×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Par plays crix hardball

Studio lays down law with New York weeklies

NEW YORK — Paramount is apparently playing hardball with several New York-based weekly publications, tightening its policy against publishing reviews until a film’s opening day.

Nearly all Gotham-based weeklies — Entertainment Weekly, New York magazine, the New York Observer, the New Yorker, Newsweek, Rolling Stone, Time Out, US Weekly and the Village Voice — reported having received phone calls in the last few weeks from Par publicity exec Tom Phillips.What the mags notified have in common is that they hit the newsstands prior to Fridays — New York magazine, the New Yorker and Newsweek all come out on Mondays, Time Out and the Voice on Tuesdays, for example.

Each of these mags regularly prints a mix of reviews of films opening on the previous, as well as on the following, Friday. EW will likely suffer least. As the bulk of its issues appear on Friday, it will be allowed to run reviews of that day’s openers.

People magazine, which is also published on Fridays, was apparently spared the edict entirely. But the rest, according to Par’s demand, were to begin holding their reviews until the following week.

“We’ve been told that they don’t want us to review their movies the week they open,” US Weekly associate editor and film critic Andrew Johnston told Daily Variety.

The New Yorker’s David Denby, who received the message on his voicemail, said, “In effect, we were told, ‘Review it after it opens or don’t review it at all.’ ”

Par’s policy contrasts with that at most other studios, which simply request that publications print reviews shortly before the film’s opening — anywhere between one and five days in advance is the standard.

But Par exec VP of worldwide publicity Nancy Kirkpatrick denied that the studio’s policy was new. “Our review policy always has been for reviews to break opening day. There has been no change in that policy,” she said.

The critics claim otherwise.

Village Voice film editor Dennis Lim said that he first learned of the embargo edict a few days after he’d closed the Voice’s July 6 film section, which included his own negative review of “The Score.” Message came from Par’s Phillips, who told Lim — too late, in any case — that the review should not be run until the week after opening day, Friday, July 13.

Warning issued

Time Out critic Mike D’Angelo also said he was first informed of the policy while planning a review of “The Score.” He said that Phillips gave him access to the screening but issued a caveat, which D’Angelo related as follows: “I need to inform you that there is a blanket policy that all the reviews are embargoed” until the week following opening day.

Time Out respected the embargo, but then was annoyed to see the Voice’s review run on time.

Phillips subsequently left messages for a number of New York pubs about a specific embargo on “Rat Race” — for which Par is holding an all-media screening Aug. 1, in advance of its Aug. 17 release date.

The message left at the Voice, according to Lim, implied “that we will be struck off the Paramount screening list if we break their rules again.”

According to Variety‘s weekly Crix Picks tally, Par movies have not done significantly worse among New York critics in recent years than have the wide releases of the other major studios and have had a comparable number of critical successes — “The Score,” “The Talented Mr. Ripley,” “Rugrats in Paris” and “Wonder Boys,” for example.For the present, response to the Par embargo policy among critics ranged from honoring it, as long as all publications did so, to posting an opening day review on the Web, to taking it on a case-by-case basis, to ignoring it entirely.

Popular on Variety

More Film

  • 42west logo

    42West Co-CEO Allan Mayer Hospitalized After Car Accident

    42West Co-CEO Allan Mayer is in the hospital due to injuries from an Oct. 17 car accident, Variety has confirmed. The public relations firm described the crash as “serious” and said that he had surgery on Oct. 20 to help repair multiple broken bones. “Allan and his family thank everyone for the outpouring of love and [...]

  • Iron Man Martin Scorsese Francis Ford

    Directors vs. Marvel: A Breakdown of the Criticism

    Despite being the highest-grossing film franchise of all time, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has not been getting any love from critically renowned auteurs, like Martin Scorsese and Francis Ford Coppola. The Marvel pile-on started at the beginning of October and has impassioned many supporters and detractors to give their two cents on whether or not [...]

  • Linda Hamilton, left, and Arnold Schwarzenegger

    Film Review: 'Terminator: Dark Fate'

    Back in 1984, seven years before “The Terminator” spawned a sequel that was big, sprawling, and James Cameron-y enough to elevate the franchise into what felt like the dystopian Marvel spectacle of its day, it’s worth noting that Cameron’s original film was a ruthlessly efficient post-apocalyptic B-movie — a proto-video-game sci-fi nightmare that took its [...]

  • Mountaintop

    Film Review: Neil Young's 'Mountaintop'

    If you ever wished you could be a fly on the wall at a Neil Young recording session, his new film “Mountaintop” may put that desire to the test. Or at least it’ll severely try the patience of any unsuspecting dates who get dragged along by Young fanatics to the movie’s one night in North [...]

  • Universal Screens 'Bride of Frankenstein,' Releases

    Universal Screens 'Bride of Frankenstein,' Releases Franz Waxman Score for First Time

    Halloween is only days away, and what better way to celebrate than with a classic monster movie that’s been fully restored and whose original score has, 84 years later, finally been issued as a soundtrack album? Universal screened its 1935 “Bride of Frankenstein” Monday night to an appreciative audience on the studio lot, following a [...]

  • Adam Driver'Marriage Story' photocall, 76th Venice

    Adam Driver in Talks to Join Matt Damon in Ridley Scott's 'Last Duel' (EXCLUSIVE)

    Adam Driver is in early talks to co-star opposite Matt Damon in Disney-Fox’s “The Last Duel,” a period drama from director Ridley Scott. Sources tell Variety that Ben Affleck, who originally eyed what would be Driver’s leading role, will now appear in a supporting part along with “Killing Eve” actress Jodie Comer. Set in 14th [...]

  • John Clarke dead Days of Our

    'Days of Our Lives' Star John Clarke Dies at 88

    John Clarke, best known for portraying Mickey Horton on the soap opera “Days of Our Lives,” died due to complications of pneumonia in Laguna Beach, Calif. on Oct. 16. He was 88. Clarke suffered a stroke in 2007 and had been in a state of deteriorating health over the past few years. His daughter, Melinda, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content