The Trumpet of the Swan

The second E.B. White children's classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall, "The Trumpet of the Swan" is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted readers since its 1970 publication, but bland animated musical offers little to charm adults with fond memories of the book, and even tykes are likely to become bored by the halfway point.

With:
Voices: Father - Jason Alexander Mother - Mary Steenburgen Serena - Reese Witherspoon Boyd - Seth Green Mrs. Hammerbotham - Carol Burnett Monty - Joe Mantegna Sam Beever - Sam Gifaldi Louie - Dee Baker Billie - Melissa Disney

The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted readers since its 1970 publication, but bland animated musical offers little to charm adults with fond memories of the book, and even tykes are likely to become bored by the halfway point. This “Swan” is unlikely to ruffle any box office feathers.

Co-director Richard Rich and his producing team should know a few things about swans; they were responsible for the animated “Swan Princess” trilogy several years ago. One might have hoped the magical ingredient missing from those efforts would have been supplied here by E.B. White. Unfortunately, even a solid cast and a mostly intact plotline can’t supply it.

The birth of cygnet Louie (“Louis” in the book) without a voice dismays his proud father (Jason Alexander) and leads to cruel teasing from the rest of the flock. Yearning to fit in and to communicate his love to the beautiful Serena (Reese Witherspoon), Louie (Dee Baker) flies away and learns to read and write, courtesy of human friend Sam (Sam Gifaldi) and Sam’s schoolteacher (Carol Burnett). Returning triumphantly to his lake, however, Louie finds the written word’s no good with other swans, and he’s back to square one.

Only after his father presents him with a stolen trumpet is Louie finally able to find a voice. It comes at a price, though, as the father is racked with guilt over the theft. Determined to restore his dad’s honor, Louie wings to Boston and becomes a hit jazz musician, returning home just in time to stop Serena’s wedding to rival swan Boyd (Seth Green) and to repay his father’s debt.

Pic is as by-the-numbers as the synopsis makes it sound, and its episodic nature makes it feel unfocused — not a good idea when aiming at 5-year-olds. Vocal cast is OK, though Alexander hams it up a little too much as the father swan with a very strong sense of self.

Animation is lacking in rich detail, looking not much more imaginative than standard TV fare.

Element that most inexcusably misses the mark is the soundtrack. Louie’s jazz riffs on the trumpet are generally well devised and well played, but rest of score sorely lacks an emotional focus that could have played a key role in the storytelling. As it is, score mixes many musical styles and themes, some of them maddeningly bland. Songs, too, are unmemorable, even one called “Louie Louie Louie” that is performed by Little Richard.

The Trumpet of the Swan

Production: A Sony Pictures Release. Produced by Lin Oliver. Executive producer, Seldon O. Young. Co-producers, Richard Rich, Thomas J. Tobin, Terry L. Noss. Directed by Richard Rich, Terry L. Noss. Screenplay, Judy Rothman Rofe, based on the book by E.B. White.

Crew: Editor, Joseph L. Campana; supervising editor, James D. Koford; music, Marcus Miller; character designers, Elena Kravets, Bronwen Barry; effects & computer animation, Brian McSweeney; layout design supervisor, Mike Hodgson; background supervisor, Jeff Richards; casting, Katy Wallin-Sandalis, Bernie Van De Yacht. Reviewed at Sunset Screening Room, L.A., May 2, 2001. MPAA Rating: G. Running time: 75 MIN.

With: Voices: Father - Jason Alexander Mother - Mary Steenburgen Serena - Reese Witherspoon Boyd - Seth Green Mrs. Hammerbotham - Carol Burnett Monty - Joe Mantegna Sam Beever - Sam Gifaldi Louie - Dee Baker Billie - Melissa Disney

More Film

  • Stanley Kubrick Arriflex

    Found: Stanley Kubrick's Lost Screenplay, 'Burning Secret'

    The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted […]

  • Director Hirokazu Kore-eda holds the Palme

    Juliette Binoche, Ethan Hawke Confirmed for Hirokazu Kore-eda’s ‘Verite’

    The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted […]

  • STX Targeting August IPO in Hong

    STX Targeting August IPO in Hong Kong (Report)

    The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted […]

  • ANT-MAN AND THE WASP

    Korea Box Office: ‘Ant-Man’ Stays Bigger Than ‘Skyscraper’

    The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted […]

  • China Box Office: 'Dying' Holds off

    China Box Office: 'Dying to Survive' Scores $69 Million, Holds Off 'Hidden Man'

    The second E.B. White children’s classic to reach theaters in recent years, and the third overall (after “Stuart Little” and “Charlotte’s Web”), “The Trumpet of the Swan” is undoubtedly the weakest. Its story of a mute trumpeter swan who learns to read, write and play the trumpet in order to express his feelings has delighted […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content