‘The Keepers’ Is the Best True-Crime Docuseries Yet

The Keepers
Courtesy of Netflix

The Netflix docuseries should be a model for others — it avoids the mistakes that "Serial," "Making A Murderer," and "The Jinx" made

One of the most distinctive characteristics of Netflix’s “The Keepers,” a seven-part docuseries that premiered May 19, is that nearly every speaking character is a middle-aged woman. This is rare enough that it begins to be surprising, and soon after that, it becomes one of the defining elements of the show — following an interviewee into her living room as she is accompanied by her five small dogs, or reminiscing with another about her loving husband, now deceased. The B-roll notices things like the decorations on the walls, the family photos on the mantle, and the niceties of small talk. These are no Hollywood-friendly million-dollar kitchens, or carefully composed sitcom living rooms. The subjects of “The Keepers” keep cozy homes, in an unassuming, uncontrived way that indicates much about them. In this largely Catholic, working-to-middle class community of Baltimore, “The Keepers” manages to convey a mindset and shared, accepted values by just following the interviewees home.

“The Keepers” tells the true story of the unsolved murder of Sister Catherine Cesnik, a young nun and high school teacher who disappeared in late 1969 only to be found dead two months later. Her disappearance was followed a few days later by another murder of another young woman named Joyce Malecki. Both cases remain unsolved. But Cesnik and Malecki had in common a connection to a powerful local priest, Father Joseph Maskell. As Cesnik’s former students started to ask questions about what happened, they began to uncover a shocking legacy of sexual abuse and coercion around Maskell and the high school he and Cesnik worked at: Archbishop Keough High School, an all-girls school with a primarily Catholic student body. Two former students of Sister Cathy’s, Abbie Schaub and Gemma Hoskins, started a Facebook page and a tip line. A third, who remained anonymous for years to protect her reputation, comes forward in “The Keepers” to identify herself as Jean Wehner, one of Maskell’s most-abused victims who had repressed much of what happened to her. Schaub, Hoskins, and Wehner work together to compile information, pursue leads, and corroborate Wehner’s own disturbing memories.

“The Keepers” emerged from a recent mushrooming resurgence in true-crime docuseries that began with the podcast “Serial,” an investigation into a murder conviction that became an unlikely sensation. Journalist Sarah Koenig, who hosted “Serial,” was able to tap into the fact that listeners wanted to see an investigation unfold in real-time, as she demonstrated how difficult it is to find the truth amidst imperfect memory, lost evidence, and conflicting stories. Koenig gets very close to her subjects in the first season of “Serial,” which meant that audiences could hear convicted murderer Adnan Syed explain his own defense as she and her producers tried to recreate victim Hae Min Lee’s final day. At the same time, Koenig’s investigation of the material sparked some controversy; she was as limited by her perspective as Syed was by his, and it’s only late in the season, following listener responses, that she explored the sorely needed racial context of the story.

“Serial’s” success and its failures are indicative of the endemic problems in the true-crime format. First: The investigator is always implicated in the ultimate conclusion. Koenig’s biases shaped the story of “Serial.” Andrew Jarecki’s similarities to Robert Durst — they’re both the sons of New York real estate tycoons — led Durst to trust Jarecki and agree to participate in “The Jinx.” Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos, the filmmakers of “Making A Murderer,” have repeatedly indicated that they are absolutely convinced of their subject Steven Avery’s innocence — to the point that they eliminated implicating evidence against him from their 10-hour first season.

Second: Because of how murder works, the audience only ever hears from the living — who in these stories are all suspected murderers. The victims — Lee in “Serial,” Kathleen Durst in “The Jinx,” and Teresa Halbach in “Making a Murderer,” among others — don’t get to build the relationship with the audience the way that Syed, Durst, and Avery get to. It makes for an inherently lopsided narrative, unless it’s addressed by the production.

And lastly, because of the nature of storytelling, true-crime stories are hampered by the rather human desire for a neat ending. “The Jinx,” in this regard, sets the bar for every other docuseries, because it backed into an once-in-a-lifetime denouement, in one of the most startling final episodes in television history — a confession recorded on a live microphone. But most stories about cold cases will not luck into such stunning circumstances. And that can mean trying to force a convenient arc through the same lack of clarity that was there when the story started.

Audiences don’t always pick up on these pitfalls at first — and indeed, sometimes, these pitfalls make for intriguing viewing. With “Serial,” Koenig’s unstable relationship with Syed makes for some of the most fascinating exchanges in the podcast, and certainly “The Jinx” wouldn’t be the “The Jinx” if Jarecki and Durst didn’t have their odd affinity towards each other. But the true-crime nonfiction format relies on a covenant of trust between the storyteller and the audience, just like journalism. When that is damaged, it’s not just the missteps that get rejected — it’s the whole story. So it was with “Making a Murderer.” The docuseries first inspired huge public support for Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey, as the filmmakers had hoped; shortly thereafter, it spawned a backlash precisely because it was biased — entrenching the support for Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey’s convictions, when the docuseries hoped to exonerate them.

“The Keepers” is a gutting story that is told well, but it is especially admirable for avoiding so many of these pitfalls. It’s the most journalistically sound docuseries of those that have followed the vogue of “Serial” — the most comprehensive and relentlessly contextualizing, even when narrative exigency would reward bias. Amidst the mundane, intimate lives of these ordinary women is one of the most radically progressive stories on television — of a victim-led, digitally facilitated, community-driven call for justice against the wealthiest and oldest institution in the Western world. Cesnik and Malecki can’t speak for themselves — and Maskell, too, is now dead. But the former students who were abused at his hands can speak, and do.

“The Keepers” manages to tap into the informal but incredibly effective network of women that Schaub and Hoskins create: Women who call into the tip line or post on Facebook with their own stories of abuse, their own memories of Sister Cesnik, or even recollections of how their ex-husbands or distant uncles had come home the night of the nun’s disappearance with a bloody shirt and a flimsy excuse. In a detail that would be implausible in a fiction story, Schaub and Hoskins are floored when not one but two different women reach out saying they have uncles that they think could have killed Cesnik. In another anecdote, Wehner’s family describes how they sought more data on the students attending Keough, and they laugh over how simple it was: Her sister-in-law just went to the school and asked nicely.

Wehner, with her unshakable courage and sincerity, quickly becomes the heart of the docuseries. Because she is so compelling, it would have been easy to gloss over how farfetched some of her story sounds. But director Ryan White — who is himself a part of the community (his aunt was a student of Cesnik’s) — instead chooses to guide the viewer through a measured assessment of repressed memories. Similarly, when most of the evidence points towards one scenario, “The Keepers” doesn’t settle for that conclusion; the series ends with a few possible guilty parties, rigorously identified and researched. And to paraphrase my colleague Maureen Ryan, who reviewed the series, White’s especial skill is his restraint: It is the overlapping voices and stories that take center stage, not the filmmakers’ narratives.

Ultimately, the story of “The Keepers” is of how difficult it is for even a concerted community effort to combat the crisis management of the Catholic Church; in that sense, it is a little like a longer and less glitzy “Spotlight.” Like “Serial,” “Making A Murderer,” and “The Jinx,” “The Keepers” is an engaged docuseries that gives the impression of investigating in real-time; the audience is pulled into this quest for truth, and is given ample room to come to their own conclusions. But the real takeaway is that in centering the women, “The Keepers” is more authentically about justice than any of its contemporary predecessors. It’s considered and responsible. And it ends, not with a pointed finger, but with Wehner’s voice, pledging her dedication to keep speaking until every powerless person can be heard by the world. This is a docuseries that others should model their approach on.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 11

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Bliss2200 says:

    I wonder how long it would take to find out the killer if the murder victim was Joseph Maskell??!!??

  2. Beth Miller says:

    My question is who types a love letter? Her sister commented she had such beautiful handwriting.

  3. Mary Mueller says:

    I am the disfigured flip-side of RCC sex trafficking: MUNCHAUSEN BY PROXY medical trafficking of “sexually unworthy” women and children for abstinence enforcement — “ankle bracelet” Magdalene laundry and secret septic tank mass grave punishment for the sexual sins of “sexually worthy” priests, nuns and wealthy donors. Late playboy pastor of Immaculate Deception in Towson, MD / Orioles chaplain Monsignor Martin Schwallenberg ordered my NFP-ruined mother to burn me head to toe as HER abstinence forever excuse while he banged Orioles’ wives. Authorities should investigate the RCC for ordering Munchausen by Proxy deaths and injuries of mothers in Catholic hospitals and disabilities in their unwanted children as abstinence enforcement. “Sexually unworthy” Rosemary Kennedy is a famous example of “ankle bracelet” Magdalene laundry / Munchausen by Proxy imposed disability and abstinence enforcement. Gypsy Rose Blanchard of “Mommy Dead and Dearest” is another example. My childbirth-ruined Munchausen by Proxy perp mom tortured me with total body disfigurement initially to prevent my fed-up non-Catholic dad from divorcing her over RCC abstinence only “birth control.” When I began rebelling like Gypsy Rose, she insisted I stay disfigured as abstinence enforcement on me. Abortion is a million times kinder. Statutes of limitation laws completely fail us RCC Munchausen by Proxy victims.

  4. Having attended the subject school, Archbishiop Keogh, “the jewel of Baltimore”, I give this documentary 10 out of 10 stars. You told it like it was. We are ashamed that his happened but remain as one, classmates/sisters who support our friends who were abused.

  5. Leigh says:

    This is a riveting series. It is an expose on bias that existed in the “system” and a lesson on the effects of bias, even today. You will not be able to stop watching this true story. These are brave women.

  6. heidi says:

    I agree that this is the best true crime series so far. I’m surprised that most of the emphasis in reviews focuses on the injustice of the Archdiocese and not the police force. Two unsolved murders, lost evidence, police abusing girls with Maskal; basically the county and city police totally botching it for decades. That upsets maybe more than the church cover up.

    • Mary Mueller says:

      It’s far worse than you think: the RCC also partnered with big pharma and the Pentagon to exploit orphans, the disabled, students and patients (especially “sinful” mothers) for ruinous involuntary medical experiments. My despicable Munchausen by Proxy Catholic mother knew that RADIUM-PAINTED rosaries and Virgin Mary statues caused my mild hand rash, but she hid this ugly truth from me and obeyed playboy Immaculate Deception pastor Schwallenberg by selling me for total body-burning radiation experiments at Johns Hopkins as HER “holy marital abstinence forever” excuse because of the pedophile priest ban on maternal life-saving contraception. The RCC runs a nasty Nazi sexual caste system of hypocrite sexual worthies (priests, nuns, police, politicians, billionaires) and oppressed sexual “unworthies” (the rest of us). This is why we suffer the schizophrenic extremes of both forced rapes (Maskell victims) and forced abstinence (Magdalene laundries, Munchausen by Proxy injuries, no contraception, and LGBTI body shaming).

    • Nina says:

      And that Maskell’s brother was on the police force, and that some victims identified the abusers Maskell brought into his office as police officers…

      The police are definitely covering up for one of their own here.

  7. Anthony Pignataro says:

    Loved it.. Would love to see a follow-up in a year or so

  8. Tim says:

    It does suck that they all got away with it.

  9. Margaret Guzman says:

    A TRULY GUT WRENCHING DOCUSERIES. Told with such feeling and depth, how horrible for those caught up in the monster’s grip. How disgraceful that it is still unsolved and not acknowledged by those who could have lessened the horror.

More TV News from Variety