You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Blurry roles for toons kudo

Difference betwwen f/x, animation weighs on new category

When Porky the Pig talks, it’s animation. But when Babe the pig talked, it’s a special effect — right?

It should be a simple to distinguish the two. In one case, the producers used techniques other than standard movie photography to create an image on film. But in the other instance … wait a minute.

The distinction may be of only minor interest to moviegoers, but now that there’s an Oscar for feature animation, the line between animation and live-action is of major import. But it’s one that digital technology is blurring.

“It is a very fuzzy line between special effects and animation,” says John Lasseter, executive vice president of creative at Pixar Animation Studios, and exec producer of the Pixar/Disney toon “Monsters Inc.”

Lasseter says the best place to start is the dictionary, which says animation means “to give life to.” “When you take something that’s inert, and through motion, give it life, make it appear to be alive, living, breathing thinking and having emotions, that’s animation,” says Lasseter. “But when you take something that’s live-action, and move a part of it, that’s a special effect.”

But the definition that matters is the one in the Academy’s Oscar rulebook. There, an animated feature is defined as “a motion picture of at least 70 minutes in running time and where a significant number of the major characters in the film are animated, and animation figures in no less than 75% of the picture’s running time.”

The letter and spirit of that regulation, particularly the emphasis on the concept of character, will probably — and properly — exclude movies that are full of more subtle CGI effects, such as the creation of misty breath on cold days, or the digital insertion of snow or other backgrounds that aren’t really there.

It’s a good definition, animators say, but as movies contain more and more computer-generated effects and CG characters, there is likely to be some controversy.

“When you set up these arbitrary rules you’re going to have to let them mature,” says Richard Hollander, president of the film division at Rhythm & Hues Studios, the shop that made Babe talk and turned the stars of “Cats & Dogs” into planetary warriors. “I think the spirit of the award is that the movie should be driven by the animation — that if you didn’t have the animation you wouldn’t have the story at all.”

“Cats & Dogs,” a film full of characters that were either fully or partially computer generated, did not qualify for the animation Oscar because the percentage of time that animated characters appears was not high enough. But observers say the fur will likely start to fly when live action films — such as the next “Star Wars” installment, which will feature computer-made characters like Jar Jar Binks, or the upcoming “Stuart Little 2” — employ completely animated main characters.

Popular on Variety

More News

  • China presentation mipcom

    Reality Shows, Rom-Coms and Ping Pong Dramas: Chinese Producers Show Off TV Exports

    At its best, television serves as a mirror for its audience. This year, the Mipcom conference trained its annual country-of-focus spotlight on original TV content produced in China. That proved to be a timely choice as the conference came on the heels of last week’s headline-making clashes between Chinese and Western cultural values in the [...]

  • Ronan Farrow Shepard Smith

    From Ronan Farrow to Shepard Smith, the Media News Is Nonstop (Column)

    There are so many big stories erupting on the media news front right now, it makes your head spin. All the upheaval is spurring spirited conversations across the industry that are sure to rage on for months. Of course, there’s the open warfare that’s broken out between Ronan Farrow and NBC News president Noah Oppenheim [...]

  • Nick Jonas, Shawn Levy Team for

    Nick Jonas, Shawn Levy Team for Netflix YA Series

    Nick Jonas and “Stranger Things” producer Shawn Levy are teaming on a YA holiday series which has been ordered at Netflix. The show in question, “Dash & Lily,” is based on the book series “Dash & Lily’s Book of Dares” by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan, and will consist of eight 30-minute episodes, scheduled to [...]

  • Felicity Huffman

    Felicity Huffman Reports to Federal Prison to Serve Two-Week Sentence

    Felicity Huffman reported to federal prison in Dublin, Calif., on Tuesday morning to begin her two-week sentence for paying to cheat on her daughter’s SAT test. Huffman pleaded guilty to one count of fraud, admitting that she paid $15,000 to consultant Rick Singer to boost her daughter’s SAT score. Judge Idira Talwani sentenced her last [...]

  • daydream view

    Google Ships Pixel 4 Without Daydream VR Support, Stops Selling Daydream Viewer

    Google is effectively phasing out its Daydream virtual reality (VR) platform: The company’s latest flagship Pixel 4 flagship phone, which Google unveiled at a press event in New York Tuesday, won’t support Google’s Daydream mobile VR platform anymore, a spokesperson confirmed to Variety. The company will also stop selling the Daydream viewer, but continue to [...]

  • Clement Miserez, Matthieu Warter

    Mediawan Acquires French Production Banner Radar Films (EXCLUSIVE)

    Mediawan has acquired a majority stake in Radar Films, the French production company behind “Belle and Sebastian,” one of France’s most successful family movie franchises. Headed by Clement Miserez and Matthieu Warter, Radar Films has been producing French and English-language films, teaming up with France’s top studios, including Gaumont and SND. Besides “Belle et Sebastien” [...]

  • 'Grease' Spinoff Series Ordered at HBO

    'Grease' Spinoff Series Ordered at HBO Max

    HBO Max is clearly hopelessly devoted to “Grease.” The streamer has issued a straight to series order for “Grease: Rydell High,” a spinoff of the original John Travolta and Olivia Newton John 1978 musical. The new series will be set in and around the world of Rydell High, the school which Danny and Sandy attended [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content