×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Mickey Mouse math

Biz reports on Disney year add up (almost)

Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down?

You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider:

  • The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney Profit Jumps 8.6%, Amid Cost Cuts.”

  • Daily Variety painted an entirely different headline picture: “Despite pix perfs, Disney profits drop.” And the drop was a steep 26%.

  • The Los Angeles Times took the middle road, reporting a 3% drop in profit for the quarter.

  • And the New York Times, apparently trying to avoid confusion or controversy, didn’t use a percentage figure in its story at all and eventually used the numbers cited by both the Journal and the L.A. Times.

So, who was right?

Actually, everyone was, and that only points up the difficulty of making sense of earnings reports.

The WSJ used the actual reported profit for the three months ending June 30, compared with the reported profit for the three months ending June 30, 2000.

Daily Variety, on the other hand, used “pro forma” figures, which many people feel give a more accurate picture of what is happening in a company. Pro forma numbers assume that any major transaction, such as buying or selling a subsidiary or closing a division, occurred at the beginning of the periods being compared. This would eliminate, for example, a major jump in revenue if a company bought another company this year.

In Disney’s case, closure of the money-losing Go.com Internet portal, which actually occurred at the beginning of this year, is assumed to have occurred at the beginning of the company’s fiscal year 2000 — Oct. 1, 1999. The pro forma numbers make last year’s profit look larger and therefore show a larger percentage drop compared to this year.

The Los Angeles Times and the New York Times used the pro forma numbers, but excluded the cumulative effect of accounting changes, a gain on the sale of Fairchild Publications and restructuring charges.

Which is the best set of figures to use? Unfortunately, there isn’t any right answer — that’s why economics isn’t an exact science.

More Biz

  • Movie Theater

    Studios Expected to Push for Early Home Release in 2019 (EXCLUSIVE)

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • NetEase Discusses Importance of Chinese Gaming

    NetEase Discusses Importance of Chinese Gaming Regulation, Anti-Addiction Measures

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • Iggy Azalea at Hits 97.3, Fort

    Iggy Azalea Says She’s Signed a $2.7 Million Deal

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • Sheryl Sandberg

    Sheryl Sandberg: Facebook 'Absolutely Did Not Pay Anyone to Create Fake News'

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • Bob Bakish

    Viacom Q4 Profit Falls on Cable Ad Revenue Shortfall

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • New Aquatic Theme Park Opens in

    New Aquatic Theme Park Opens in Shanghai to Take On Disneyland

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

  • Amy Schumer Detained

    Amy Schumer Hospitalized for Pregnancy-Related Condition, Postpones Tour Date

    Did the Walt Disney Co.’s profit this year go up or down? You’d think that would be an easy question. But with a company as large as the Mouse House, which reported its third-quarter earnings last week, there are several ways to look at the numbers. Consider: The Wall Street Journal’s Disney headline read: “Disney […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content