UJA honor hits sour note

Jewish activists displeased with honoree

Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons.

The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for being the first to honor a German.

But many of the assembled luminaries, including Nobel laureate and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, argued that Middelhoff deserved to be judged on the merits of his actions rather than his heritage.

“The children of murderers are not murderers; they are children,” Wiesel said during an emotional keynote speech. “If one is permitted to hate the children of killers, where does it end?”

But the evening had its lighter moments as well, including punctuations of dry wit from master of ceremonies Tom Brokaw, and a musical performance from “Aida” star (and recording artist for Bertelsmann unit RCA Records) Heather Headley.

Among the corporate heavy-hitters in attendance were AOL Time Warner chairman Steve Case, chief exec Gerald Levin and co-chief operating officer Bob Pittman; Vivendi Universal vice chairman Edgar Bronfman Jr.; BMG Entertainment CEO Rolf Schmidt-Holtz; J Records founder Clive Davis; Bertelsmann’s U.S. chief Joel Klein; and National Basketball Assn. commissioner David Stern.

More Scene

  • Carter Hudson, John Singleton, Angela LewisFX's

    John Singleton on Disney-Fox Deal: 'You Gotta Let FX Be What It Is'

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Kevin Durant Lindsey Vonn

    Kevin Durant, Lindsey Vonn to Keynote Variety's Sports & Entertainment Breakfast

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Cher and Meryl Streep'Mamma Mia! Here

    How the Cast of 'Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again' Geeked Out Around Cher

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Demi MooreComedy Central's Roast of Bruce

    Demi Moore Appears as Surprise Guest at Bruce Willis' Comedy Central Roast

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Outfest Filmmakers Get Political, Issue Call

    Outfest Filmmakers Get Political, Issue Call to Action on Opening Night

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Bob Woodruff Foundation Acquires Veterans Org

    Bob Woodruff Foundation Acquires Veterans Org Got Your 6

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

  • Tiffany HaddishTiffany Haddish at the Hollywood

    Tiffany Haddish on Future Career Plans, Taking Advice From Tyler Perry, Melissa McCarthy

    Tuesday night’s United Jewish Appeal Federation of New York dinner honoring Bertelsmann topper Thomas Middelhoff was as heavy with controversy as it was with global media barons. The org’s sixth annual Steven J. Ross Humanitarian Award dinner, held in the opulent grand ballroom of Gotham’s Waldorf-Astoria hotel, drew the ire of some Jewish activists for […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content