Helen Hayes is the sorrowing Angela, as solid and satisfying a bit of acting as comes to the screen in a blue moon. Clark Gable is a gallant soldier hero and leaves nothing to be desired.
The studio has given the story [from the play by Walter Hackett, from the novel by E. Marion Crawford] a superlative production, making the most of the setting in Rome with the background of the church’s pomp and pageantry, a background, too, which colors the sentimental quality of the whole tale and gives it emotional grip.
Midway there are war sequences involving nicely-handled airplane battles, and later the hero’s escape from an enemy prison camp, which give the action substance, although side issues of the central theme. This, of course, is the separation of the lovers, a parting which sends the girl, believing her lover is dead, into a nunnery, from which, upon his return, she cannot bring herself to depart.