You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Besson story ‘Arc’ inflames scribe

Maxwell calls pic 'ultimate ego trip'

HOLLYWOOD — Critics often dump on historical films for fudging the truth, but Luc Besson’s latest version of the Joan of Arc story takes the cake.

So says screenwriter-director Ronald Maxwell (“Gettysburg”), who has been readying his own Joan of Arc script for the past five years, and believes that Besson has made a mockery of history.

Maxwell’s critique is just one of a number of negative reviews of “The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc,” which opened Nov. 12 and grossed $8.3 million domestically in its first week.Filmmakers, Maxwell argues in a letter to Variety, should tell their tales with less fiddling of the facts and more attention to the spirit of the age they are recreating. Besson, he says, errs on both counts.

The problem, he says, is that too often today’s filmmakers put their own egos ahead of historical accuracy: Their poetic license thus easily turns into a license to kill the truth.

In this case, Maxwell suggests, Besson’s ego may have gotten in the way of his ability to envision the ego-less Joan: “The pic is the ultimate ego trip, the polar opposite of the historical Joan, who surrendered her own ego to what she herself saw as a higher calling.”

One glaring goof in “The Messenger,” as Maxwell sees it, is that the pic ignores Joan’s belief that she was visited by saints, as detailed in her actual 1429 trial testimony.

Besson’s version, he says, portrays Joan simply as “a fictitious marionette” who is “transfixed by thrashing winds, rushing clouds and a wolf pack on the hunt” rather than as a pious young girl who believes she has been singled out by God.

Just as irresponsible, Maxwell says, is to center “The Messenger” around a graphic rape scene when there is no evidence in the historical record that this ever happened.

Not able to enter into the spirit of the Middle Ages, the filmmakers were desperate to find some sort of traumatic explanation for her actions, Maxwell believes.

To back up his claim, Maxwell points out that no other writer who has tackled the Joan of Arc story (he lists 32) has ever incorporated a rape scene into their interpretations.

Defending the film, a Sony exec says, “It’s not a documentary, but to our knowledge there was a significant amount of research done on the historical accuracy of this movie.”

In the Battle of Orleans sequence, Besson used the exact number of actors as soldiers listed in historical records, and “many lines in the movie were taken from the trial transcripts,” says the exec.

And of course there’s a reason why the fierce femme’s life is always labeled “the story” of Joan of Arc: No one arguably has ever nailed down the truth about her.

Still, “the cinematic hocus-pocus of ‘The Messenger’ adds to the clutter and confusion which has over the centuries accumulated to the Joan story like barnacles,” Maxwell writes.

And yet, Maxwell argues, “the known facts, or even the events conjectured by the best historians, are infinitely more interesting and dramatic than any of the lame inventions of this film.”

Maybe Maxwell will eventually succeed in conveying those facts more persuasively than he thinks Besson did.

More Film

  • 'Brokeback Mountain,' 'Jurassic Park' Added to

    'Brokeback Mountain,' 'Jurassic Park,' 'My Fair Lady' Added to National Film Registry

    “Brokeback Mountain,” “Jurassic Park,” “My Fair Lady,” “The Shining,” “Hud” and “Monterey Pop” are among the best known titles among this year’s additions to the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress. A place on the list — always made up of 25 films — guarantees the film will be preserved under the terms [...]

  • Christian Bale'Vice' film premiere, Arrivals, Los

    Christian Bale Recalls Meeting Donald Trump: 'He Thought I Was Bruce Wayne'

    With Christian Bale’s latest film, “Vice,” a political dramedy, it’s inevitable ties will be drawn between the film and the current political administration and its chief, President Donald Trump. On the red carpet for the premiere of “Vice,” Bale, who stars as former Vice President Dick Cheney, shared that he met the current president while [...]

  • ‘Bumblebee’ Again Tops Studios’ TV Ad

    ‘Bumblebee’ Again Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by the TV advertising attention analytics company iSpot.tv, Paramount Pictures claims the top spot in spending for the second week in a row with “Bumblebee.” Ads placed for the sci-fi/action film had an estimated media value of $6.31 million through Sunday for 941 national [...]

  • Ryan Reynolds Stunt

    Film News Roundup: Ryan Reynolds' Michael Bay Film '6 Underground' Wraps Production

    In today’s film news roundup, shooting has wrapped on Ryan Reynolds’ “6 Underground,” BAFTA LA names new board members, and the WGA East honors longtime exec Randall Jasta.  PRODUCTION Michael Bay’s Ryan Reynolds-starrer “6 Underground” has wrapped production. Netflix and Skydance Media completed principal photography in Abu Dhabi on the action-adventure, which reportedly carries a $125 [...]

  • Bruce Springsteen on Broadway

    Film Review: 'Springsteen on Broadway'

    Hope you like the 69-year-old version of Bruce Springsteen’s face, because it’s virtually all you’re going to see for the two hours and 40 minutes of the filmed “Springsteen on Broadway” — other than the bare brick wall of the theater casting a dim glow in the background beyond those gray sideburns, and two songs’ [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    'A Star Is Born,' 'Vice' Lead 2018 Australian Academy of Cinema and Television Arts Nominees

    The Australian Academy of Cinema and Television Arts (AACTA) announced their nominees for the 8th annual AACTA International Awards on Tuesday. “A Star Is Born” and “Vice” lead the pack, with five and four nominations respectively. The two leading films compete with “BlacKkKlansman,” “Bohemian Rhapsody,” and “Roma” for best film, while Nicole Kidman becomes the [...]

  • China's Government Orders Talent Home to

    After Golden Horse Awards Embarrassment, China Orders Talent Home for Huabiao Ceremony

    China’s government quietly ordered top Chinese talent back to the mainland from abroad this past weekend to attend a Beijing ceremony for its highest film industry honors, the loosely bi-annual Huabiao Awards. The move came just weeks after it directed mainland film executives and talent to snub after-parties and return home as quickly as possible [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content