×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Psycho – ‘Psycho’ Analysis: Van Sant’s Remake Slavish But Sluggish

Imitation, in the case of Gus Van Sant's "Psycho," may be the sincerest form of flattery, but it's hardly the most scintillating. A faithful-unto-slavish remake of the 1960 Hitchcock classic, pic contains nothing to outrage or offend partisans of the original, yet neither does it stand to add much to their appreciation. And as for introducing a new generation to the granddaddy of all slasher films, forget about it: Tothe "Scream" kids, sincerity is out anyway, and the thrills here are strictly old hat. With its natural audience limited mainly to Hitch fans and first-weekend curiosity seekers, pic hardly stands to reduce the body count at beleaguered Universal.

With:
Norman Bates ..... Vince Vaughn Marion Crane ..... Anne Heche Lila Crane ..... Julianne Moore Sam Loomis ..... Viggo Mortensen Milton Arbogast ..... William H. Macy Dr. Simon ..... Robert Forster Sheriff Chambers ..... Philip Baker Hall Mrs. Chambers ..... Anne Haney Tom Cassidy ..... Chad Everett Mr. Lowery ..... Rance Howard Caroline ..... Rita Wilson Patrolman ..... James Remar Car Dealer ..... James LeGros

Imitation, in the case of Gus Van Sant’s “Psycho,” may be the sincerest form of flattery, but it’s hardly the most scintillating. A faithful-unto-slavish remake of the 1960 Hitchcock classic, pic contains nothing to outrage or offend partisans of the original, yet neither does it stand to add much to their appreciation. And as for introducing a new generation to the granddaddy of all slasher films, forget about it: Tothe “Scream” kids, sincerity is out anyway, and the thrills here are strictly old hat. With its natural audience limited mainly to Hitch fans and first-weekend curiosity seekers, pic hardly stands to reduce the body count at beleaguered Universal.

Van Sant’s publicized intention not just to restage “Psycho” but to duplicate it in scrupulous, exacting detail was a nervy gambit, one that brought an air of pop-art intellectualism and experimentation to what might have otherwise seemed redundantly mercenary. And in some senses, the gambit will earn a justified place in the history books: Not only is it the first such duplication outside the ranks of experimental filmmakers, it also reps a fascinating effort on the part of one important filmmaker to crawl inside the stylistic skin of another — which, if you think of it, is eerily appropriate to Sir Alf.

The reason the conceit backfires, basically, is that the original depended on narrative surprises that can’t possibly be surprising now; on genre conventions that were superseded decades ago; and on material considered daring in 1960 that’s long since lost its power even to raise an eyebrow (recall that Hitch’s single most shocking move was to show a toilet flushing, which had never been done in a major studio film).

Oddly, while Hitchcock’s “Psycho” today still seems fresh, bold and ahead of its time, Van Sant’s updated tribute makes the same thing seem quaint and old-fashioned, the product of a bygone era.

In effect, though, Van Sant’s exercise might have been more compelling if he had taken his advertised passion for exact duplication to fastidious, fetishistic extremes. It turns out that this “Psycho” is not, after all, a “shot by shot” re-creation of the original. The very first sequence announces that. Where Hitchcock used three ‘panning and zooming shots to cross the Phoenix skyline and enter an illicit hotel window, Van Sant uses a helicopter and various trickery to accomplish the same in one shot.

It’s more accurate to say that this is a largely faithful “scene by scene” restaging in which many shots of the original, especially the most famous and striking, are copied. But the differences don’t end there. This “Psycho” is in color (ably shot by ace Aussie lensman Chris Doyle), which reduces the dream-like mood as well as the schematic visual rigor of Hitchcock’s design. And though Van Sant shot on the same Universal lot and kept to the original’s brisk six-week schedule, the result feels looser and more prone to fresh air, minus the original’s dark, pressured, claustrophobic atmosphere.

The story, taken from Joseph Stefano’s skillful adaptation of Robert Bloch’s novel is, of course, still the same. Marion Crane (Anne Heche), who’s having an affair with commitment-shy Sam Loomis (Viggo Mortensen), steals a load of cash — $ 400,000, adjusted upwards tenfold from 1960’s haul — and hits the road.

Taking refuge in the motel owned by conflicted mama’s boy Norman Bates (Vince Vaughn), she’s murdered during a nocturnal shower. Her disappearance prompts inquiries by a private eye named Arbogast (William H. Macy) as well as Sam and Marion’s sister Lila (Julianne Moore), who discover the morbid bond linking Norman to his mysterious mom.

The film’s most famous scene, the shower knife-murder, Van Sant restages with slightly more nudity and realism and at what seems like a slightly protracted length. Here and in the murder of Arbogast, he also departs from the original by inserting dreamy cutaway shots, including fast-motion views of clouds that recall similar shots in “My Own Private Idaho.”

Acting, however, is the one area where the execution of this “Psycho” falls consistently and markedly below the original. Vaughn was a bad casting choice whose awkwardness as Norman only proves, by contrast, the extraordinary skill and subtlety of Anthony Perkins’ work for Hitchcock. Heche tries to paint Marion as flighty, but ends up making her a pale, vapid, slightly vulgar shadow of Janet Leigh’s brilliant, hard-edged original.

Mortensen’s making Sam a hick and Moore doing Lila as a Walkman-wearing music-store chick are similarly uninspired and broadly drawn.

The two bright spots in the cast are Macy, whose Arbogast has presence, dimension and believable quirkiness, and Robert Forster, who does a surprisingly good job in the thankless role of the psychiatrist, whose explanatory final-reel speech Van Sant has mercifully abbreviated somewhat.

Pic’s other tech contributions, including Tom Foden’s thoughtful production design and Danny Elfman’s new rendition of Bernard Herrmann’s legendary score, are all first rate.

Psycho - 'Psycho' Analysis: Van Sant's Remake Slavish But Sluggish

(CRIME DRAMA)

Production: A Universal release of an Imagine Entertainment production. Produced by Brian Grazer, Gus Van Sant. Executive producer, Dany Wolf. Directed by Gus Van Sant. Screenplay by Joseph Stefano, based on the novel by Robert Bloch.

Crew: Camera (Deluxe color), Christopher Doyle; editor, Amy Duddleston; music, Bernard Herrmann; music adaptor and producer, Danny Elfman; production designer, Tom Foden; art director, Carlos Barbosa; costume designer, Beatrix Aruna Pasztor; sound (Dolby digital, DTS, SDDS), Ron Judkins; associate producer , James Whitaker; assistant director, Bruce Franklin. Reviewed at the Sony 19th Street East, New York, Dec. 4, 1998. MPAA rating: R. Running time: 109 MIN.

With: Norman Bates ..... Vince Vaughn Marion Crane ..... Anne Heche Lila Crane ..... Julianne Moore Sam Loomis ..... Viggo Mortensen Milton Arbogast ..... William H. Macy Dr. Simon ..... Robert Forster Sheriff Chambers ..... Philip Baker Hall Mrs. Chambers ..... Anne Haney Tom Cassidy ..... Chad Everett Mr. Lowery ..... Rance Howard Caroline ..... Rita Wilson Patrolman ..... James Remar Car Dealer ..... James LeGros

More Film

  • Game of Thrones Cast

    What's Next for 'Game of Thrones'' Cast Members

    Eight years and eight seasons later, the “Game of Thrones” cast finally has some downtime to relax or move onto other projects. Some stars, like Kit Harington, who told Variety that he doesn’t plan on taking another role as physically demanding as Jon Snow, certainly deserve a break, but others have wasted no time getting back on [...]

  • MEET THE PRESS -- Pictured: (l-r)

    Submissions Now Welcome for Third 'Meet the Press' Film Festival

    Chuck Todd’s quest to bring “Meet the Press” to the movies continues. The third annual Meet the Press Film Festival, held in collaboration with the American Film Institute, will take place on October 6 and 7 in Washington, D.C., and remains a haven for issue-focused documentary shorts. Todd believes the event serves a critical mission: [...]

  • Challenges Still Keep Content From Traveling

    Cannes: Challenges Still Keep Content From Traveling to and From China

    Challenges still remain when it comes to buying, distributing and producing content that can travel between China and the West, attendees of a panel organized by the Shanghai Intl. Film Festival on the sidelines of Cannes said. Cai Gongming, president of Road Pictures, has hit box office gold in China with Cannes art-house titles such [...]

  • 180423_A24_Day_03B_0897.jpg

    Cannes Film Review: Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe in 'The Lighthouse'

    “The Lighthouse,” the second feature directed by Robert Eggers (“The Witch”), is a gripping and turbulent drama that draws on a number of influences, though it merges them into its own fluky gothic historical ominoso art-thriller thing. Set in the 1890s, and suffused with foghorns and epic gusts of wind, as well as a powerfully [...]

  • Cannes: Diao Yinan Explains His Artistic

    Diao Yinan on Cannes Pic 'Wild Goose Lake': 'I Try to Portray the Opposite of a Utopia'

    In competition in Cannes with “Wild Goose Lake,” director Diao Yinan explained Sunday why he’s fascinated by dark crime thrillers – and why his new film features dialogue in China’s Wuhan dialect. “Such thrillers are not only an exercise in style; they’re also full of dramatic tension, and when you combine style with dramatic tension, [...]

  • CAP D'ANTIBES, FRANCE - MAY 18:

    Cannes: Robert Pattinson, Shailene Woodley Attend Starry Vanity Fair Party

    It’s true what they say about Batman being a loner. On Saturday night, Robert Pattinson made his first public appearance since being cast as the new Dark Knight at this year’s Vanity Fair Party at the Cannes Film Festival. But while all the other A-list guests mingled and worked the crowd at the restaurant of [...]

  • 180423_A24_Day_03B_0897.jpg

    Robert Pattinson: 'The Lighthouse' Rehearsal Was a 'Pressure Cooker'

    Rehearsal for director Robert Eggers’ “The Lighthouse” wasn’t as long as Robert Pattinson remembers. “I’ve never rehearsed like I rehearsed with Robert before,” Pattinson said at the first screening of the period thriller on Sunday morning. “We rehearsed for what, three weeks?” Actually, no — it was only one week! “One, but it felt like [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content