×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

I’d Rather Be … Gone

Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy "I'd Rather Be ... Gone" watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux's vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer.

With:
With: Maria Breaux, Amy Kelly, Csilla Horvath, June Sparagna, Sarah Fatemi, Marisol McIlvain, Aaron McIlvain, Bob Martinez.

Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal cassette and gay fest exposure is signaled.

Writer-helmer plays Michelle, a San Franciscan in midlife crisis over her boring computer programmer job and live-in g.f.’s recent walkout. Taking a month’s sabbatical to regroup, she soon finds her one-bedroom apartment invaded by even needier women: First “temporarily” homeless, substance-abusive chaos magnet Rocky (Csilla Horvath), then closeted schoolteacher April (Amy Kelly), who’s just blown her own employment/relationship security. Trio eventually road-trip to L.A., the journey presumably (if murkily) shaking each from individual paralysis.

It’s anyone’s guess why Michelle lets these two wreck her much-needed solitude or, indeed, why they’re friends at all — by personality-clashing nature, all three annoy one another no end. Horvath’s droll nut case and Kelly’s Kay Ballard-like loudmouth have inspired moments, as do several supporting players. But Kelly (who developed story with Breaux) often seems to be acting in a much broader comedy of her own, while pic’s meandering, anecdotal setpieces lead to no deeper character insight or narrative payoff. Results are more trivial than the many incidental laughs can compensate for. Next time out, one hopes promising talent Breaux relies less on improv and more on brass-tacks screenplay structuring. Shoestring production’s tech aspects are OK.

I'd Rather Be ... Gone

Production: A Ragamuff production. Produced, directed, screenplay by Maria Breaux.

Crew: Camera (color, HD video), Aaron McIlvain, Tonje Hoel; editor, Marisol McIlvain; costume designer, Cynthia Billops; sound, Aaron McIlvain, Jim Granato. Reviewed at San Francisco Lesbian & Gay Film Festival, June 22, 2001. Running time: 112 MIN.

With: With: Maria Breaux, Amy Kelly, Csilla Horvath, June Sparagna, Sarah Fatemi, Marisol McIlvain, Aaron McIlvain, Bob Martinez.

More Film

  • Colombia’s Macondo Academy Award Winners, 2018

    ‘Killing Jesus’ Wins Big at Colombia’s 2018 Macondo Academy Awards

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • ‘Free Solo’ Tops Kendal Mountain Festival,

    ‘Free Solo’ Tops Kendal Mountain Festival

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • Olivier Awards 2016

    Judi Dench to Be Honored at British Independent Film Awards

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • ‘Act of Killing’s’ Final Cut for

    Frida and Lasse Barkfors Pitch 'School Shooters' At IDFA Forum

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • IDFA: ‘Dawn’ Director Carmen Torres on

    IDFA: Colombia’s Carmen Torres’ Talks IDFA Doc ‘Dawn’

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • VENOM

    China Box Office: 'Venom' Enjoys Spectacular $87 Million Second Weekend

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

  • Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald

    Korea Box Office: 'Fantastic Beasts' Beats 'Bohemian Rhapsody' and Burns 'BTS'

    Quirky, unpredictable humor keeps the indie lesbian seriocomedy “I’d Rather Be … Gone” watchable until it becomes clear no master plan exists to tie together the very loose, multicharacter strands. An intriguing sensibility bubbles beneath Maria Breaux’s vid-shot feature, but by the end its utter lack of plot momentum and focus exhausts viewer goodwill. Marginal […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content