The Carpetbagger’s Children

When Horton Foote's latest work premiered at Houston's Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept in, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote's memory play, though not void of possibility, remains too flimsily built to float.

With:
Cornelia - Roberta Maxwell Grace Anne - Jean Stapleton Sissie - Hallie Foote

When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, though not void of possibility, remains too flimsily built to float.

Structured as a series of monologues delivered to no one in particular, the work (calling it a play would seem to presume some minimal onstage activity) concerns three aged sisters living in the familiar Foote territory of a small Texas town. They are the daughters of the titular carpetbagger, and, as such, have inherited a large, ill-gotten plantation. They each suffer the sins of their imperious father: One is a disinherited prodigal, another a dazed naif, the third a lovelorn spinster.

For reasons never made entirely clear, the sisters are compelled to divulge their entire family history, replete with endless prattling about clothes and food and money. As characters, they may actually ring too true: Listening to this deluge is like being cornered by your least favorite aunt in triplicate.

This production’s director, Michael Wilson — who recently moved from the Alley to become artistic director of the Hartford Stage Co. — follows the playwright’s undramatic bent, leaving the stage empty but for the actors and some furniture. Like Foote’s writing, the staging strips away all artifice.

The problem, though, is that there’s nothing underneath to hold the play up — it’s a blob of character without a dramatic skeleton.

“The Carpetbagger’s Children” is modeled after Chekhov’s “Three Sisters,” and the theme is superficially similar (the frustrations and impacted desires of provincial life). But Chekhov made his arguments about vanity and survival manifest onstage. It may not matter if his three sisters make it to Moscow or the Ranevskys manage to keep their cherry orchard; their struggle endures. Foote, in contrast, gives no sense that anything is at stake; we’re never sure what these women want, and so never sure of what they’ve lost.

Absent any narrative thrust, it’s up to the high-profile cast to give “The Carpetbagger’s Children” a shove. Jean Stapleton has a winning earthiness, but her role, as the prodigal daughter, offers only intermittent opportunity to display her comic gifts. Roberta Maxwell as the faithful Cornelia fares worse, stumbling over lines she’s been delivering for two months. If this is an affectation, it’s particularly ill-suited to the play’s naturalism; people generally don’t forget what they’re saying when they’re chatting about themselves.

Only Hallie Foote, as Sissie, the “baby” of the brood, seems to be at home inside her character (the playwright’s daughter, she’s also the best of the trio in managing the Texas accent). Yet the play’s aimlessness also seems to sabotage her performance: Just when Sissie is getting interesting, she’s abruptly killed. It’s indicative of the whole exercise: “The Carpetbagger’s Children” may sound like life, but, as drama, it’s dead in the water.

The Carpetbagger's Children

Guthrie Lab, Minneapolis; 400 Seats; $30 Top

Production: A Guthrie Lab presentation, with the Alley Theater and Hartford Stage Co., of a play in one act by Horton Foote. Directed by Michael Wilson.

Creative: Sets, Jeff Cowie; costumes, David Woolard; lighting, Rui Rita; sound, John Gromada; stage manager, Amy Knotts. Opened, reviewed Aug. 8, 2001. Running time: 1 HOUR, 30 MIN.

Cast: Cornelia - Roberta Maxwell Grace Anne - Jean Stapleton Sissie - Hallie Foote

More Legit

  • Allelujah! review

    London Theater Review: 'Allelujah!' by Alan Bennett

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • A Monster Calls review

    London Theater Review: 'A Monster Calls'

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants

    'Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants' Stage Musical in the Works

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • Joe Morton

    Joe Morton, Daphne Rubin-Vega Among Rebel Verses Guest Performers (EXCLUSIVE)

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • The Lehman Trilogy review

    London Theater Review: 'The Lehman Trilogy,' Directed by Sam Mendes

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • elizabeth perkins First Time in Variety

    Elizabeth Perkins on Her Early Film, Stage Roles

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

  • 'Mary Page Marlowe' Review: Tatiana Maslany

    Off Broadway Review: 'Mary Page Marlowe'

    When Horton Foote’s latest work premiered at Houston’s Alley Theater in June, it proved a literal washout: Tropical storm Allison swept through town, leaving the Alley partially submerged. To judge from that production, which is stopping in Minneapolis en route to Hartford, Conn., Allison may have been trying to make a point. Foote’s memory play, […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content