot-on.

Apart from an artistic dance number in a cabaret featuring topless beauties,film about the joint dilemmas of children and adults is suitable for older children. Students of prior films about the era may spot traces of Claude Berri’s “The Two of Us” or Joseph Losey’s “M. Klein,” among others, but the prevailing inspiration here clearly is a personal quest with a universal reach.

Projecting exceptional intelligence as well as complete boyishness, Sitruk is outstanding as Simon. Jugnot makes Edmond a believable everyman who’s oblivious to the rotten underbelly of the status quo, yet responds when a modest chance for greatness is thrust upon him.

Khalil Chahine’s score is a model of how not to clobber auds with musical emotions.

Monsieur Batignole

France

Production: A Bac Distribution release of an RF2K Prods., Novo Arturo Films, TF1 Films production. (International sales: UGC Intl., Paris.) Produced by Olivier Granier, Dominique Farrugia, Gerard Jugnot. Directed by Gerard Jugnot. Screenplay, Philippe Lopes Curval, Jugnot.

Crew: Camera (color, widescreen), Gerard Simon; editor, Catherine Kelber; music, Khalil Chahine; production designer, Jean-Louis Poveda; costume designer, Martine Rapin; sound (Dolby), Claude Villand, Michel Kharat; assistant director, Herve Ruet; casting, Francoise Menidrey, Sandra Mainguene. Reviewed at UGC Danton, Paris, March 9, 2002. Running time: 101 MIN.

With: Simon Bernstein - Jules Sitruk Edmond Batignole - Gerard Jugnot Marguerite Batignole - Michele Garcia Pierre-Jean Lamour - Jean-Paul Rouve Micheline Batignole - Alexia Portal SS Col. Spreich - Gotz Burger Max Bernstein - Sam Karmann Lucien Morel - Ticky HolgadoWith: Violette Blanckaert, Daphne Baiwir, Elisabeth Commelin, Hubert Saint Macary, Nadine Spinoza, Jean-Marie Winling, Karine Pinoteau, Sylvie Herbert.

More Film

  • 'The Equalizer 2' Review

    Film Review: Denzel Washington in 'The Equalizer 2'

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • Stan Dragoti 'The Last Boyscout' PremiereDecember

    Stan Dragoti, Director of 'Mr. Mom,' 'Love at First Bite,' Dies at 85

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • Jagged Edge

    Film News Roundup: Halle Berry's 'Jagged Edge' Remake Finds Writer

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • Kate Winslet Diane Keaton Mia Wasikowska

    Kate Winslet, Diane Keaton, Mia Wasikowska to Star in 'Silent Heart' Remake

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • (L to R) Young Tanya (JESSICA

    'Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again' Reviews: What the Critics Are Saying

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

    'Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants' Stage Musical in the Works

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

  • Sundance Film Festival Placeholder

    Sundance Festival's Economic Impact Jumps Up 26% From 2017, Study Says

    In “Monsieur Batignole,” a Gentile butcher gets a crash course in Jewish reality when a young escapee neighbor falls into his lap during the summer of 1942. Well-crafted, bittersweet comedy, in which an ordinary fellow in Nazi-occupied France behaves heroically despite himself, zips along with an entertaining and witty blend of close calls and despicable […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content