Film Review: Stephen King’s ‘It’

It movie review
Warner Bros.

Visual flair and a solid cast keep Andy Muschietti's patchy Stephen King adaptation afloat.

Stephen King’s “It” has always been a tough nut to crack. Though the mammoth novel has been reduced to a few indelible images and quotes over the decades — a killer clown, a balloon, “you’ll float too” — King’s story of seven youngsters who come of age while confronting a shape-shifting demonic presence in small-town Maine, then come home as adults to deal with its return, is quite a lot of things. It’s a messy, druggy attempt to distill decades of horror tropes into a chaotic fever dream; a portrait of a fictional town as obsessively mapped as Joyce’s Dublin; a meditation on childhood, trauma, and forgetting; “In Search of Lost Time” bloodied up for the grindhouse.

The second attempt to adapt King’s 1,100-page doorstop for the screen, director Andy Muschietti’s “It” is also a lot of different things. Focusing entirely on the childhood-set portions of King’s book, it’s a collection of alternately terrifying, hallucinatory, and ludicrous nightmare imagery; a sometimes jarring pileup of moods, ranging from haunted house horror to nostalgic hangout humor; a popcorn movie about gruesome child murders; a series of well-crafted yet decreasingly effective suspense setpieces; and a series of well-acted coming-of-age sequences that don’t quite fully mature. “It” looks poised to make a killing at the box office, but there’s a fundamental hollowness that haunts the film just as surely as the titular monster haunts this small town.

Perhaps that’s inevitable, as the film is incomplete by design, punting one half of its source material to a potential sequel — and considering the film’s pre-release tracking numbers, that sequel looks like a safe bet. Much like Quentin Tarantino’s first volume of “Kill Bill” offered a delirious yet morally unmoored mixtape of kung-fu spectacle, only for the second installment to provide the context that retroactively made it all meaningful, “It” very much feels like the flashier half of a longer story. As it stands, Muschietti (along with screenwriters Chase Palmer, Gary Dauberman and previously attached director Cary Fukunaga) has remained faithful to the book’s overall mood while diverging from its particulars, and King fans will surely appreciate the clear effort and affection that went into this adaptation, even as it struggles to become more than the sum of its parts.

Related

It Movie 2017

Stephen King’s ‘It’ Arrives at a Terrifying Time for the Movie Business

Advancing the setting from the 1950s to the late 1980s, the film spans roughly nine months in the roughneck township of Derry, Maine, beginning with the brutal murder of six-year-old Georgie (Jackson Robert Scott). The novel’s famous opening sequence is largely adapted beat-for-beat, lingering with sickening unhurriedness on this sweet kid frolicking in the rain as he follows a paper boat into a storm drain, where he’s met by a sinister figure calling itself Pennywise the Dancing Clown (Bill Skarsgard), who sweet-talks him inch by inch toward his doom. It’s an upsettingly effective scene, and the rest of the film struggles to craft another with similar impact.

A few months later, Georgie’s older brother Bill (Jaeden Lieberher), wracked with guilt over sending Georgie out alone, is the last one still holding out futile hopes of finding him alive. Several other kids have since gone missing, and as school breaks for the summer, Bill enlists his clique of dorky buddies to help scout out the nearby streams for clues. His friends try their best to remain supportive, even as they’re more interested in talking about girls and avoiding the torments of the town’s psychotic bully, Henry Bowers (Nicholas Hamilton). The clan includes Richie (Finn Wolfhard), a crass, Coke-bottle-spectacled know-it-all; Eddie (Jack Dylan Grazer), an inhaler-wielding hypochondriac; and Stanley (Wyatt Oleff), a sclerotic skeptic heading unprepared into his bar mitzvah.

Their group, self-named “the Losers Club,” gradually grows to include Ben (Jeremy Ray Taylor), a shy new kid who spends his time in the library, and Mike (Chosen Jacobs), a home-schooled loner who also appears to be the only black kid in town. The biggest disruption, however, comes with the addition of Beverly (Sophia Lillis), a supremely confident, chain-smoking tomboy eager to escape her abusive home life. Both Bill and Ben are quick to fall in love with her, and the film is sensitive to the sometimes tender, sometimes unbearable awkwardness that ensues when puberty tosses a wrench into the already delicate machinery of male-female friendships.

Following the novel’s example, Muschietti has constructed a film that’s just as much “Stand by Me” as creature feature, and casting director Rich Delia goes above the call of duty assembling a group of youngsters who are every bit as funny, irritating and empathetic as the script requires. Lieberher and Lillis are particularly revelatory, their flirtations warm and believable, and Lillis bears more than just a superficial resemblance to a young Amy Adams. But Wolfhard all but steals the show as the gang’s cheerful antagonist Richie. Best known for his turn last year in “Stranger Things” — which itself shamelessly pilfered elements from “It” to more cohesive effect — the 14-year-old unleashes torrents of profanity and stupid-clever teenage quips with infectious panache.

Of course, there’s also the matter of the child-killing chthonian creature haunting their steps. One by one, It (a pronoun that gradually becomes a proper noun) appears to each of the Losers in a variety of guises, toying with them just long enough to scare them witless before reverting to its default form of Pennywise. Eventually, the kids all admit to one another that they’ve been having the same experiences, and bookish Ben connects the sinister goings-on to similar eruptions of violence throughout the history of Derry, a town where mysterious tragedy appears to strike every 27 years. Led by the increasingly committed Bill, the group resolves to fight back against It themselves, even if that means venturing into the town’s labyrinthine sewer system.

No matter how many awful fates befall “It’s” characters, the filmmaking itself is never sadistic. The action is generally clean and comprehensibly staged, with the long fun-house scene inside 29 Neibolt Street offering a particularly inventive set of scares, and composer Benjamin Wallfisch’s arsenal of spare piano pieces, breathy woodwinds and vortices of sampled children’s voices works wonders. Muschietti shares King’s love of period-appropriate rock music, though he doesn’t always use it appropriately: One potentially blood-curdling scene is bizarrely neutered by its use of the Cure’s “Six Different Ways.”

But as spine-tingling as a number of individual scenes are, the film struggles to find a proper rhythm. Scene-to-scene transitions are static and disjointed, settling into a cycle of “…and then this happened” without deepening the overall dread or steadily uncovering pieces of a central mystery. Curiously, “It” grows less intense as it goes, handicapped by an inability to take in the scope of Derry as a town defined by its buried traumas and secrets, let alone really plumbing the primal depths of fear that It itself represents. As Pennywise, Skarsgard is largely tasked with providing a canvas for the film’s visual effects, and he never manages to cast as long a shadow as Tim Curry did with the character in the 1990 TV miniseries.

The film does, however, pick up on one key element of the novel, and King’s writing in general, that often goes missing in films based on his work: the notion that young people are uniquely burdened with atoning for the inequities of the adult world. Much of “It” takes place with no parents in sight, and when adults do break into the narrative, they’re invariably drunk, cruel, manipulative and indifferent if not hostile toward the fears and worries of those they ought to be protecting. As King puts it in the novel, “adults are the real monsters,” and Muschietti has plenty of ground left to cover when we see what kinds of adults these characters become.

Film Review: Stephen King's 'It'

Reviewed at Warner Bros. studios, Burbank, Aug. 29, 2017. MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 135 MIN.

Production

A Warner Bros. release of a New Line Cinema presentation of a Vertigo Entertainment, Lin Pictures, Katzsmith production in association with Ratpac-Dune Entertainment. Producers: Roy Lee, Dan Lin, Seth Grahame-Smith, David Katzenberg, Barbara Muschietti. Executive producers: Dave Neustadter, Walter Hamada, Richard Brener, Toby Emmerich, Marty P. Ewing, Doug Davison, Jon Silk, Niija Kuykendall.

Crew

Director: Andy Muschietti. Screenplay: Chase Palmer, Cary Fukunaga, Gary Dauberman, based on the novel by Stephen King. Camera (color): Chung-Hoon Chung. Editor: Jason Ballantine. Music: Benjamin Wallfisch.

With

Jaeden Lieberher, Sophia Lillis, Jeremy Ray Taylor, Finn Wolfhard, Chosen Jacobs, Jack Dylan Grazer, Wyatt Oleff, Bill Skarsgard, Nicholas Hamilton, Jackson Robert Scott

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 101

Leave a Reply

101 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. eric says:

    to the reviewer ..it was never going to be told in one setting!! At one point it was produced to be three parts. But it seems they have settled on two. Mr. King’s stories have always had heart and this is a prime example of his genius and while no fictional writer can spin a tale quite the way he does. “IT” is a heartbreaking novel to read. They actually took it pretty easy on us so far. I don’t think we will fare so well for the conclusion.

  2. Jay says:

    What did Pennywise do with the kids he ambushed and killed?

  3. Ben Kerley says:

    ‘though he doesn’t always use it appropriately: One potentially blood-curdling scene is bizarrely neutered by its use of the Cure’s “Six Different Ways.”’ Are you joking??? that scene they are helping each other as a team. It is a beautiful use of the song.

  4. gahanam says:

    Watch It Full Movies Online Free HD ===>> http://cutt.us/upcoming enjoy!

  5. digaswae12 says:

    Watch It Full Movies Online Free HD ===>> https://plus.google.com/u/0/collection/ELciJE

  6. jane wilson says:

    I didn’t care for the time change. They should have stuck to starting it in 1958 like the book. In the 80s Bill’s bike is totally out of character and they offer no explination for it. It played a big part in the book and it should have been kept true to the time period.

  7. Bismillah says:

    Watch IT 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://sites.google.com/site/watchitfullmovieonline/

  8. Ngabulaeh says:

    Watch IT 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://t.co/j2xjJhrewn

  9. TJ says:

    Am I the only one that was disappointed in the over use of zombie/ Corpse fear illusions used, I was underwhelmed by this. Was looking forward to some more creative fears for each kid, I especially thought there would be an awesome Werewolf scene. Other than it falling flat in that sence. I really liked it over all. A darker version with a rating R that seemed to follow more by the book than the original and doing a whole movie of the kids story & a whole other movie of them as adults to come was a good idea as IT can’t be only a 2 hr movie. I’m anticipating what the ending will be as the orig ending was pretty lame imo.

  10. purnama agung says:

    Watch IT 2017 Full Movie Online HD Quality ====> http://BIT.LY/2xbobUv

  11. purnama agung says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download =====>> http://BIT.LY/2xbobUv

  12. purnama agung says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ===>> http://BIT.LY/2xbobUv

  13. Deborah says:

    Watch IT 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://okmovie.us/movie/346364/it

  14. Ewezero says:

    Watch IT 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://t.co/Mb4Rsz7oRZ

  15. purnama agung says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ==>> http://BIT.LY/2xbobUv

  16. David2017 says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► http://hbo.telecinema.pw/movie/346364/it.html

  17. risy46thea says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://tinyurl.com/yar4ydyn Enjoy it !!

  18. MArkJoss says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://daffa.pro/2fblJ6G

  19. Giri Indah says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►►https://movieflix.win/movie/tt1396484

  20. MArkJoss says:

    Amazing

  21. marl1212 says:

    Real ,,,https://t.co/8Kkp2IJMv3 No Ads,Spam

  22. stace says:

    utter shite!

  23. hanyamovie8 says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► bit.ly/2w9GWE6 Enjoy it !!

  24. hanyamovie8 says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://ifsanmovies.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !! good movies

  25. VarietyShouldFire You says:

    I tried to understand this review, but I don’t speak hipster. This was a fantastic horror film.

  26. chewwwwy1 says:

    bloody awful why 1980s ? so disappointed had NO character evolution .I am very cross I spent £13 on this nonsense. Mr King how did you allow this crap to be made .

  27. Jaybird says:

    Movie was bad ass !!! Seen it last night..can’t expect everything from the book lol..that be way to much..I wont even see the gunslinger because it seems way off..It is off but if you haven’t read the book and just seen the movie with Tim Curry than it won’t make a difference. In general as a person that’s critical if you like It the first movie or the book you’ll dig this movie.

  28. Oktag grace says:

    Just share :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leaked} Safe site and 4K ultra HD only premium :)
    Play Now or Download ►► ;;;; https://popmovies.co/movie/346364/it ;;;;Enjoy it !

    • chewwwwy1 says:

      don’t know how old you are and if you have read the book, but this was one of the most disappointing films ever

      • Cheryl says:

        Yes it was very disappointing. I’m a wimp and it wasn’t scary at ALL. Soundtrack was lousy and telegraphed the ongoing, non-stop, what-were-supposed-to-be jump-scares (that weren’t). The only thing I enjoyed was the acting of the kids. There was no sense of dread and no sense of “what is lurking there in the dark.”

  29. Peezy F Baby says:

    I just watched it last night… You gave a horrible review you fckn hipster prolly sitting at Starbucks with your skinny jeans on and faux dreads lol you’re the real clown

  30. Adi Martiana says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://moviespedia.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !!

  31. hanyamovie8 says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://ifsanmovies.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !!

  32. hanyamovie8 says:

    Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak} (4K ultra HD only premium)
    Play or Download ►► https://t.co/s2ggvD442U Enjoy it !

  33. hanyamovie8 says:

    Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak} (4K ultra HD only premium)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://ifsanmovies.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !

  34. Oktag grace says:

    Hai guys watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leaked} Safe site and 4K ultra HD only premium :)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://popmovies.co/movie/346364/it Enjoy it !

  35. Ewon says:

    T0 Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub English [Leaked] HD Streaming
    Play Now or Download ►► https://4kputlocker.pro/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !

  36. Oktag grace says:

    Hello Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leaked} Safe site and 4K ultra HD only premium :)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://popmovies.co/movie/346364/it Enjoy it !

  37. Ouida Evans says:

    “It”, was one my favorite books, but I will skip this movie. Tim Curry will always, in my opinion, be Pennywise, the creepiest clown to ever inhabit a storm drain.

  38. Yet another self-absorbed douchebag snob that spoils the entire plot of the movie just to read himself write…Do yourselves a favor; it is better to watch the movie adaptaion first before reading the novel, it’s like eating a mediocre meal before the delicious dessert!

  39. Oktag grace says:

    Great ! Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leaked} Safe site and 4K ultra HD only premium :)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://popmovies.co/movie/346364/it   Enjoy !

  40. gabrielpayau says:

    Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak} (4K ultra HD only premium)
    Play or Download ►► https://t.co/s2ggvD442U Enjoy it !

  41. Oktag grace says:

    Just share my friend :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak} (4K ultra HD only premium)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://popmovies.co/movie/346364/it Enjoy it !

  42. Patricia Starr says:

    This is my favorite Stephen King book and if you read the book then you know a lot more history about the town and the people in the town and what was going on with that said a movie cannot list all of the things that is in the books or address everything in the book. I know people are not going to go read the book but enjoy the movie for what it is a Movie I hate critics

  43. Cybes says:

    KYS fa ggot.

  44. gabrielpayau says:

    Hai everyone :) Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak}
    Play Now or Download ►► https://ifsanmovies.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !!

  45. NMO says:

    Well, like almost all of King’s works, the First Act is brilliant! The Second Act is suspenseful. And, the Third Act, totally sucks! The rough thing here is that we already know what “It” is, and it’s not that cool of an It. I’m bored already and I haven’t seen It.

  46. gacesayang says:

    Watch It 2017 Full Movie- Sub {Leak} (4K ultra HD only premium)
    Play Now or Download ►► https://ifsanmovies.co/movie/tt1396484/it Enjoy it !

More Film News from Variety

Loading