Four Ways the Entertainment Industry Can Counter Trump’s Narrative of Muslims (Opinion)

Master of None
Courtesy of Netflix

Suhad (Sue) Obeidi, Director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council’s Hollywood Bureau (MPAC), addresses the next steps for the film and television industries to take after many industry figures denounced the Executive Order targeting predominantly Muslim countries. Obeidi has worked with industry executives to reduce stereotyped depictions of Islam and of Muslims and present more accurate and humanizing portrayals. She also organizes the annual MPAC Media Awards, which salute works from film and TV as well as individuals.

Ever since President Trump signed the Muslim Ban Executive Order, I have seen many representatives of the entertainment industry come together to support a community that the very same industry has vilified for decades.

Having said that, as an American-Muslim woman and the Director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council’s Hollywood Bureau, I have been overwhelmed by the support of the industry in standing up for the universal values of freedom, human dignity and justice for all citizens of the world, including, and this time, especially for Muslims. Of course, celebrities have a long history of political activism. That is no surprise. The big surprise is that now more celebrities are speaking up to defend my community.  From public statements by celebrities like Ashton Kutcher and Julia Louis-Dreyfus, to those who attended protests at airports like Ellen Page, Tim Robbins and Amy Schumer, to the Guilds denouncing the anti-immigration policy in their statements. I must say, the exponentially increased support feels good and it is very much appreciated.

So why does it feel so good right now for the industry to defend and regard Muslims with such terms of inclusion? The answer for me and my organization is simple. Like other vulnerable communities — African-American, Hispanic and LGBTQ, for example, in general, we have not been authentically and accurately portrayed in film and television. When we were “humanized” in stories, it was under the pretense of “tolerance.” The “other” was being “tolerated” and that was supposed to be enough. Human beings should never have to tolerate one another. We are not a pain to be tolerated. And that is when I understood why it felt so good. The Executive Order created a sense of acceptance, respect and inclusion of Muslims. It was finally cool to be Muslim in America. And that is a new feeling to me.

It took a humanitarian crisis and an impulsive and erratic man in the White House to get us here, so now what do we do to keep moving forward? Well, as a member of the industry, I believe we should start “normalizing” Muslim characters just like we did when the industry “normalized” a member of the gay community. “Modern Family” and “The Real O’Neals” didn’t just appear on television without a long struggle with the industry to “normalize” the LGBTQ community. Those shows follow the groundbreaking work of ABC’s “Soap” in the 1970s and Fox’s “Party of Five” in the 1990s.

This is what I want for Muslims.  I want to see a Muslim character who doesn’t have negative baggage or a cloud of suspicion over his/her head. The good news is that this is slowly beginning to happen. We now have Hasan Minhaj (“The Daily Show”), Aziz Ansari (“Master of None”), Riz Ahmed (“The Night Of”), and Yasmine Al Massri (“Quantico”). But we need to speed up this “normalization,” as it is the way we will become off limits to rogue Executive Orders like the one we saw recently. It is going to take a lot of collaborative work between the Muslim and entertainment communities. But because Muslims are standing on the shoulders of giants in other marginalized communities, and because the door has already been cracked open for us, I  think the process of  amplifying our voices will be faster. But it is not going to come easy. Here is what needs to happen:

— We need to work together to have a collective impact on the narrative because portraying better, authentic and accurate stories is not “doing us a favor” — it is simply good business for the industry to represent what the real world looks like. But this responsibility should not be taken lightly. We all know the painful consequences of vilifying a faith and a community.

— If you are a producer, director, or a screenwriter, please reach out to us when your project involves Muslim characters or storylines. MPAC’s Hollywood Bureau has consulted on many high-profile projects and we will be happy to consult on many others. We do not act as watchdogs, but give creatives the opportunity to tell better stories by providing them with accurate information about Islam and Muslims.

— Muslim screenwriters should be included as staff writers when there is a storyline that involves Muslims or Islam. There is plenty of Muslim talent in the industry, so reach out to them. If you need help, reach out to us. One writer is not enough. There should be no fewer than three writers creating Muslim characters in order to accurately represent the community, otherwise, there will be too much lost in translation.

— If you are a Dean of a Theater, Film, and Television Department at a major university, encourage your students to do their due diligence and educate themselves on the subjects they are writing about.  Audiences are intelligent and can see through thin facades.

I have so much hope in the power of storytelling and its impact on shaping opinions, values and actions. I have so much hope that our work together will impact the narrative in a positive manner and save lives in the process.  Despite what is happening in Washington, D.C., I have so much hope that we will come out of this as a stronger nation. I have so much hope in the American spirit and the pluralism of America.

But we must work together to create stories that reflect what America really looks like, to understand each other and to save the soul of America, together.

(pictured: “Master of None,” starring Aziz Ansari)

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 12

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. J.T. Chance says:

    Where is the dissent against radical Islamism from within Islam? Where are the protests, the marches, the riots, the satirical art, the books, the articles, the freedom of expression against the tyranny and oppression of men, women, children, and most of all, of ideas and freedom of thought? At least this article is a start…

  2. William M Collins says:

    This “humanizing” and “normalization” is nothing more than deceitful propaganda.

    • Sarfa says:

      You have audacity to ask which other religion is killing, even after recent burning down of Muslim mosque by Christian fanatics in Texas —- killing of six Muslims in Quebec by Christian terrorist supporter of Trump. Everyday Muslims are attacked in Europe and USA – three mosques were burnt in Texas by Americans and other hate attacks – shame on hypocrite American bigots

  3. eddie willers says:

    Reforming your church would be a start.

  4. Jo Mama says:

    The very headline is unforgivable, and transparent. Here’s the subtext: “How can we change the way people think?” That’s not your job, entertainment is. You deny for years that you try to sway public opinion, but all you have to do is read your headline and not be empty-headed.

    If your cause and message is a just one, WHY DOES IT NEED SUBTLE MESSAGING IN OUR ENTERTAINMENT??????????????????????????????

    Present your case in the proper forum of public discourse. Don’t go after the minds of people in a hidden fashion, where you often target young people and shape their minds in a secret way. If your argument is so valid, and your message so honorable, why do you employ such trickery?

  5. Jo Mama says:

    Because of some insidious mindset that gives people license to look down on others – in the argument that we should all be treated the same. WTF???

    It’s clear to the entire world that the “progressive” left is bending over backwards for a culture that utterly embraces wholesale violence against women and sexualization of children.

    • Sarfa says:

      what about your Christian majority USA bombing and destroying and killing and droning Muslim countries? America has not rape crimes in the world after India – just because your mainstream media is not showing white Christian American who rapists, killers, gangs, smugglers etc doesn’t mean the world doesn’t know.

  6. som says:

    Islam is not a cult but the second largest religion in the world and the fastest growing religion. Islam does not oppress women but gave women unprecedented right to education, divorce, child support, inheritance, ability to own property and financial freedom . Do not be confused and judge Islam by the misbehavior of some people called Muslims. Steal wealth? It is a pillar and requirement of Islam to give zakat- a percentage of your wealth to the poor. Kills gays? Killing in general! “…if any one killed a person, it would be as if he killed the whole of mankind; and if any one saved a life, it would be as if he saved the life of the whole of mankind…” – The Holy Quran (Chapter Five, Verse 32).

    • Jo Mama says:

      The Quran evolves as Mohammed grows older and more aggressive. The peaceful beginning is just that – the beginning. It goes on to tell you that his final understanding rises above his beliefs at the beginning. Once you understand this, no flowery quotations can counter it. This is also how the religion has so many permutations, and one devout Muslim can be a peaceful person, while another is a rapist and killer. And the fact that the “peaceful” are the majority is completely irrelevant. They don’t do anything to stop the radical portion, and are complicit in their savagery. Also, when there are over a billion of them, that radical fraction is a massive number of belligerent barbarians the size of the population of South America.

      • Sarfa says:

        More gun-rotting Americans are shooting each other dead and injured every day of the year for century and half… So you have no right to preach about savagery and barbarism here.

  7. Jef says:

    The narrative of truth? They oppress woman. Kill gays. Steal wealth. Destroy art. Trump or no Trump they are what they are, an outdated cult that no one wants in a western society. Stop with the propaganda Hollywood until you do you’ll never regain power.

    • Sarfa says:

      Your post proves that you are not what you are trying to be part of the western society with uncivilised and bigotry flowing from your mouth.

More TV News from Variety