Broadway Review: ‘The Play That Goes Wrong,’ Produced by J.J. Abrams

The Play That Goes Wrong review
Alastair Muir

The show must go on — but in the Broadway transfer of West End hit “The Play That Goes Wrong,” forgotten lines, lost props, technical gaffes and rebellious scenery all seem to reply, “Oh no it doesn’t.” This broad, silly and deliciously demented show, about a fictitious amateur theatrical group with great resilience and greater incompetency, is by the Brit trio of Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields in a style that evokes “Fawlty Towers” with nods to Buster Keaton, Carol Burnett and Monty Python. Under the go-for-broke direction of Mark Bell, its high-energy cast is comic gold and manages to sustain, with a never-ending series of diversionary tactics, its one-joke concept.


J.J. Abrams Broadway

How ‘The Force Awakens’ Got J.J. Abrams to Broadway

The show isn’t as elegant or as clever as that other hit British show-run-amuck farce, “Noises Off!,” whose last revival was seen on the Broadway just last season. “Wrong” isn’t interested in the relationship between its characters and the ones they portray in the play-within-a-play. It’s more lowbrow, interested in the gag and shameless in how it gets it: sometimes incredibly inventively, but sometimes going for the low-hanging fruit. (A special nod goes to sound designer Andrew Johnson who created the various bonks, splats, and crashes.)

The play follows the woeful troupe as it tries to build a better mousetrap with its presentation of a dusty murder mystery, whose plot happily gets lost along the way as the production implodes. Though it could benefit from some cutting, the production is an idiot’s delight. It should also prove a boon when it hits the provinces, despite engineering challenges of the screw-loose set ingeniously designed by Nigel Hook.

It’s clear from the beginning — even before the beginning with its pre-show shtick — that wrong will be just right. But it takes a while before the laughs come at full speed.

Among the misguided characters in the play-within-a-play are a lively corpse (Greg Tannahill), an exasperated detective (Shields, in a performance that John Cleese might admire), a word-mangling butler (Sayer) who is, of course, in charge of the dense exposition, and a sound man (Ron Falconer) who is more interested in listening to Duran Duran than he is in the show at hand.

Then there’s novice actor Max (a sweetly loopy Dave Hearn), the bearish actor Robert (Lewis), a painfully shy stage manager (Nancy Zamit) who finds her calling when she is enlisted to act after Sandra (Charlie Russell), the female lead, becomes incapacitated in one of the play’s most outrageous and hysterical bits.

Pity the replacement cast that succeeds this troupe, which has had years together perfecting its timing, physical gags and carefully choreographed mayhem. “Break a leg” could take on a whole new meaning.

Broadway Review: 'The Play That Goes Wrong,' Produced by J.J. Abrams

Lyceum Theater; 950 seats; $139 top; opens April 2, 2017; reviewed March 29. Running time: 2 HOURS


A Kevin McCollum, J.J. Abrams, Kenny Wax, Stage Presence Ltd., Catherine Schreiber, Kevin Davenport, Double Gemini Productions/deRoy-Brunish, Damian Arnold/TC Beech, Greenleaf Productions/Brad-Roth, Martian Entertainment/Jack Lane/ John Yonover, Lucas McMahon presentation of a play in two acts by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields.


Directed by Mark Bell; sets, Nigel Hook; costumes, Roberto Surace, lighting, Ric Mountjoy; sound, Andy Johnson; original music, Rob Falconer; production stage manager, Matt DiCarlo.


Rob Falconer, Dave Hearn, Henry Lewis, Charlie Russell, Jonathan Sayer, Henry Shields, Greg Tannahill, and Nancy Zamit.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 5

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. rob wunder says:

    funny three stooges type humor for several minutes, but “hysterically repetitive” is the oxymoron that dooms this otherwise funny five minute sketch agonizingly and expensively stretched to a couple of hours. I cannot vouch for the second half as my wife and I left for spicy noodles up the street at halftime. The spicy and just-made noodles at Xi’an Famous Foods are just as repetitive as every joke and gag of this play, but somehow I still want more.

  2. Lenore says:

    The audience loved the performance I attended last night, with laughter, whoops, applause and hollering. I got caught up for a while but it was just too silly. I had seen NOISES OFF last year and that was so superior, even with similar physical gags. NO was just a better play.
    But…..many obviously disagreed with me….

    • Norman Duncan says:

      The most disappointing theatrical experience I’ve ever attended. Completely lacking in subtlety or invention. After the few few minutes it was about as entertaining as yesterday’s weather report.

  3. Mary Tierney says:

    Total delight when you leave your NYC cynicism and ‘sophistication,’ behind and d suspension of disbelief. . . And ‘become asa little child.’

    Mary Tierney
    And thanks to Frank Craven who brought me as husband AEA guest!

  4. Tom says:

    May be like The Three Stooges without Curly. But good comedies are hard to find and I hope this will be a big hit.

More Legit News from Variety