Judge takes wind out of Sayles suit

A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.”

In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy Were Neighbors” and turned it into “Passion Fish.”

Hilton ruled that Towler showed no evidence that Sayles had access to her screenplay before he started filming his own. “And there is no evidence,” he continued, “just not a scintilla of evidence upon which a reasonable jury could find that he did have access.”

Just a month earlier, Hilton rejected a motion from Sayles to dismiss the suit because of claims by Towler that she had given her script to a Sayles assistant.

Towler claimed that she had submitted a script to an employee of SCS Films, who promised to give it to Sayles. According to an open letter from Sayles to the media, the former SCS employee, Shelby Stone, testified that she never sent Towler’s screenplay to Sayles.

In the letter, Sayles said Judge Hilton rejected his dismissal plea because of Towler’s claim that SCS was owned or operated by Sayles. “Very early on in the trial, those representations were found to be completely false,” Sayles said.

Sayles claimed a “handwritten” version of “Passion Fish” existed long before Towler asked anyone to pass her script on to him. He called the “substantial similarities” between the two works “at best, surreal.”

Towler said she would appeal the decision.

“I said it was going to be difficult and it is, especially when people are basically lying on the stand,” she said.

Towler’s suit was filed against Sayles; his two corporations, Atchafalaya and Esperanza; and “Passion Fish” distributor Miramax Films.

More Film

  • NANTUCKET, MA - JUNE 23: (L-R)

    How Long Will TV and Film's Boom Market for Female Stories Last?

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • 'Ideal Home' Review: Steve Coogan, Paul

    Film Review: 'Ideal Home'

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • 'Calibre' Review: A Terrific, Intensely Terrifying

    Edinburgh Film Review: 'Calibre'

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • CHRIS PRATT stars as Owen in

    Box Office: 'Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom' Gnaws on $144 Million Debut Weekend

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • Leung Chiu-wai

    Tony Leung Breaks With Wong Kar-wai’s Jettone (Reports)

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • No Merchandising. Editorial Use Only. No

    ‘Jurassic World’ Holds off ‘Incredibles 2’ in China

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

  • shanghai skyline China Placeholder

    Regulators Keep Chinese Film Industry in Suspense

    A Virginia district court judge has thrown out a lawsuit against helmer/scripter John Sayles over copyright infringement on the Oscar-nominated film “Passion Fish.” In a Dec. 20 ruling, Judge Claude M. Hilton tossed out the complaint of Washington, D.C., attorney Virginia Towler that claimed Sayles had stolen her script “Crossed Wires or Bobbie and Wendy […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content