Out of the Closet, Off the Screen: The William Haines Story

One of the "forgotten" stars of Hollywood's Golden Age, William Haines, has edged back into public consciousness due to William J. Mann's biography "Wisecracker." That tome now has a spinoff from Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato. Results are not an ideal match, but featurette should whet appetites for revival of Haines' long-unseen pictures.

William Haines - Christopher Lawford Jimmy Shields - Chris Allen Older Haines - Herb Gore Older Shields - Bob Wildman Narrator - Stockard Channing

One of the biggest “forgotten” stars of Hollywood’s Golden Age, William Haines, has edged back into public consciousness due to William J. Mann’s biography “Wisecracker.” That tome now has a short screen spinoff from Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato, the docu duo whose prior efforts (“Party Monster,” “The Real Ellen Story,” “The Eyes of Tammy Faye”) anticipated this one only in the vague overlap of gay/camp/scandalous terrain. Results are not an ideal match, but AMC-produced featurette should whet appetites for revival of Haines’ long-unseen pictures.

Commissioned to fit a 45-minute timeslot, docu expectedly suffers (especially in comparison to Mann’s thorough book) from lack of breathing room. Some simplifications seem inevitable, while others — most notably the recasting of Haines as a martyr to “born again” Hollywood homophobia — are over-rigged to reflect current attitudes rather than Haines’ own milieu. The book finds much less evidential certainty that Haines’ career was sabotaged by Louis B. Mayer solely because the star refused to dump his male lover for a “beard” marriage.

Glossed over here to support the victim scenario are the headaches that Haines’ oft-wild carousing (and lifelong heavy drinking) caused studio PR flaks and legal reps, among other less than flattering characteristics.

Nonetheless, his was a classic Hollywood Cinderella story. The black-sheep progeny of a wealthy Virginia family, Billy fled the manse at an early age to live large — landing smack in tres gay Greenwich Village just as the Roaring ’20s were revving up. (His roommate for a time was one Archibald Leach, later known as Cary Grant.) Haines’ good looks and breezy manner caught a film agent’s eye, which promptly led to passage westward.

Haines hit his screen stride as “Brown of Harvard” (1926), the first of many comedy-dramas in which he played callow, cocksure collegians invariably redeemed in the last reel by a stiff dose of go-getting resolve, the Girl’s love and some healthy humble pie. Combining romantic lead appeal with an all-American delight at deflating pretense (not least his own), Haines was hugely popular, topping numerous exhibitor as well as fan polls through 1930.

Despite that gold-plated record, Haines chafed at his copycat Metro assignments, while the studio fretted over his fluctuating girth, fits of temperament, over-the-top partying and less-than-discreet domestic partnership with Jimmy Shields, a fey ex-sailor he’d met in NYC. (Joan Crawford, befriended by Haines well before she reached stardom, later pronounced the men’s half-century relationship “the happiest marriage in Hollywood.”)

Prudish boss Mayer was no fan, and when Haines’ box office clout appeared to ebb, the mogul reportedly seized the moment to give his contractee an ultimatum: Get a “real” wife and lose the she-male, or else. Haines refused, making his final feature (for a Poverty Row studio) in 1935.

Like his contemporary, “It Girl” Clara Bow, Haines was pegged as a limited talent suitable only for the assembly-line formula pics an effervescent personality could juice with surefire zip. Having already weathered the silents-to-talkies changeover, thesp might easily have found a berth in later 1930s products — Lee Tracy-type roles in screwball comedies or Warner Bros. backstage musicals would have been ideal.

Yet he seems to have suffered little in the demotion to civilian life. Building on an amateur passion, he became the leading “Hollywood Regency” stylist of interior decor for socialites from Carole Lombard to Nancy Reagan.

“Out of the Closet” strains to view its subject as a rebel who lived a truly authentic life. The reality was more complex: Money, privilege and a tacit “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy among A-list cronies (Reagans included) made Haines and other gay stars immune to censure, so long as their proclivities remained private. (Before his 1973 demise, he supposedly voiced disgust at the new phenom of out-and-proud “gay libbers.”) His drunken, promiscuous offscreen escapades (continuing well after Shields moved in) attracted police attention more than once, a fact as likely key to his MGM fall as the potential gay-cohabitation scandal.

One wishes that in “Out of the Closet” more attention had been paid to Haines’ short but heady first career and less to his hindsight “heroism.” Unfortunately, docu’s budget couldn’t accommodate MGM’s costly film library, so clips showing Haines in screen action are in short supply. The few on tap suggest a dashing, self-mocking comic persona worth reassessment.

Decision to deploy actor Christopher Lawford as a middle-aged Haines looking back on life is more distancing than engaging; this arch bitch-quipper comes off like a stock character on AMC’s fiction series “The Lot.” Commentators range from the insightful (biographer Mann, Christina Crawford) to the irrelevant (latter-day gossip Michael Musto). Stockard Channing’s narration sounds like an uninterested rush job.

Lamentably, helmers use wholly inappropriate techno-style music throughout, with scarcely a period tune soundtracked.

Popular on Variety

Out of the Closet, Off the Screen: The William Haines Story


Production: A World of Wonder production for American Movie Classics. Produced by Randy Barbato, Fenton Bailey, David Schiff. Executive producers, Marc Juris, Jessica Falcon. Co-producer, Joan Cohen. Directed by Fenton Bailey, Randy Barbato. Screenplay, Gabriel Rotello, based on the book "Wisecracker: The Life & Times of William Haines, Hollywood's First Openly Gay Star" by William J. Mann.

Crew: Camera (color, video), Teodoro Maniaci; editor, Jeremy Simmons; music, Derek Brin; production designer, Scott Storey; sound, Jan Schulte. Reviewed at San Francisco Lesbian & Gay Film Festival, June 17, 2001. Running time: 44 MIN.

With: William Haines - Christopher Lawford Jimmy Shields - Chris Allen Older Haines - Herb Gore Older Shields - Bob Wildman Narrator - Stockard Channing

More Film

  • Fiddler A Miracle of Miracles

    Film Review: 'Fiddler: A Miracle of Miracles'

    Still beloved and routinely revived 55 years after its Broadway debut — including a Yiddish-language version now playing in New York — “Fiddler on the Roof” is a popular phenomenon that shows no sign of subsiding. Max Lewkowicz’s “Fiddler: A Miracle of Miracles” provides an entertaining if hardly exhaustive overview of how the unlikely success [...]

  • 'Weathering With You' Heads for $100

    'Weathering With You' Heads for $100 Million Box Office Haul

    Makoto Shinkai’s animated romantic drama “Weathering with You” passed the JPY10 billion ($94 million) mark in Japan on Wednesday, according to an announcement by distributor Toho. This makes it the tenth-highest earning Japanese film of all time. Since its release on July 19 on 448 screens in 359 complexes, the film has racked up 7.52 million admissions. The [...]

  • Burn review

    Film Review: 'Burn'

    There’s more smoke than fire in “Burn,” a reasonably promising single-location thriller that never quite settles on what it wants to be — a straight-up suspense piece, twisty black comedy, oddball character study, etc. “All the above” would be a tall but not impossible order to pull off. The problem is that writer-director Mike Gan’s [...]

  • Rounds

    Sarajevo Film Review: 'Rounds'

    Five features (plus a scattering of documentaries) into his career, leading Bulgarian writer-director Stephan Komandarev has resisted cultivating a clear thematic or stylistic throughline to his oeuvre. Yet his latest, the overnight police patchwork “Rounds,” feels surprisingly close to quintessential, pulling as it does plot points, structural models and tonal switches from his previous films [...]

  • Travis Scott Surprises Fans With Netflix

    Travis Scott Surprises Fans With Netflix Documentary Reveal, Pop-Up in Houston

    Travis Scott just revealed his new Netflix documentary in the most organic way possible: a social media post to his 18.5 million followers on Instagram. The photo consisted of him holding a series of VHS tapes, which turns out to be the trailer for his forthcoming documentary on Netflix titled “Look Mom I Can Fly.” [...]

  • Overcomer

    Film Review: 'Overcomer'

    No matter the setting or circumstances, the solution to every dilemma found in Christian Evangelical films is getting closer to God. That certainly holds true with regards to “Overcomer,” the latest bit of bigscreen proselytizing by writer-director-star Alex Kendrick (“War Room,” “Courageous”). The story of a high school basketball coach who’s forced to take over [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Inside the Spider-Man Split: Finger-Pointing and Executive Endgames

    Spider-Man’s neighborhood has been decidedly unfriendly this week. A private and contentious battle over the onscreen future of the beloved Marvel superhero has spilled out into the public square over the past few days. After making nice for two wildly successful films, Sony Pictures, which holds the licensing rights to the Marvel character, will go [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content