×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Desire Under the Elms

Despite all the plus factors, Desire under the Elms is not satisfactory entertainment. It is painfully slow in getting underway, the characters are never completely understandable or believable, and the ghastly plot climax (of infanticide) plays with disappointingly little force.

With:
Sophia Loren Anthony Perkins Burl Ives Frank Overton Pernell Roberts Rebecca Welles

Despite all the plus factors, Desire under the Elms is not satisfactory entertainment. It is painfully slow in getting underway, the characters are never completely understandable or believable, and the ghastly plot climax (of infanticide) plays with disappointingly little force.

Eugene O’Neill’s play has been given a reverent translation. But Irwin Shaw, who did the screenplay, has not improved the story. O’Neill wrote a modern version of a Greek tragedy, as raw and chilling as anything in Oed ipus or Med ea. He chose the craggy New England of 1840 and its flinty characters with care. The casting of Sophia Loren in the role of the young (third) wife of farmer Burl Ives is a key error because it injects an alien-to-the-scene element that dislocates the drama permanently.

The passion of greed and lust that takes place, in which Anthony Perkins and Loren embark on a semi-incestuous love affair that ends with Loren’s having a child that Ives thinks is his, has been handled with discretion. Too much, perhaps.

Popular on Variety

O’Neill saw it as men fighting the gods and losing. Shaw apparently sees it as men understood through modern psychology, still doomed and damned, but for different reasons.

Despite Loren’s unsuitability for the play, she exposes a great variety of emotion and manages the scenes of tenderness with special value. Perkins’ character is not as exciting or vivid as it should be. Ives is the best, a bull of a man, cold in emotion and hot in passion.

Desire Under the Elms

Production: Paramount. Director Delbert Mann; Producer Don Hartman; Screenplay Irwin Shaw; Camera Daniel L. Fapp; Editor George Boemler; Music Elmer Bernstein; Art Director Hal Pereira, J. McMillan Johnson

Crew: (B&W) Available on VHS, DVD. Extract of a review from 1958. Running time: 111 MIN.

With: Sophia Loren Anthony Perkins Burl Ives Frank Overton Pernell Roberts Rebecca Welles

More Film

  • Imogen Poots

    'Black Christmas' Star Imogen Poots on Why Male Horror Fans Should See Slasher Remake

    “Black Christmas” is the second remake of the 1974 slasher classic, which centers on a group of sorority sisters stalked by an unknown murderer. While the original had the female protagonists (SPOILER) offed, in this one, the women fight back. “It’s been called a re-imagining of the original, and I think, in ways that the [...]

  • Imogen Poots as Riley in "Black

    'Black Christmas': Film Review

    “Black Christmas,” a low-budget Canadian horror movie released in 1974, was a slasher thriller with a difference: It was the very first one! Okay, there were more than a few precedents, from “Psycho” (the great-granddaddy of the genre) to “The Last House on the Left” and “The Texas Chain Saw Massacre” to Mario Bava’s “A [...]

  • David Benioff, D.B. Weiss. Creators and

    'Game of Thrones' Creators to Develop H.P. Lovecraft Movie at Warner Bros.

    Following their exit from the “Star Wars” universe, “Game of Thrones” co-creators David Benioff and D.B. Weiss have found their replacement pic, signing on to produce an untitled thriller based on the graphic novel “Lovecraft” for Warner Bros. It is unknown if they will also direct the project, but they’ve already set Phil Hay and [...]

  • Little Women Greta Gerwig BTS

    Greta Gerwig and 'Little Women' Crew Mix Modern and Classical

    Greta Gerwig wrote and directed Sony’s “Little Women,” a new look at Louisa May Alcott’s much-loved 19th-century classic. Eager to pay tribute to her artisan colleagues, Gerwig says, “It was a joy for me to work with all these people. It’s a movie that’s impossible to create without world-class artists. They killed themselves for me!” [...]

  • Honey Boy

    Shia LaBeouf's 'Honey Boy' Adds Unusual Twist to Oscar's History With Kids

    Hollywood has made many terrific films about childhood, and many about filmmaking. Amazon’s “Honey Boy,” which opened Nov. 8, combines the two: A movie with a child’s POV of the industry. That unique angle could be a real benefit during awards season, and the film’s backstory — with Shia LaBeouf as the main attraction — will [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content