You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Battery Park

Goldberg and NBC know there's a kernel of quality in "Battery Park," but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode reviewed, which airs March 30, weaves through painfully worn-out jokes in the name of exposition and then suddenly shifts gears to show off its comic, and poignant, potential.

With:
Madeline Dunleavy - Elizabeth Perkins Ben Hardin - Justin Louis Derek Finley - Bokeem Woodbine Elena Vera - Jacqueline Obradors Anthony Stigliano - Frank Grillo Kevin Strain - Robert Mailhouse Carl Zernial - Jay Paulson

NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode reviewed, which airs March 30, weaves through painfully worn-out jokes in the name of exposition and then suddenly shifts gears to show off its comic, and poignant, potential.

Ben (Justin Louis), the cop with what’s termed an annoyingly impeccable record, is smitten by Maria (Wendy Moniz), the daughter of a dead mob boss. Once they begin to date — in the middle of the show — it becomes a surveillance free-for-all that manages to bring in elements of a slew of police show predecessors: “Police Squad,” “Barney Miller” and “Hill Street Blues.” It’s in the second half of the show that “Battery Park” breaks from its fomulaic one-two of straight lines and jokes to elevate these plain-clothes members of New York City’s finest into full-fledged people.

Madeline (Elizabeth Perkins) is the overbearing commander with an ear for sarcasm and the eye of a watchful mother. She continually cautions her charges, particularly Derek (Bokeem Woodbine) and Stig (Frank Gillo), about rights and wrongs; these two overzealously blast their way through every assignment. What Madeline lacks are people skills, which opens the door for her more caring officers.

Carl (Jay Paulson) is running in a collection of hookers when he stumbles upon his high school English teacher (Michelle Clunie) — the brood’s madam. Without condemnation, he lavishes praise on her teaching skills and the effect she had on his life, while the juxtaposition of sentimentality and absurdity is resonant.

Elena (Jacqueline Obradors), meanwhile, takes pity on the squad room’s resident crime victim (Sam Lloyd as Ray) and even agrees to have dinner with him after she learns he’s a gourmet cook. Her police partner, Kevin (Robert Mailhouse), is stunned; it’s clear that he longs for a romantic diversion with her.

“Battery Park” has no interest in solving crime, and Sheriff Andy Taylor probably put more people behind bars in Mayberry than these cops ever will. To a certain degree, it’s “Sports Night” moved to a precinct. Blessed with one of the most-coveted timeslots in television, series needs to find a consistent tone to find its own audience — the second half of the second episode demonstrates that it is possible.

Battery Park

NBC, Thurs. March 23, 9:30 p.m.

Production: Taped in Studio City by UBU Prods. in association with DreamWorks Television. Executive producer, Gary David Goldberg; supervising producers, Chris Henchy, Jane O'Brien; director, Andy Cadiff.

Crew: Camera, Mikel Neiers; production designer, Michael Hynes; editor, Andy Chulack; casting, Allison Jones, Bonnie Finnegan. 30 MIN.

Cast: Madeline Dunleavy - Elizabeth Perkins Ben Hardin - Justin Louis Derek Finley - Bokeem Woodbine Elena Vera - Jacqueline Obradors Anthony Stigliano - Frank Grillo Kevin Strain - Robert Mailhouse Carl Zernial - Jay Paulson

More TV

  • New Amsterdam review

    TV Review: NBC's 'New Amsterdam'

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

  • Bill Cosby

    Bill Cosby Prosecutor Seeks 5 to 10 Years in Prison

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

  • Valley of the Boom Review

    TV Review: 'Valley of the Boom'

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

  • The Lifeboat Clique

    'Lifeboat Clique' Series Adaptation in Development at CW

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

  • Chris Evans Hailee Steinfeld Reese Witherspoon

    Star Power, Image Concerns Drive Apple's Original Content Strategy

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

  • Martin Gero participates in the "Blindspot"

    Martin Gero, Brendan Gall Land Production Commitment for Spy Drama at CBS

    NBC sent out for review the second episode of Gary David Goldberg’s cop comedy due to the reshooting of scenes in the first episode. Goldberg and NBC know there’s a kernel of quality in “Battery Park,” but getting an ensemble comedy to gel at lightning speed, even with special handling, is well nigh impossible. Episode […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content