Telluride Film Review: Saoirse Ronan in ‘Lady Bird’

'Lady Bird' Review: Greta Gerwig's Semi-Autobiographical
Courtesy of Toronto Film Festival

In the decade since her mumblecore origins, Greta Gerwig has found her voice, applying that unselfconscious honesty to her directorial debut.

By the time you read this, you’ll probably have a pretty good idea of what the movie “Lady Bird” is about, seeing as how it’s the kind of modest, miraculous low-budget gem that takes on a life of its own. But sight unseen, the title sounded a lot like a sequel to last year’s “Jackie,” seeing as how LBJ succeeded JFK in office, and Lady Bird was the name of his wife. Turns out Lady Bird was also the name restless high school senior Christine McPherson picked for herself — a first act of defiance in a battle to assert her own identity as separate from her parents.

“Lady Bird” is indie darling (and one-time mumblecore muse) Greta Gerwig’s directorial debut, and the character is basically her, 15 years younger and played by Saoirse Ronan, sporting a vampire-red rinse and a face full of acne (both signs of its attention to detail). Early Telluride reactions seem particularly impressed that such an accomplished film could be anybody’s first, although those who’ve been following Gerwig’s career surely saw it coming: She’s been starring in, co-writing and even co-directing smart, soul-baring dramedies for more than a decade. The real surprise is just how honest and personal this film proves to be — again, par for the course with Gerwig, and yet, fairly rare among first-time directors, who haven’t had nearly so much practice simply being real.

Just think, it took Mike Mills 11 years to work up to examining that chapter of his life in “20th Century Women,” a movie in which Gerwig played a key supporting role, and a spiritual model for this richly complicated homage to her own mother (a once-in-a-lifetime part for Laurie Metcalf). But the more appropriate comparison might be to “Frances Ha,” which also turns on a young woman’s what’s-in-a-name coming-of-age concerns.

The only thing missing from “Lady Bird” is Gerwig herself, although one could argue that she inhabits every frame of this movie, and especially those in which Ronan appears — that’s how thoroughly the young Irish actress channels her Sacramento-raised writer-director. And wouldn’t it be great if this were but the first instance of a career-long series of stand-ins, the way Woody Allen casts stammering act-alikes to basically play him on screen? Not that you have to be familiar with any of Gerwig’s previous roles to appreciate “Lady Bird,” and considering the college-age demographic to which this A24 release is most likely to appeal, the vast majority probably won’t have seen a single one.

Absorbing Gerwig’s mannerisms and way of speaking, Ronan comes across as a bright young woman who feels as if she’s only experienced a fraction of what life has to offer. She also looks less like a Greta than she does a Lady Bird. The self-selected nickname not only suits her character — fancifully girlish, yet eagerly anticipating womanhood — but is a lot less eccentric than the affectations other screenwriters invent to distinguish their oddball teen characters (say, Bud Cort’s faux suicides in “Harold and Maude” or Paul Dano’s notebook writing in “Little Miss Sunshine”).

Gerwig isn’t being quirky merely for the sake of being quirky, but to make a point, and that point is: How’s a middle-class gal with average grades and no hobbies supposed to distinguish herself from her parents, much less her peers? There’s the Manic Panic red hair, of course, but beyond that, “Lady Bird” is about that universal late-teen need to reject our parents’ advice and to pave our own way, even at the cost of making a few easily avoidable mistakes. Only then do most of us come to appreciate how right our parents may have been.

In the opening scene, Lady Bird’s mom (Metcalf, in her meatiest role since “Roseanne”) is chaperoning her on a college tour, basically any school within driving radius of Sacramento, where the McPhersons live modestly (unemployed dad Tracy Letts and adopted brother Jordan Rodrigues round out the family) and send their daughter to a private school on scholarship. Like so many movie teens, Lady Bird really wants to get as far away from home as possible. She believes that she has outgrown Sacramento — as Gerwig must have felt when she herself went off to college — but in truth, the movie doubles as a sweet homage to a city seldom depicted on screen (coincidentally, it’s also where Ben Stiller lives in college-application comedy “Brad’s Status”).

Loosely structured and jauntily paced, the events of “Lady Bird” span the 2002 school year — although the film inexplicably skips from prom to its freshman-year coda at the end, breezing by the last summer at home when so many coming-of-age films unfold. It’s a genre that’s already been explored from practically every angle, though as a writer, Gerwig shows a gift for specificity that turns her first audition, first kiss and first heartbreak into singular events.

Treating each of its characters with respect no how small their parts, Gerwig’s script derives much of its comedy from the nun-run Eternal Flame school (where Lady Bird’s grades aren’t that good, and she has no lasting hobbies to speak of), and to a lesser degree, her friendship woes and romantic disappointments. While nowhere near as sassy as Diablo Cody nor as self-assured as Lena Dunham, “Lady Bird” comes from a fundamentally genuine place — as evidenced by the character’s betrayal of lifelong bestie Jules (charismatic newcomer Beanie Feldstein).

The movie is also frank — and funny — about the awkwardness of first-time sexual experiences, and casts realistic actors as Lady Bird’s two senior crushes: theater geek Danny (“Manchester by the Sea” breakout Lucas Hedges) and aloof rocker Kyle (Timothée Chalamet). But the relationship that matters most is the one between Lady Bird and her mother, based in love but increasingly combative as young Christine asserts her own identity — felt from the first scene, when Lady Bird throws herself out of the moving car when her mom’s nagging becomes too much, with the consequence that she wears a bright pink cast for at least half the movie.

Metcalf has never had a big-screen role as rich as this, and she makes the most of it, playing a character who doesn’t hold back in criticizing her daughter’s faults (from academics to future job prospects), but works double shifts in the psych ward to provide for her future. On the surface, she’s tough on Lady Bird, but Metcalf manages to communicate between each line how it all comes from a place of caring. The big showdown between them involves Lady Bird’s choice of college, and what will become of the family if she goes off to the east coast. Gerwig may have flown the nest, but “Lady Bird” is proof that she hasn’t forgotten where she came from.

Telluride Film Review: Saoirse Ronan in 'Lady Bird'

Reviewed at Telluride Film Festival, Sept. 3, 2017. (Also in Toronto Film Festival — Special Presentations.) Running time: 94 MIN.


An A24 release, presented with IAC Films. Producers: Scott Rudin, Eli Bush, Evelyn O'Neill. Executive producer: Lila Yacoub. Co-producers: Alex Scott, Jason Sack.


Director, screenplay: Greta Gerwig. Camera (color): Sam Levy. Editor: Nick Houy. Music: Jon Brion.


Saoirse Ronan, Laurie Metcalf, Tracy Letts, Lucas Hedges, Timothée Chalamet, Beanie Feldstein, Lois Smith, Stephen McKinley Henderson, Odeya Rush, Jordan Rodrigues, Marielle Scott, Jake McDorman, John Karna, Bayne Gibby, Laura Marano.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 8

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. stevenkovacs says:

    Saw ‘Lady Bird’ at TIFF, and it is an absolute joy! Greta Gerwig has become a powerhouse talent of acting, writing and directing!
    Saoirse Ronan nails it as the quirky young woman struggling to become the best version of herself. The entire cast (minus Saoirse, sadly!) was present and received a robust ovation of applause as they were perfect!
    I was lucky to have been picked for the Q&A and asked Greta if she had to choose between acting or directing in it and she explained she couldn’t handle directing herself so no way to starring in it.
    I also asked how did she decided upon casting Irish actress Saoirse Ronan in the lead role of Christine ‘Lady Bird’ McPherson, and she explained, to the joy of the audience, that it was at TIFF 2015 she was attending for ‘Maggie’s Plan’ and Saoirse for ‘Brooklyn’, and decided to call Saoirse at hotel to meet. They did, and as they were doing a reading of the script, Greta knew Saoirse was perfect as she quickly understood the part and watched her make it her own very quickly. So Greta thanked TIFF for its role in the casting and making of ‘Lady Bird’!
    A must see dramedy!

  2. Oktag grace says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch Lady bird 2017 Full Movie- Sub (4k Ultra HD only premium) Leaked !
    Play Now or Download ►► enjoy it !

  3. Kevin Mcgue says:

    Saoirse Ronan was actually born in New York (to Irish parents).

  4. Irish! Saoirse Ronan is Irish!!!

  5. Okay, okay, aside from the nationality fuck-up, I’m delighted by this review. Particularly enthused by your glowing plaudits for Metcalf, whom I’m beginning to believe has a genuine shot in the Supporting Actress category, at least for her first nomination. Love her. But it also seems like Ronan makes a good case for obtaining a lead Actress slot too. I see a Comedy/Musical Golden Globe win more likely than an Oscar win. And I hope, realllllly hope, Gerwig can nab an Original Screenplay slot. I honestly thought she was robbed of a nomination for Frances Ha. (Tough year though. So was Brie Larson from Short Term 12, and meanwhile the 5 nominees were all worthy.) Regardless of Oscar potential, I’m eager to see this. Hope we get a trailer soon!

  6. Reeder says:

    Scottish no! Even though she will be playing Mary Queen Of Scots, the lass is definitively Irish!

  7. Lara says:

    She`s Irish, not Scottish.

  8. Tomas Toal says:

    Scottish actress?????? Scottish? And, Variety is the best Peruvian showbiz publication out there

More Film News from Variety