×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

One Man Up

A small scale but absorbing twin character study powered by two compelling performances, "One Man Up" tracks the parallel lives of two men from Naples in the cynical, amoral '80s as they are elevated to positions of public glory then coldly cast aside by society.

With:
Tony - Toni Servillo Antonio Pisapia - Andrea Renzi Il Molosso - Nello Mascia Genny - Ninni Bruschetta Franca - Angela Goodwin Elena - Enrica Rosso Salvatore - Peppe Lanzetta Interviewer - Roberto De Francesco

A small scale but absorbing twin character study powered by two compelling performances, “One Man Up” tracks the parallel lives of two men from Naples in the cynical, amoral ’80s as they are elevated to positions of public glory then coldly cast aside by society. While Paolo Sorrentino’s writing is more refined than his direction, this is an intelligent, thematically ambitious first feature by Italian standards, and should play festivals and open doors for the Neapolitan newcomer. Produced by some of the same team that launched Mario Martone’s film career with “Death of a Neapolitan Mathematician,” the drama was the swan song project of American-born producer-distributor Kermit Smith, who died in April.

In terms of the depth with which it explores the identically named main characters, Sorrentino’s original script has something of the density and complexity of a novel. As the 1980s begin, both men seem to have the world at their feet but both are destined for a fall.

One is Tony Pisapia (Toni Servillo) a cocaine-addled cheesy club singer, whose moment in the spotlight with a triumphant concert segues to disgrace when he’s caught in bed with an underage girl and publicly crucified.

The other is Antonio Pisapia (Andrea Renzi), an ace professional soccer player whose crucial goal in a big match makes him a hero, but whose torn ligaments force him off the team, beginning a long, frustrated quest to carve a career as a coach.

Both men are quintessentially Italian public figures — based on singer Franco Califano and footballer Agostino Di Bartolomei — and this undoubtedly will limit offshore audiences’ access to the story. But while it takes too long to establish the slightly schematic juxtaposition of two seemingly distant but ultimately similar lives, and then to intersect the parallels, Sorrentino’s script turns enough unexpected corners to keep the drama intriguing.

Skipping forward to 1984, Toni and Antonio both struggle to get back on their feet, not helped by the ambiguous, self-serving figures around them. Even Antonio’s initially sympathetic wife loses patience and abandons him. But both men continue to fight the obstacles and pursue their dream of dignity and achievement until their paths cross briefly, signaling a moment of truth.

Despite the melancholy nature of this story, the film maintains a tone that is sober and reflective without becoming maudlin, making original observations about the nature of celebrity and success, ambition and failure. While Sorrentino’s direction is often awkward — some dream sequences are especially cumbersome — and his grasp of narrative flow erratic, the drama steadily gains momentum and forcefulness as its themes coalesce. Sole weak technical link in the modest production is an insistent, overbearing music score.

As is frequently the case with Neapolitan cinema, some of the supporting cast tend to be too stridently emphatic, but the two measured central performances are full of depth and subtle nuance. Renzi quietly conveys the sorrow of a timid, unassuming man acutely aware of his failings, while Servillo, in the showier role, pairs brash swagger and self-importance with humor, generosity, expansiveness and an understated pathetic side that keeps Toni human until the final act revelation that he too has a soul.

Popular on Variety

One Man Up

Italy

Production: A Key Films release of a Key Films/Mediatrade presentation of an Indigo Film/Key Films production in association with Telepiu. Produced by Nicola Giuliano, Kermit Smith, Francesca Cima, Angelo Curti. Directed, written by Paolo Sorrentino.

Crew: Camera (color), Pasquale Mari; editor, Giogio Franchini; music, Pasquale Catalano; art director, Lino Fiorito; costume designer, Silvia Nebiolo; sound (Dolby Digital), Daghi Rondanini, Gianluca Costamagna; assistant director, Enzo Di Terlizi. Reviewed at Cinecitta, Rome, July 31, 2001. (In Venice Film Festival -- competing.) Running time: 103 MIN.

With: Tony - Toni Servillo Antonio Pisapia - Andrea Renzi Il Molosso - Nello Mascia Genny - Ninni Bruschetta Franca - Angela Goodwin Elena - Enrica Rosso Salvatore - Peppe Lanzetta Interviewer - Roberto De FrancescoWith: Marzio Honorato, Italo Celoro, Clotilde Sabatino, Beniamino Femiano, Stefania Barca, Toni Laudadio, Rosaria De Cicco, Monica Nappo.

More Film

  • Paramount Movie Theater Paramount Consent Decree

    Why Eliminating the Paramount Antitrust Decrees Won't Shake Up the Movie Business

    The Paramount Decrees have been the rules of the road for Hollywood since the golden age of movies, but the Justice Department’s decision to do away with directives that were hammered out decades before the rise of cable or streaming has barely registered within the entertainment industry. That’s because they are widely seen as anachronisms [...]

  • Kristen Bell Frozen 2

    'Frozen 2' Cast Weighs in: Should Elsa Have a Girlfriend?

    The cast of Disney’s “Frozen 2” gave their two cents on whether or not Princess Elsa should one day find a girlfriend in any of the future films. The idea has been a hopeful wish of fans due to Elsa’s lack of a male love interest in “Frozen” or its sequel. At the movie’s red [...]

  • the two popes

    How Luca Canfora Recreated The Papal Vestments for 'The Two Popes'

    Luca Canfora is no stranger to designing papal vestments; his previous projects include “The Young Pope” and “The New Pope.” Coming into Fernando Meirelles’ “The Two Popes” meant Canfora knew where he could have costumes made with the highest quality, and when it came to fabric choice and constructing his costumes. Canfora had to create [...]

  • Pom Klementieff poses at the launch

    Pom Klementieff Lands New Role in Next 'Mission: Impossible' Film

    “Guardians of the Galaxy” star Pom Klementieff is set to join the latest installment of Paramount and Skydance’s “Mission: Impossible,” joining Tom Cruise, who is reprising his role of Ethan Hunt. Christopher McQuarrie announced the news on Instagram on Tuesday, and is returning to write and direct the seventh and eighth movies, which will be [...]

  • Fede Alvarez

    'Don't Breathe' Director Fede Alvarez Developing White House Horror Movie With Legendary

    “Don’t Breathe” director-producer Fede Alvarez is teaming with Legendary Pictures for an untitled White House horror movie. The project, described as “The Shining” set in the White House, will be directed by Alvarez from a script by Joe Epstein and produced by Alvarez’s Bad Hombre Films. Legendary announced the horror movie Tuesday as part of [...]

  • Awkwafina Actors on Actors

    How 'The Farewell' Changed Awkwafina's Understanding of Grief and Mercy

    Awkwafina’s film “The Farewell” explores the Chinese tradition of not disclosing terminal illnesses to elderly family members. The actor discussed her evolving thought process on the subject matter with Taron Egerton (“Rocketman”) during a conversation for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” Egerton began the interview by asking Awkwafina about her personal opinion of the film’s [...]

  • Kristen Bell and idina menzel Walk

    Kristen Bell and Idina Menzel Took Parallel Paths to Hollywood

    Once upon a time in New York City, two young talents set off on a near-impossible quest: a successful Broadway career. Since childhood, Idina Menzel and Kristen Bell had focused on their quest with a ferocious drive — and learned to avoid the trolls. In Long Island, Menzel, the daughter of a pajama salesman, spent [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content