TV Review: The CW Updates Archie Comics With ‘Riverdale’

TV Review: The CW Updates Archie
Courtesy of CW

With all due respect to the Eagles: On TV, high school is the real Hotel California. You can and probably did check out years ago, but television of every genre makes sure that you never escape it. The pressure cooker of nascent adulthood, structured days, uncertain futures, and wildly fluctuating hormones makes for a well of creativity with endless iterations — teenage superheroes, deadly secrets, pop music covers, introspective voiceover.

Riverdale,” the CW’s new teen drama based on the Archie comics, is an eerie and offbeat take on the high school mythos — both addictive and confusing in equal parts. Its incredibly attractive leads, secret backstories, complex buried relationships, and unreliable, unethical adults are reminiscent of Freeform’s “Pretty Little Liars” and the CW’s “Gossip Girl.” But where those shows, and most teen shows, serve as titillating coming-of-age narratives, hovering between the wholesome bubble of innocence and the seductive call of the wider adult world, “Riverdale” is a much more stylized story, trying to create dynamism out of what is, to most viewers, one of the most frozen-in-time franchises in comics.

To be sure, the Archie comics franchise, which dates back to 1941, has changed dramatically in the last decade — with a new visual style, expanded “darker” stories, and a gay character in classmate Kevin Keller. (“Riverdale’s” showrunner, Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa, is Chief Creative Officer of Archie Comic Publications — a position he obtained, bizarrely, a decade after the company sent him a cease-and-desist order for a play he wrote that had Archie himself coming out of the closet.)

But for most of us, Archie is still the oval-eyed, round-eared, quaintly jolly ginger perennially torn between sweet-as-pie Betty and fierce, rich Veronica. Archie comics are so numerous and inconsistent that they are quintessentially cartoonish, in a way that is quite the opposite of Batman’s moody “The Dark Knight Returns” or Marvel’s politically cognizant X-Men; the butler is really named Smithers, the teacher is really named Mrs. Grundy, Josie and the Pussycats (!) are really fellow students, and the kids really do go out for milkshakes after school.

What’s fun about “Riverdale,” which casts itself as a moody teen drama in a remote, slightly spooky town, is how much the show commits both to the unchanging world of the comics — and to tweaking it constantly. (To underscore the point, both Luke Perry and Mädchen Amick play parents — in nods to two very different takes on high school.) Along with the stylized visuals of Veronica’s white headband, Betty’s constant ponytail, and Archie’s too-red hair is the characters’ near-consciousness that they are playing strangely archetypal roles in a pretty-as-a-picture world. Part of the surreality of the show is in the characters’ conversations — the 15- to 16-year-olds cram pop-culture references into their quippy patter with implausible skill. Kevin (Casey Cott) makes a crack about a “pre-accident Montgomery Clift” that must play well with the four or so classic-film nerds under the age of 18; in a later scene, both “In Cold Blood” and “Making a Murderer” are equivalently name-dropped.

And to deflate the notion of wholesome Americana as quickly as possible, the primary story driver of “Riverdale” is, quite incongruously, an incestuous murder mystery. The opening scenes are narrated by Jughead (Cole Sprouse), an emo hipster whose crown is in the form of a slouchy toque. He has a weakness for florid language, but in his defense, the story is pretty chilling; a senior at Riverdale was in a boat with his twin sister when it capsized. She survived, he didn’t; no one knows why. The direction gives loving attention to Cheryl Blossom (Madelaine Petsch)’s white gloves and red hair; to the twins’ matching outfits, as they creepily row their boat down the river. It’s unexpectedly captivating.

But aside from style, much of “Riverdale’s” success boils down to the nuts and bolts of character development. With time and attention, the dynamic between Betty (Lili Reinhart), Veronica (Camila Mendes), and Archie (K.J. Apa) becomes more than just a frozen love triangle; Betty and Veronica become plausible friends, each with a peculiar relationship with the unbelievably attractive Archie (whose interpersonal failings are plausibly made up for by his frequently displayed six-pack). In “Riverdale,” Betty is a “good girl” because her mother Alice Cooper (Mädchen Amick) is an abusively controlling bully, and rich-bitch Veronica is trying to redefine herself after hastily decamping from New York City, where her father just got sent to jail for embezzlement. Both have real chemistry with each other and with the object of their affections.

Archie, for his part, is a flatter character, possibly … because he’s just a tad dumber. His passion for music sends him headlong into an affair with his music teacher — a younger and much hotter Ms. Grundy (Sarah Habel) than you might be expecting — which is a major misstep, a major misstep, both for the characters and the show. For a show that experiments with tropes and styles, the student-teacher affair feels neither playful nor interrogated — a cold fish of a plotline.

Still, what’s fascinating about the show is how intimate it is with its own silliness. In the very first episode, Veronica and Betty confront with the queer subtext of their relationship by kissing in front of the cheerleading captain, none other than the bereaved Cheryl Blossom herself. The high school princess — who has “HBIC” printed on the back of her jersey — rolls her eyes dismissively. “Check your sell-by date, ladies. Faux-lesbian kissing hasn’t been taboo since 1994.”

TV Review: The CW Updates Archie Comics With 'Riverdale'

Drama, 13 episodes (4 reviewed): The CW, Thurs. Jan. 26, 9 p.m.


Executive producers, Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa, Greg Berlanti, Sarah Schechter, Jon Goldwater


K.J. Apa, Camila Mendes, Lili Reinhart, Cole Sprouse, Ashleigh Murray, Sarah Habel, Mädchen Amick, Madelaine Petsch, Marisol Nichols, Luke Perry

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 8

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Viki Duncan says:

    This seems like a Buffy The Vampire Slayer remake, without the Vampires… or great writing. Hit and a MISS.

  2. Stacee says:

    Gross…teaching teen girls it’s okay to support a piece of crap father and disrespect a mother who gives up everything. We teach people how to treat us…I have stopped watching this program and disallowed my teen daughter to watch this program because it encourages Stockholm syndrome!!! Absolutely disgusting

  3. HCHARRY says:

    I don’t see what everybody’s complaining about. You shouldn’t compare these characters to the original Archie comics/storyline to begin with. If anything, it plays more into the alternate/dark/dystopian feel of the “Life with Archie” comics, where Archie eventually dies. I think that the adaptation isn’t horrible. Sure it’s a teen drama with some cliche moments, but I feel like some of the feel is there. They just tried to play into the every small “wholesome” town has its secrets playbook. I was a huge fan of Archie comics growing up, and I’m willing to give this show a chance at least to see where it goes. Most shows don’t hit their stride until after the first season anyway, and few hit shows were anywhere near as amazing when they ended compared to where they began.

  4. Nakrosys says:

    I’m from Germany, I saw this on Netflix and we here really don’t know sh** about Archie and all the comic world except for Sabrina the teenage witch (which I hadn’t watched) and the overlooked movie of Josie & the Pussycats (which I liked). So it was a bit shocking to read about all this background stories after I watch the premiere. I thought that it’s like a mix-up between Gossip Girl, Pretty Little Liar and Twin Peaks, but with a more adult take on things than the first named series. And it seem to be fun to watch for someone without the knowledge of the whole Archie history. It was like a guilty pleasure series to watch. And it was great to see Dylan McKay (LOL) again on TV.

  5. Pam Clark says:

    I was excited too, I love dark humor and horror, mystery etc but this is just bad I couldn’t get thur the first epi…I turned if off when Archie and the teacher were screwing in the car smh. So happy I didn’t make it to the lame lesbian kiss scene. I’m ok with remakes, I LOVE Bates Motel..great acting great plot etc, but this Riverdale is just thrown together bs

  6. Paul says:

    I’ve been a Archie fan since I was a kid and this tv show IS not the Archie I don’t want to watch you people screw up the characters that we all grew up with not happy 😠😠😠😠😠😠

  7. Jim says:

    So basically it’s a generic teen show from CW that just slapped “Riverdale” and some character names on it for name recognition? No thanks.

    • Rex the Wonder Dog says:

      Actually I did get a good Archie and Veronica vibe from the characters. Betty is still sort of a work in progress. It does feel like the characters from the comic books if they were thrust into a dystopian version of Riverdale. If you liked the characters from the comic books they are still recognizable.

More TV News from Variety