×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Against Her Will: The Carrie Buck Story

Marlee Matlin broadens her repertoire with a showy portrayal of a woman who's not deaf in a TV movie based on a precedent-setting legal case; Melissa Gilbert stays within her established range as the lawyer who ... well, who doesn't help very much at all.

With:
Cast: Marlee Matlin, Melissa Gilbert, Peter Frechette, Pat Hingle, Joe Inscoe , John Bennes, James Martin Jr., Elaine Nalee, Terry Loughlin, Sharyn Greene, Moses Gibson, Trent McDevitt, Tammy Arnold, J. Michael Hunter, Laddy Sartin, Mark Jeffrey Miller, Michael Burgess, Nello Tate, Ed Grady, Stan Kelly, Joann Pankow, David Lenthall.

Marlee Matlin broadens her repertoire with a showy portrayal of a woman who’s not deaf in a TV movie based on a precedent-setting legal case; Melissa Gilbert stays within her established range as the lawyer who … well, who doesn’t help very much at all.

Carrie Buck (Matlin) was subject of a 1927 Supreme Court decision allowing involuntary sterilization of mentally deficient women. Story follows Buck from her placement in a Virginia “feeble-minded colony” through resolution of case.

Melissa Prentice (Gilbert) is an upper-class Virginian, soon to be one of the country’s few female attorneys of the era. At the time, Brian L. Ross’ efficient script tells viewers, Prentice was clerking with Adam White (Peter Frechette), attorney aiming for political office as well as Prentice’s affections.

Her line of reasoning for preserving the lineage of the mentally deficient doesn’t make much sense. Still, she persuades White to take on Buck’s case, in which he winds up fighting Prentice’s uncle (Pat Hingle), a prominent physician who has already sterilized as many as 100 women.

This being Lifetime, Prentice is the hero, though she and White flub things wherever possible: plucky Prentice helps Buck escape from the facility, resulting in the patient’s placement in solitary, and White loses the case.

Always an appealing actress, Gilbert keeps a stiff upper lip throughout, as Matlin and Hingle munch on the scenery. Frechette is wooden under John David Coles’ otherwise sharp direction.

Lensed in various North Carolina locations by Ron Fortunato, film looks especially good, with Frederic C. Weiler’s production design heavy on the earth tones.

Card at the end of the film tells audience that Buck’s daughter, born before the start of the story, made her school’s honor roll, and that a geneticist testifying in favor of sterilization of the “inferior” was subsequently honored by Nazis for his work.

Against Her Will: The Carrie Buck Story

(Wed. (5), 9-11 p.m., Lifetime)

Production: Filmed in North Carolina by Janet Faust Krusi Prods. in association with Viacom. Executive producer, Janet Faust Krusi; co-producer, Brian L. Ross; line producers, Krusi, Robert Girolami; director, John David Coles; script, Ross.

Crew: Camera, Ron Fortunato; editor, Angelo Corrao; production designer, Frederic C. Weiler; sound, Carl Rudisill; music, Mickey Erbe, Maribeth Solomon.

Cast: Cast: Marlee Matlin, Melissa Gilbert, Peter Frechette, Pat Hingle, Joe Inscoe , John Bennes, James Martin Jr., Elaine Nalee, Terry Loughlin, Sharyn Greene, Moses Gibson, Trent McDevitt, Tammy Arnold, J. Michael Hunter, Laddy Sartin, Mark Jeffrey Miller, Michael Burgess, Nello Tate, Ed Grady, Stan Kelly, Joann Pankow, David Lenthall.

More TV

  • Anna Paquin, Sophie Okonedo in Flack

    TV Review: 'Flack' Starring Anna Paquin

    There’s a familiar, acrid aftertaste to “Flack,” Pop’s new drama about the controlled chaos of the publicity industry. The grim behind-the-scenes machinations of the glossy entertainment industry have always been one of TV’s favorite subjects, as are the people tasked with pulling the strings without anyone ever realizing. Over just six episodes, the show manages [...]

  • Jee Young Han

    NBC Comedy Pilot 'Like Magic' Casts Jee Young Han in Lead Role

    Jee Young Han has been cast in the lead role of the NBC single-camera comedy pilot “Like Magic,” Variety has learned. The project is a workplace comedy that follows an optimistic young woman (Jee) pursuing her dream to be a headlining magician in the eccentric and ego-driven world of the Magic Palace. Jee will play Holly. [...]

  • Sharon Case from The Young and

    NATAS Announces 2019 Daytime Emmys Pre-Nominations for Drama Performer Categories

    The National Academy of Television Arts & Sciences have announced the pre-nominations for all of the drama performer categories ahead of the 46th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards. “The Young and the Restless” lead the pre-nominations with 21 candidates, but “General Hospital” and “Days of Our Lives” are close behind with 20 and 19 candidates, respectively. [...]

  • Childrens Hospital

    'Childrens Hospital' Team Reunites at Netflix for Comedy Series 'Medical Police'

    The team behind the Adult Swim series “Childrens Hospital” has come back together at Netflix. The streamer has ordered 10 thirty-minute episodes of a new scripted series called “Medical Police,” which is written and executive produced by Rob Corddry, Krister Johnson, Jonathan Stern, David Wain. In addition to his onscreen role, Corddry created “Childrens Hospital,” [...]

  • mike colter luke cage portrait

    'Luke Cage' Alum Mike Colter Joins CBS Drama Pilot 'Evil'

    Mike Colter has been cast in a lead role in the CBS drama pilot “Evil” from Robert and Michelle King, Variety has learned. Colter will play David DaCosta, a Catholic priest in training, tasked by the Church to assess unexplained phenomena to see if there is a supernatural or scientific explanation. He joins previously announced [...]

  • Watch First Trailer for Motley Crue

    Watch First Trailer for Motley Crue Biopic 'The Dirt'

    Netflix has dropped the first trailer for its Motley Crue biopic “The Dirt” — based on Neil Strauss’ best-selling history of the legendarily bad-behaved ‘80s metal icons — and it looks like the film pulls no punches in terms of the band’s famously sordid history. In this two-minute trailer, we get glimpses of singer Vince [...]

  • man-in-the-high-castle-season-two-rufus-sewell-amazon

    Amazon's 'The Man in the High Castle' to End With Fourth Season

    “The Man in the High Castle” is coming to an end. Amazon Prime Video said Tuesday that the dystopian alt-history series will end with its fourth season, which will premiere in the fall. “It has been a great privilege to work alongside our extraordinary ‘High Castle’ team, in partnership with David Zucker and Scott Free, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content