×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Sister Mary Explains It All

Satire tends to date quickly, but Christopher Durang's 1980 black comedy criticizing Catholic rigidity, "Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All for You," still has some bite to it, which says a lot about the writer's incisive wit.

With:
Sister Mary - Diane Keaton Gary Sullivan - Brian Benben Aloysius Benheim - Wallace Langham Angela DiMarco - Laura San Giacomo Philomena Rostovich - Jennifer Tilly Thomas - Max Morrow Skeptical Husband - Martin Mull

Satire tends to date quickly, but Christopher Durang’s 1980 black comedy criticizing Catholic rigidity, “Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All for You,” still has some bite to it, which says a lot about the writer’s incisive wit. Yet that bite comes across too stridently in this Showtime adaptation of the play (whose title has been truncated). Under Marshall Brickman’s direction, the comic beginnings come off too broad and the more earnest elements too sentimental. These are really symptoms of a more fundamental problem: This is a genuinely theatrical piece, and presented realistically it simply doesn’t work in the same way.

Story involves the title character (Diane Keaton) delivering her Christmas lecture on the ways of the world, a ritual she’s performed for more than 25 years. A firm believer in the strict teachings of the church, Sister Mary has made her views on heaven, hell, purgatory and mortal sin known to several generations of pupils at this church school. This year, she’s visited by a foursome of former students, who, in performing the Nativity scene as they did years ago, confront Sister Mary with their sinful lives.

Durang and Brickman open up the piece by showing the four students when they were children in 1959. The film then jumps forward 25 years to show us these cherub-faced disciples of Sister Mary as adults who have clearly, shall we say, lapsed. They’re played by the solid team of Laura San Giacomo, Brian Benben, Jennifer Tilly and Wallace Langham. As they start to reveal to Sister Mary how their lives have deviated from her teachings, the nun proves to be as inflexible as ever. Her reactions caused controversy when the play premiered, and the material undoubtedly still would give the Catholic League fits. Showtime, of course, would invite the publicity of loud condemnation.

A versatile comic performer who can capture multiple levels of a character, Keaton seems at first glance a fine choice for Sister Mary. But she’s a bit too restrained here. Keaton’s a physical actress who uses her full body to define a character, but here, wrapped in a nun’s habit, and often photographed in close-up, she’s forced to act almost solely with her face, which turns out to be not especially expressive or subtle. What’s missing most of all is the sincerity of the character’s deep beliefs. One can imagine an older actress with a less antsy bearing — Maggie Smith, for example — pulling this off to greater effect.

But the biggest problem is that the film simply can’t re-create the theatricality of Durang’s initial work. Since the original piece was structured as a lecture, the audience was included in the theatrical space and addressed directly by Sister Mary — she was, in effect, explaining it all “for you.” In this adaptation, we see the audience, some of whom are sketched out in the broadest possible character strokes. Even though the audience members, like the under-used Martin Mull as an unbeliever forced to attend by his wife, provide a moment or two of humor, their reactions are obvious at the beginning, and then as things go awry, Durang and Brickman seem perplexed about what to do with the audience at all. The satire itself feels cold and distant as a result, and the playing too realistic instead of properly stylized.

Perhaps this dilemma could have been resolved by having Sister Mary deliver her lecture as a television production addressed directly to her unseen audience. That would have been more faithful to the original.

Sister Mary Explains It All

Showtime; Sun. May 27, 8 p.m.

Production: Filmed in Toronto by Tennant/Stambler Prods. in association with Columbia TriStar Television. Executive producers, Kirk Stambler, Victoria Tennant; co-executive producers, Charles Barrington Lewis, Brian Woods; producer, Ron Bozman; director, Marshall Brickman; writer, Christopher Durang, based on his play "Sister Mary Ignatius Explains It All for You."

Crew: Camera, Anthony B. Richmond; production designer, Ian Brock; costumes, Suzette Daigle; editor, Kristina Boden; music, Philippe Sarde; casting, Laura Rosenthal, Stephanie Gorin. 76 MINS.

Cast: Sister Mary - Diane Keaton Gary Sullivan - Brian Benben Aloysius Benheim - Wallace Langham Angela DiMarco - Laura San Giacomo Philomena Rostovich - Jennifer Tilly Thomas - Max Morrow Skeptical Husband - Martin MullWith: Victoria Tennant, Joanne Boland, Jon Davey, Joan Gregson, Linda Kash, B.J. Woodbury, Jocelyn Zucco, Rebecca Brenner, Spencer Van Wyck, Michael Cameron, Chloe Randle Reis, Steven Taylor, Iaislinn Paul, Larry Mannell, Deborah Tennant, Hunter Scott, Dana Fernald, Edie Inksetter, Mari Trainor, Colleen Williams, Glen McDonald, Mark Allan, Paul MacFarlane, Gary Pearson, Ken Gorin, Hazel Gorin, Kirk Stambler.

More TV

  • Billy McFarland of the Fyre Festival

    Entertainment One Takes International Rights to Hulu's 'Fyre Fraud'

    Entertainment One has picked up international rights to Hulu’s documentary on the disastrous Fyre Festival. “Fyre Fraud” looks at the unscrupulous dealings of Billy McFarland, the self-aggrandizing huckster who sold thousands of tickets to a music festival in the Bahamas that turned out to be a sham. Duped by a promotional campaign on social media [...]

  • ‘Stan & Ollie’ Producer Making Joan

    ‘Stan & Ollie’ Producer to Make TV Series About Joan and Jackie Collins

    The colorful lives of movie star Joan Collins and her bestselling novelist sister, Jackie, will be dramatized in a TV series. Sony-backed Fable Pictures, the British film and TV producer behind “Stan & Ollie,” will make the series, having secured the TV rights to the Collinses’ story. The series, which has the working title “Joan [...]

  • Friends From College

    'Friends From College' Canceled by Netflix

    Netflix has canceled comedy series “Friends From College” after two seasons. “Friends from College will not return for a third season,” a Netflix spokesperson said in a statement Monday. “We’re grateful to creators Nick Stoller and Francesca Delbanco for creating a wise, funny and supremely relatable show. We also want to thank the hard-working crew, [...]

  • Mandy Moore

    Mandy Moore Opens Up About Her Marriage to Ryan Adams: ‘I Was So Sad’

    Mandy Moore opened up about her marriage to Ryan Adams on Monday’s episode of Marc Maron’s “WTF” podcast. While the interview was taped before the publication of the Feb. 13 New York Times report in which multiple women, including Moore, accuse Adams of sexual misconduct or emotionally abusive behavior, she speaks freely about the “unhealthy dynamic” in [...]

  • Lisa Borders Time's Up

    Time's Up President Lisa Borders Resigns

    Lisa Borders has resigned as president of Time’s Up, she and the organization announced on Monday. Borders is resigning due to family issues, she said in a statement. Time’s Up COO Rebecca Goldman will now serve as interim CEO. More Reviews Film Review: Keira Knightley in 'The Aftermath' Sundance Film Review: Stephen K. Bannon in [...]

  • Alfonso Cuaron71st Annual Writers Guild Awards,

    Alfonso Cuarón on Academy's 'Inevitable' Reversal on Televised Oscar Categories

    Alfonso Cuarón isn’t exactly surprised that the Academy reversed its decision and will now air all the Oscar categories during the live show on Sunday. Feb. 24. Calling the decision “inevitable,”Cuarón tells Variety that he thinks the Academy should take things even further. “Let’s stop calling them technical categories!” he told Variety on Sunday night [...]

  • Desus Nice The Kid Mero

    TV Shows to Watch the Week of Feb. 18, 2019: Academy Awards, 'Desus & Mero'

    Welcome back to Tune In: our weekly newsletter offering a guide to the best of the week’s TV. Each week, Variety’s TV team combs through the week’s schedule, selecting our picks of what to watch and when/how to watch them. This week, the Academy Awards air and Desus & Mero make their debut on Showtime. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content