Emmys: Final ‘Girls’ Season Makes a Strong Case in Heated Comedy Categories

Emmys: 'Girls' Deserves Consideration for an

HBO’s “Girls” has maintained a modest presence at the Emmys ever since the program’s big coming-out in 2012 and 2013, when it scooped up two nominations in a row for outstanding comedy series. Adam Driver has shown up consistently in the supporting actor category, while guest stars like Gaby Hoffman and Peter Scolari have been recognized as well. But the show has mostly struggled to reach those early heights again.

That could change with the sixth and final season, which has made for the richest portrait of Lena Dunham’s world yet.

You may well have bailed by now, whether the creator’s outsized activist footprint overshadowed the series, or her various characters’ descent into their own navels made it seem like there was no light at the end of the tunnel. But it’s time to catch up. Things were already on the upswing with season five, and now, with just one episode left, Dunham and company are sticking the landing.

Of course, whether voters in the TV Academy feel moved enough to return to this particular well, or whether they’ll even have the bandwidth to take the show’s graceful close into account, is left to be seen. The comedy landscape has only gotten more competitive, and it is littered with proven heavy-hitters, fresh prospects looking to get theirs, and recent firebrands that have claimed their own turf.


Golden Girls Jimmy Kimmel

Watch Lena Dunham and the Cast of ‘Girls’ Transform Into NSFW Version of ‘The Golden Girls’

In front of the camera this season, Dunham — who picked up three Emmy nominations and a Golden Globe for her performance along the way — has carved the lines of Hannah Horvath deeper than ever. She’ll face stiff competition, not least of all from reigning champ and stalwart of the lead actress race, Julia Louis-Dreyfus. The “Veep” star has been joined by actresses like Ellie Kemper (“Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”), Tracee Ellis Ross (“Black-ish”) and Lily Tomlin (“Grace and Frankie”) in recent years.

Former nominees like Amy Schumer (“Inside Amy Schumer”) are off the table, but countless contenders will be rushing to fill the void — Tomlin’s co-star Jane Fonda, newcomer Issa Rae (“Insecure”), and former winner Sarah Jessica Parker (“Divorce”) among them.

Elsewhere on the show, Critics’ Choice nominee Allison Williams has found novel shades to play, while Jemima Kirke has shifted into a whole new gear. They’ll be part of a lively supporting actress mix that includes regulars like Anna Chlumsky (“Veep”), Gaby Hoffman (“Transparent”) and Allison Janney (“Mom”). Last year’s winner Kate McKinnon (“Saturday Night Live”) will probably return to the fray, and you never can guess where voters will fall on previous nominees like Mayim Bialik (“The Big Bang Theory”), Julie Bowen (“Modern Family”) and Jane Krakowski (“Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”). Plus, at least one legend appears to be formidable: Rita Moreno in Netflix’s “One Day at a Time.”

The stand-out, however, has been Andrew Rannells as Elijah Krantz. In season five he found further dimension for his character opposite guest star Corey Stoll, but in episodes like “Gummies” and particularly “The Bounce” this season, he has not thrown away his shot. He’s created the kind of character spin-offs are made of. (Hint, hint, HBO.)


Girls Premiere HBO

‘Girls’ Cast Celebrates Final Season and Legacy of Empowering Women

Giving Rannells competition in the supporting actor category are Louis Anderson (“Baskets”), Tituss Burgess (“Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”) and Tony Hale (“Veep”), who all seem primed to return, perhaps alongside Andre Braugher (“Brooklyn Nine-Nine”) and Ty Burell (“Modern Family”). Matt Walsh made it through for “Veep” last year, but co-star Timothy Simons may well be in the hunt, too, along with Brian Tyree Henry from FX’s hot new series “Atlanta,” and Alec Baldwin, who could make the biggest splash overall for his “Saturday Night Live” stint.

This final season has also provided one of the most talked-about half-hours of the entire “Girls” run. “American Bitch,” a bottle episode focused on gender power struggles, features actor Matthew Rhys as a successful memoirist symptomatic of an insidious culture. The guest actor and actress fields are always a mystery early on, but the “Americans” star certainly makes a case for inclusion, as does Riz Ahmed in earlier episodes as an aloof surf instructor who changes Hannah’s life forever.

Ultimately, all of this may amount to too steep a hill for Dunham’s denouement to climb. But it still deserves one last hard look from Emmy voters as “Girls” rides off into the sunset.

The curtain finally drops on Sunday, April 16.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 15

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Jeff Dunham says:

    Never watched the show but I love watching people have full psychotic breaks at just the mere mention of the name Lena Dunham. It’s f@$#ing hilarious! I’m not supporting her in anyway but I am mentally sound enough to hear Lena’s name and not have to be locked into a padded room to cool down.

  2. anon says:

    Thank JAHOWAH this deranged, narcissistic tripe is leaving the airwaves. Please please please no reunion movies in which the girls reunite at Coachella! The writing in this show is atrocious – well versed in greeting card platitudes proffered by Manhattan behavioral therapists, with zero insight. Were these characters supposed to be sociopaths? After so many seasons, I just don’t know – but I do know I never, ever cared. Don’t go away mad…just go away

  3. Mona martinez says:

    Please bring the walking dead back and get the deal over with and negrate do that i can work and i need a job bad the walking dead season 8 wants to began fliming and i wanna began working and go to war so that i can kill negan and jadis

  4. wane says:

    Lena def deserves an Emmy! Best Dramedy on tv next to Shameless..

  5. Rena Moretti says:

    It makes a strong case for Worst Series Ever. and Most Connected writer-producer-actress with the Least Talent ever…

    What a joke the US TV industry has become.

  6. BD says:

    Yes on everything. Except maybe the Jemima Kirke part. Dunham screwed up with Jessa and specially Soshanna. They had nothing to do. But yeah, Dunham, Driver, Ahmed and Rhys deserve their nominations. A big YES to Rannells too.

    A writing directing nod for some truly good episodes will also be welcomed.

  7. Rose McGowan says:

    season 5 was better. And I can’t believe they might nominate Allison or Jemima before Zosia. It’s criminal that Zosia was given nothing to do this season until yesterday’s episode. I bet Dunham had an argument with her or something. Shosh is the best! (Well, Adam Driver is the best, but he’s got a much better film career to worry about now, so we know why his character has gotten less screen time).

  8. Marie says:

    Media: Stop trying to make Girls happen. It’s over.

  9. Ivan says:

    They lost me years ago after I realized there were no positive characteristics in any of the 4 leads.

    Who needs people with that much drama and dishonesty in their life?

  10. No... says:

    This show is not Emmy worthy. It is a prententious, self-involved show that preaches to a very small audience of pretentious, self-involved people.

    C’mon–as a evolved society, aren’t we happy that Lena’s 15 minutes are finally up?

    • Rena Moretti says:

      Lena Dunham exemplifies what connections and money can do in Hollywood: a horribly bad show that its network has been trying to force-feed unsuccessfully on the American public for six long years.

      She has nothing whatsoever to say other than platitudes and fake-edginess.

      She should not have gotten a second, let alone 15 minutes!

      HBO also shot its reputation in the foot promoting her for so long. Only in Hollywood do people think HBO is special. In the rest of the country they have to give away HBO as a (poor) enticement to sign up for cable or satellite!

More TV News from Variety