You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Syndie Implications Seen In Cleveland Anti-Trust Ruling

A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators.

In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets.

The suit was brought in 1987 by Northeastern Educational TV of Ohio against the Educational TV Assn. of Metropolitan Cleveland, which operates WVIZ-TV in that market; WVIZ prez and g.m., Betty Cope; Eastern Educational TV of Boston; and Eastern’s program syndication service, IPS.

Northeastern, which operates two Ohio pubcasters, WEAO-TV Akron and WNEO-TV Alliance, claimed that Educational TV’s policy – which states that stations that overlap other stations’ signals are not allowed equal access to programs, in this case those supplied by IPS for WVIZ – is monopolistic.

The court’s opinion apparently endorsed Eastern Educational’s own policy, called Duplicate Market Criteria, which designates primary and secondary markets. The court stated, in part, that “from the television viewers’ perspective, it is…clear that the IPS policy increases the diversity of programming available to the viewing public.”

The opinion goes on to explain that “interbrand competition” is increased by the policy because it causes secondary affiliates, such as the stations operated by Northeastern Educational, “to go to suppliers other than [IPS] to purchase certain programming.”

Among the programs not made available to the overlapping stations and kept exclusive for the primary affiliates was the Canadian Broadcasting Corp.’s “The Nature Of Things.”

According to Bill Gale, v.p., service at Eastern Educational, this is the first court decision ruling on the legality of exclusive programming licenses in public broadcasting, but it also has application for commercial broadcasting.

More TV

  • Robbie Williams

    Robbie Williams On His World Cup Middle Finger: ‘I Cannot Trust Me’

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • ‘Mystery Road,’ Judy Davis Drama Series,

    ‘Mystery Road,’ Judy Davis and Aaron Pedersen Drama Series, Heads to Acorn TV in the U.S.

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • Highlighting Conecta Fiction SGAE Laboratory Pitches

    Highlighting Conecta Fiction SGAE Laboratory Pitches

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • DirecTV Nabs Latin American Rights To

    DirecTV Nabs Latin American Pay TV Rights To Mediaset España's Hit 'El Accidente'

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • Tiffany Haddish - Best Comedic PerformanceMTV

    TV Review: 2018 MTV Movie Awards

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • Tiffany Haddish

    MTV Movie and TV Awards: 10 Standout Moments

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

  • Michael B. Jordan

    'Black Panther,' 'Stranger Things' Reign at 2018 MTV Movie and TV Awards (Full List)

    A little-noted federal court decision in Cleveland last month may have significant implications for tv syndicators. In dismissing antitrust claims in a 3-year-old suit brought against a public tv syndicator, the Cleveland Federal Court said, in effect, that a program distributor is able to set criteria designating primary and secondary markets. The suit was brought […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content