You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

My Own Private Idaho

Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant's appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes.

With:
River Phoenix Keanu Reeves James Russo William Richert Rodney Harvey Chiara Caselli

Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant’s appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes.

Taking his title from a B-52s song, Van Sant begins his crooked yarn on a straight Idaho highway, where the scruffy outcast Mike (River Phoenix) succumbs to his affliction of narcolepsy and has visions of his lost home and mother. In Seattle, Mike is a sex-for-hire boy, a sensitive but raw youth who will go both ways but has the unfortunate habit of passing out on the job.

Mike’s cohort and soon-to-be best friend is Scott (Keanu Reeves). The wealthy son of Portland’s mayor, Scott is clearly hanging with the boys as an act of teenage rebellion against his family.

Then Van Sant makes a sudden, fatal shift in tone and style. The dialog begins sounding arch, the acting style becomes strangely theatrical and, for a while, the film becomes a modern, gay adaptation of Shakespeare’s Henry IV, Part I.

Shakespearean side of the story falls short due to Reeves’ very narrow range as an actor. Phoenix cuts a believable, sometimes compelling figure of a young man urgently groping for definition in his life. For a story about two gay hustlers, film deals very little with sex.

My Own Private Idaho

Production: New Line. Director Gus Van Sant; Producer Laurie Parker; Screenplay Gus Van Sant; Camera Eric Alan Edwards, John Campbell; Editor Curtiss Clayton; Music Bill Stafford; Art Director David Brisbin

Crew: (Color) Available on VHS, DVD. Extract of a review from 1991. Running time: 102 MIN.

With: River Phoenix Keanu Reeves James Russo William Richert Rodney Harvey Chiara Caselli

More Film

  • Martin Scorsese, Sigourney Weaver to Appear

    Martin Scorsese, Sigourney Weaver, Giuseppe Tornatore Set for Rome Film Festival

    Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant’s appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes. Taking his title from a B-52s song, Van Sant begins his crooked yarn on […]

  • Terence Stamp English actor Terence Stamp

    Terence Stamp, Gemma Arterton Join Netflix's 'Murder Mystery'

    Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant’s appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes. Taking his title from a B-52s song, Van Sant begins his crooked yarn on […]

  • 'The Parting Glass' Review: An Honest,

    Film Review: 'The Parting Glass'

    Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant’s appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes. Taking his title from a B-52s song, Van Sant begins his crooked yarn on […]

  • Owen (CHRIS PRATT) with a baby

    What 'Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom's' Success Means for the Franchise's Future

    Rather less than the sum of its often striking parts, Gus Van Sant’s appealingly idiosyncratic look at a pair of very different young street hustlers is one of those ambitious, over-reaching disappointments that is more interesting than some more conservative successes. Taking his title from a B-52s song, Van Sant begins his crooked yarn on […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content