Broadway’s Shubert Organization Nixes Plans for New Theater

The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district.

It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in a recent interview with Shubert chairman and co-CEO Philip J. Smith. “It got too complicated.”

Broadway real estate is at a premium, making the prospect of a new theater a tantalizing one. With the massive revenue streams of megahits like “The Lion King,” “Wicked” and now “Hamilton” attracting new interest in producing — both from individuals and from movie studios — the crop of projects angling for a midtown theater is at a seemingly unprecedented high. And with big hits running much, much longer than popular shows did in prior decades (see: “The Phantom of the Opera,” “The Lion King,” “Chicago”), houses open up for new shows much less frequently.

But according to Shubert leadership, the complications of building a new theater in a planned residential tower in midtown — between 45th and 46th Streets, beside the Imperial Theater and just east of Eighth Avenue — proved insurmountable. The cost of the theater would easily have hit $150 million or more.

“It was more the complexity of the development, which is in part a cost factor, but it was also just getting too difficult to incorporate the theater into the new building in a way that made it economically feasible,” Wankel said. “It was an opportunity, but we just didn’t think, in the end, it would work, much as we tried.”

Still, with the theater industry as robust as it currently is, Broadway could use another venue — and the Shuberts haven’t ruled out the possibility of trying again in the future. “Oh, sure, we would always consider it,” Wankel said.

More Legit

  • Hello, Dolly! Bette Midler

    Broadway Box Office: Bette Midler, Bruce Springsteen Help Keep Street's Spirits High

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • Keegan-Michael Key

    Stagecraft Podcast: Why Keegan-Michael Key Craves the Green Lights

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • RWS Entertainment Group Marquee Holland America

    RWS Entertainment Launches Theatrical Development Department (EXCLUSIVE)

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • John Lithgow Stories By Heart

    Broadway Review: 'John Lithgow: Stories by Heart'

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • Lin-Manuel Miranda

    Lin-Manuel Miranda to Receive Monte Cristo Award (EXCLUSIVE)

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • Allan-Corduner Murder on the Orient Express

    'Crazy,' 'Murder' and More on Playwright Ken Ludwig's Packed Plate

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

  • Stephen Adly Guirgis

    Stagecraft Podcast: Stephen Adly Guirgis Talks Writing, Acting and 'The Get Down'

    The Shubert Organization, the company that owns 17 Broadway theaters, has given up efforts to construct a new Broadway venue on West 45th Street, after years of working to add one more house to the theater district. “It’s not going to happen,” said Robert E. Wankel, the president and co-CEO of the Shubert Org, in […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content