Judge blocks ‘Net DVD copying code

2600.com, DeCSS program get permanent halt

NEW YORK — Chalk one up for the establishment in the ongoing, multi-pronged battle for control over intellectual property rights on the ‘Net.

A federal court judge in Gotham sided with the film industry Thursday in its effort to shut down online purveyors of software that can decrypt and copy content from DVDs.

In a ruling that the defendants have vowed to appeal, Judge Lewis A. Kaplan made permanent a temporary injunction against 2600.com and its author, Eric Corley, which prevents the site from providing access to a program called DeCSS.

The software, originally developed in part by a teenage hacker from Norway, is a small, easily downloadable program that lets users “unlock” DVD content and transfer it to their computers’ hard drives, from which it can be easily copied and traded.

The suit was originally filed late last year by the Motion Picture Assn. of America and eight of Hollywood’s largest film studios.

Valenti pleased

“This was, in my judgment, the most tightly reasoned, unambiguous decision I’ve read in a long time,” MPAA chief Jack Valenti told Daily Variety. “Judge Kaplan demolished every single argument posited by the defendant’s counsel.”

Corley’s defense team, headed by veteran First Amendment counsel Martin Garbus, had attacked the plaintiff’s case on several fronts. They argued that DeCSS copying constitutes a “fair use” of the technology because it allows users to make copies for personal use, like a VCR.

In an unprecedented argument that drew close scrutiny from Judge Kaplan, the defense also proposed that the DeCSS computer code itself was protected by the First Amendment as a form of speech.

However, Kaplan rejected that logic, noting that the code is “not purely expressive any more than the assassination of a political figure is purely a political statement.”

Getting around decision

In January, Judge Kaplan authorized a preliminary injunction barring 2600.com’s Corley from posting the actual DeCSS code online. Corley removed the code, but promptly posted links to foreign sites that still offered DeCSS.

The DeCSS case has been part of a larger legal offensive by both the motion picture and recording industries against online services that they claim flout the law and the rights of artists by circumventing the normal commercial channels by which artists are compensated for their work.

The recording industry’s suit against Napster is by far the most high-profile case, but a suit brought by both industries against file sharing service Scour Exchange also is likely to be impacted by Kaplan’s ruling.

Scour Exchange, which was sued last month by the Recording Industry Association of America, the MPAA and several of each group’s most prominent members, allows users to swap and download files of all types, including audio and video.

But the most important effect of the suits may be that venture capitalists and other high-profile sources of capital will likely steer clear of the controversial file-sharing services, argued the MPAA’s Valenti.

Funding essential

Without major financial backing, the sites will never be able to facilitate operations on the same scale as a service like Napster, which claims more than 20 million members, he said.

“Their funding will be drying up and there will be fewer of them until eventually they disappear,” he predicted.

David Atlas, an attorney for the defense, said he was “not entirely surprised” by the ruling, intimating that Kaplan appeared to have been swayed by the plaintiff’s arguments early on in the case.

“The plaintiffs painted our guys as hackers and thieves, when in fact they are journalists,” he contended. “I think the judge bought into that.”

Atlas also expressed disappointment in the rejection of the fair use defense, noting that when VHS tapes “go the way of the eight-track,” consumers will have no way to copy video content for personal use.

The decision “just allows copyright holders to expand their existing monopoly,” he said.

More Digital

  • FaceApp is displayed on an iPhone,

    SAG-AFTRA Warns Members About FaceApp Terms of Use

    SAG-AFTRA is warning its 160,000 members about the “overreaching and invasive” terms of use for the FaceApp mobile application. FaceApp, developed by Russian company Wireless Lab, uses neural network technology to automatically generate transformations of faces in photographs. The app can be used to make users appear older, younger, or change gender. The terms include [...]

  • J. Cole

    Apple Music Launches 'Rap Life' Playlist

    Apple Music announced the launch of “Rap Life,” a new global playlist focusing on contemporary rap artists and culture. It replaces the former “The A-List: Hip-Hop” playlist. Said Ebro Darden, Apple Music’s Global Editorial Head of Hip-Hop and R&B: “We flipped it to dig deeper into into the lifestyle [and to] keep pushing the culture [...]

  • Billie Eilish

    ARRI, Mobile TV Group Back New Venture Revitalizing Streamed Concerts

    A new venture looking to bring a fresh approach to live-streaming concerts has gotten the backing of hardware heavyweights ARRI and Mobile TV Group. Wide+Close is launching with the mandate of shooting music performances with film cameras and cinematographers in order to give the content a more cinematic feel. “We want to take concert filming [...]

  • Fortnite Battle Royale

    How 'Fortnite' Fans Can Earn Loot by Watching YouTube Videos

    Epic Games and YouTube have teamed up with a special offer for “Fortnite” players — giving players of the popular battle-royale game rewards when they watch “Fortnite”-premiered content on the video platform. The catch: You have to watch at least 20 minutes of “Fortnite” special content or live esports broadcasts to receive the loot. Under [...]

  • Roku headquarters

    Roku Plans to Expand to Brazil, Other Countries (EXCLUSIVE)

    Roku plans to expand to multiple new territories in the coming months, Variety has learned. One of the first new markets for the company will likely be Brazil. An international expansion could help Roku grow its customer base, which in turn should lead to growing advertising revenues. Roku executives have been hinting at plans to [...]

  • Google Stadia Pro to Include 1

    Google’s Stadia Game Streaming Service to Include Free Monthly Game

    Google has been busy sharing additional details about its upcoming game streaming service Stadia, clearing up some confusion in the process. Stadia’s pro subscription tier, which will cost $10 per month, won’t be a Netflix-type subscription service. However, subscribers will get free games at the rate of about a title per month. That’s according to [...]

  • Crypt-TV-Facebook

    Facebook Signs Deal With Crypt TV for Slate of Five Horror Series

    Crypt TV, the digital studio founded by Eli Roth and Jack Davis and backed by Jason Blum, expanded its deal with Facebook, inking a content partnership to create a slate of five horror and monster-themed series exclusively for Facebook Watch. For Facebook Watch, it’s one of the first deals for a full slate of content [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content