You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

What Dreams May Come

A feel-good "Orpheus" for the late '90s, "What Dreams May Come" represents a heaping serving of metaphysical gobbledygook wrapped in a physically striking package.

Chris Nielsen...Robin Williams Albert...Cuba Gooding Jr. Annie Nielsen...Annabella Sciorra The Tracker...Max von Sydow Marie Nielsen...Jessica Brooks Grant Ian Nielsen...Josh Paddock Leona...Rosalind Chao

A feel-good “Orpheus” for the late ’90s, “What Dreams May Come” represents a heaping serving of metaphysical gobbledygook wrapped in a physically striking package. With Robin Williams leading an extensive tour of the afterlife as imagined through a gallery-full of vivified 19th century romantic paintings, Vincent Ward’s ambitious first American film tilts toward undue sentimentality from the get-go and shortly becomes hopelessly mired in its eagerness to remain likable and upbeat in the face of subject matter that calls for considerable more gravity and depth. This attempt to rally a mass audience around the weighty themes of mortality and eternal love had an outside shot at the “Ghost” audience, but the reportedly $85 million-$90 million production looks to fall way short of the commercial mark despite its audience-pleasing aspirations.

In tackling Richard Matheson’s 20-year-old tome about a man’s effort to reunite with his wife after death, the filmmakers no doubt believed that they were embarking upon a brave, unusually serious undertaking for a Hollywood project. In the event, however, the picture spreads out every conceivable safety net for its walk on the spiritual high wire, going directly for the tear ducts at the outset via the deaths of children and a pet dog, for God’s sake, and reducing the perennial theme of transcendent love to the easily digestible pop slogan, “You must never give up.”

Popular on Variety

At almost every moment, the picture evinces a tension between a desire to assert itself as an aesthetically refined consideration of its potentially weighty subject, and a compulsion to pander to a low common denominator via emotional manipulation and an avoidance at all costs of a tragic view of existence. Unfortunately, this creative split does not work in the film’s favor, but instead dilutes both its artistic and commercial qualities.

Before the opening credits are even over, the two children of upscale couple Chris and Annie Nielsen (Williams and Annabella Sciorra) are dead and buried. Jump ahead four years and a few more minutes of screen time and Chris, too, is killed in an auto accident and surveying his own funeral while chatting to his host in the hereafter, Albert (Cuba Gooding Jr.).

Chris, who is portrayed as little short of a saint in flashback snippets of his corporal life as a doctor, husband and father, finds himself in a strange world of brilliant colors, dramatic landscapes and remarkably familiar visions that he soon understands are elaborations upon the paintings his wife either restored or created herself. His heaven, in which both Annie and, for a time, Albert remain blurry figures, consists of intense representations of the heightened romantic world he and his wife inhabited together, but one that Chris must now accept that he will occupy without her.

It must be said that nothing quite like this painted world has been seen in a major feature film before, as it no doubt would have been impossible to create such a thing so credibly before the advent of the sort of sophisticated digital visual effects that can make three-dimensional spaces out of two-dimensional art works. Drawing upon diverse artistic sources but influenced most decisively by the brooding, windswept, nature-dominated landscapes of German romanticist Caspar David Friedrich, the film’s backgrounds provide a genuine feast for the eyes.

At first, Chris slides about as his shoes alight upon grass and flower surfaces that are nothing but large daubs of paint. Sprites, in 19th century garb, flit about through the sky, people walk on water, and Chris soon envisions, among other sights, a golden metropolis in the classical style and other vast constructs straight out of the Age of Enlightenment. It’s an enticing, lofty version of what an educated man might want to find in the next life, and getting it so convincingly on the screen represents an indisputable triumph for the many heads and hands involved on both the conceptual and technical sides.

Pic’s narrative progress is another story, however. Pushing fearlessly into an increasingly insufferable realm of touchy-feely mysticism, Ron Bass’ structurally intricate but dramatically banal script has Chris discover the fates of his children, but also learn that, since a depressed Annie committed suicide and has been relegated to “somewhere else,” he can never hope to be with her throughout eternity.

This is where the “never give up” ethic kicks in, as Chris engages a gruff, wise old man called “The Tracker” (Max von Sydow, very welcome as the only tough-minded person onscreen here) to guide him, as it were, across the River Styx and into hell to rescue his Eurydice. Once again, the creative team is up to the visual challenge involved, as the gates of hell are imaginatively represented as a massive, nocturnal watery graveyard in which any number of battleships from diverse historical eras are seen in flames on their way to the bottom. Hell itself is then memorably depicted as a vast, gloomy field of mud from which innumerable densely packed faces peer up in eternal hopelessness.

But even here, the visuals don’t possesses the weight of their startling conceptual creativity because the overall approach to the material backs away from anything that smacks of the profound or the genuinely disturb-ing. The somewhat highbrow aspirations suggested by the “intellectual” use of the paintings and by the epic, transcendent elements in Ward’s previous work create hopes for a haunting and intelligent treatment of infinitely deep subject matter, while the mealy-mouthed philosophical platitudes — dialogue is loaded with wish-fulfillment aphorisms such as “It’s in your mind” and “All you have to do is close your eyes” — bring the level of discussion down to the level of greeting cards.

Audiences who liked Williams in “Jack” may love him here, but anyone hoping for the old Williams edge should beware. Gooding is antic and good-natured in a role that remains as fuzzy as it initially appears to be visually, and Sciorra is emotionally sincere in a highly idealized role.

The film’s technical accomplishment is its signal point of interest. A more dissonant, complex score might have helped bridge the gap between the picture’s two warring impulses, but composer Michael Kamen mostly underlines the obvious emotional points.

What Dreams May Come

Production: A Polygrams Films release of a Polygram Filmed Entertainment presentation of an Interscope Communications production in association with Metafilmics. Produced by Stephen Simon, Barnet Bain. Executive producers, Ted Field, Scott Kroopf, Erica Huggins, Ron Bass. Co-producer, Alan C. Blomquist. Directed by Vincent Ward. Screenplay, Ron Bass, based on the novel by Richard Matheson.

Crew: Camera (Monaco Film Labs color, Panavision widescreen), Eduardo Serra; editors, David Brenner, Maysie Hoy; music, Michael Kamen; production designer, Eugenio Zanetti; supervising art director, Jim Dultz; art directors, Tomas Voth, Christian Wintter; set designers, Erin Kemp, Dawn Swiderski, Aric Lasher, Jake Strelow, Alicia Maccarone; set decorator, Cindy Carr; costume designer, Yvonne Blake; sound (Dolby digital/DTS/SDDS), Nelson Stoll; supervising sound editors, David Kneupper, Peter Michael Sullivan; visual effects producer/supervisor, Ellen M. Somers; special makeup designed and created by, Masters FX; prosthetic makeup effects, Todd Masters; painted world visual effects, Mass Illusions; visual effects, POP Film & POP Animation; visual effects supervisor, Stuart Robertson; special visual effects and digital animation, Digital Domain; digital visual effects, CIS Hollywood; assistant director, Stephen P. Dunn; stunt coordinator-second unit director, Charles Croughwell; second unit camera, Richard Michalak; casting, Heidi Levitt. Reviewed at Polygram screening room, Beverly Hills, Sept. 24, 1998. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 113 MIN.

With: Chris Nielsen...Robin Williams Albert...Cuba Gooding Jr. Annie Nielsen...Annabella Sciorra The Tracker...Max von Sydow Marie Nielsen...Jessica Brooks Grant Ian Nielsen...Josh Paddock Leona...Rosalind Chao

More Film

  • cr: Claudette Barius/Universal Pictures

    Jordan Peele's 'Us' Named Best Movie of 2019 by African-American Film Critics Association

    Jordan Peele’s horror film “Us” has been selected as the top 2019 film by the African-American Film Critics Association. “Us” also won the AAFCA’s trophies for Peele for best director and Lupita Nyong’o for best actress. The awards will be presented on Jan. 22 at the Taglyan Complex in Hollywood. Peele dominated the AAFCA awards [...]

  • Star Wars Maryann Brandon JJ Abrams

    'Star Wars' Editor Maryann Brandon Balances Story and Character

    Few fandoms are as passionate as those who love “Star Wars” — a franchise that spans multiple media, including movies, books and theme parks. Editor Maryann Brandon, an Oscar nominee for her work on “Star Wars: Episode VII — The Force Awakens,” returned to the galaxy once more for “Star Wars: Episode IX — The [...]

  • Jumanji: The Next Level

    'Jumanji: The Next Level': Film Review

    When Sony dusted off its 22-year-old “Jumanji” movie for a distant sequel in 2017, it looked to some as though Hollywood had hit rock bottom in terms of pillaging its own properties. In fact, “Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle” proved to be that rare reboot that built upon its initial high concept — a jungle-themed [...]

  • Judy Movie 2019 Costume Design

    Costume Designer Jany Temime Looked to the Colorful Past For ‘Judy’

    As costume designer on “Judy,” the biopic about Judy Garland, Jany Temime kept one criteria in mind. “My question was, ‘What would Judy wear for that scene?’ That how I approached it,” says Temime, who also wanted to portray the difference between “the real Judy and the performer Judy.” But instead of using replicas of [...]

  • Rocks

    'Rocks' Director Sarah Gavron to Receive Femmes de Cinema Award at Les Arcs Festival

    British filmmaker Sarah Gavron, whose latest film, “Rocks,” competed at Toronto in the Platform section and won two awards at San Sebastien, will be honored during the 11th edition of Les Arcs Film Festival with the Femmes de Cinema Award. Created by Les Arcs festival in partnership with Sisley in 2013, Femmes de Cinema is [...]

  • Give Me Liberty

    'Give Me Liberty' Grabs Best Film Award in Macao

    Kirill Mikhanovsky’s “Give Me Liberty” and Gu Xiaogang’s “Dwelling in the Fuchun Mountains won the best picture prizes in the international and Chinese cinema sections on Tuesday at the International Film Festival and Awards Macau (IFFAM). “This film shouldn’t have existed because there were so many obstacles. Everything was a miracle. Us being here is [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content