Is James Franco’s ‘The Disaster Artist’ Already an Oscar Contender?

The Disaster Artist
Courtesy of SXSW

The SXSW Film Festival continues to grow in scope, as a launching pad for broad studio comedies and blockbusters — see “Bridesmaids,” “Neighbors,” and “Trainwreck” — but it’s never unveiled a major Oscar contender before. That might have changed on Sunday night, with the “work-in-progress” premiere of James Franco’s “The Disaster Artist.”

On paper, the movie should be a niche story — a comedy about the making of what’s widely regarded as the worst movie of all time, the 2003 cult indie “The Room,” starring an outsider named Tommy Wiseau, who financed the project and directed it, too. But to say the Austin crowd was ecstatic at the premiere is an understatement. I don’t think I’ve ever heard such thunderous rolls of laughter at the Paramount Theatre, thanks to a tour-de-force (and career-best) performance by Franco, who also (how method!) directed the upcoming Warner Bros. release.


James Franco Alien Covenant

SXSW Film Review: ‘The Disaster Artist’

Franco plays Wiseau like Jim Carrey as Andy Kaufman in “Man on the Moon,” meets Joaquin Phoenix as Johnny Cash in “Walk the Line.” At a post-screening Q&A, Seth Rogen — who portrays “The Room” script supervisor Sandy Schklair — revealed that Franco stayed in character during the entire shoot, even meeting his grandmother as Wiseau. “There were scenes where you,” Rogen said, pointing to Franco, “were playing Tommy, directing a movie as Tommy, directing a movie as Tommy. We’ve done a lot of weird s— in our day. But that was one where I was like, ‘This is f—ing weird.’”

The movie is adapted from a 2013 non-fiction book, written by “The Room” co-star Greg Sestero (played by Dave Franco). James pitched the idea to Rogen while they were shooting another movie together. “This is the good thing to come out of ‘The Interview,’” Rogen said, of the 2014 comedy that led to a hack of internal emails at Sony Pictures. Wiseau wanted Johnny Depp to play him, but Franco convinced him that he was a suitable second choice. “I’ve seen some of your work,” the real-life Wiseau told Franco. “You do good things and bad things.”

Franco said he approached playing Wiseau as if he were a legendary screen icon. “It’s funny,” Franco said. “Tommy is a huge fan of James Dean. In a weird way, I studied the role of Tommy in the way I played James Dean — just obsessively driving around in my car, listening to [his] voice all the time.”

Throughout the screening, Wiseau, who was in attendance, sat solemnly next to Sestero, watching the picture for the first time, as the theater erupted around him. After the credits rolled, when approached by a Variety reporter, Wiseau wouldn’t offer a thumbs up or thumbs down. “I have to think about it,” he replied.

The Academy typically doesn’t honor comedies, but there are elements in “The Disaster Artist” that may be hard to resist. First off, it’s a valentine to Hollywood, which is usually a guarantee for a boatload of nominations. Then there’s the film’s star-studded ensemble, some of whom only make a brief cameo — including Sharon Stone (as an agent), Bryan Cranston (playing himself from his “Malcolm in the Middle” days), Melanie Griffith, Zac Efron, Josh Hutcherson, Jacki Weaver, and Judd Apatow.

Warner Bros. doesn’t have a release date set yet, but whenever “The Disaster Artist” hits theaters, it’s sure to be a formidable hit, especially once word-of-mouth gets out. While it helps to know “The Room,” the movie was constructed so that even those unfamiliar with it could follow along. At the post-screening Q&A, the audience started chanting Wiseau’s name, as he reluctantly took the stage with the film’s cast for a photograph. “I hope he liked it,” Rogen said. If he didn’t, he’d be the only one.


Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 12

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Rutegar says:

    But of course it’s in OSCARS contention — it’s a movie about movie-making !

  2. WHy says:

    Odd how this movie is getting praised but “The Dubious Battle” is being trashed on.

  3. Loved the book, can wait for this to hit theaters!

  4. Bob says:

    Fluff piece to help producers convince WB to meaningfully release the Picture or find a new home for it.

  5. Irrespective of quality of this movie.. Is it this much easy for a film to be an oscar contender??

    Just based on the opinions of 500 people watched it at the premiere???

    I’m not opposed to your views but the “HEADLINE”.
    Variety loved it so it must be an oscar contender!!!

    It creates false impression.

  6. John Choate says:

    The Hurt Locker… premiered at SXSW not only as a contender but an eventual winner.

    • Lisbeth says:

      “The Hurt Locker” premiered before SXSW in competition at the Venice International Film Festival. On the 4th Sept. 2008, more than 6 months before SXSW…

  7. Ben says:

    James Franco is a good – sometimes even great – actor. But most of the self-financed, digitally shot, low-budget films he directed are not made with enough care. They are more like student films.

    The best one was “Child of God” IMO which had a central performance so powerful and a story so sick, it made you forget all the flaws.

    You need to give Franco some credit for trying weird and freaky stuff in an industry that plays it safe all the time.

    And you can trash his self-directed movies as much as you like – maybe they all lack something and ain’t good yet – but he never played it safe.

    Maybe “The Disaster Artist” is finally his masterpiece as a director…James Franco is close to Tommy Wiseau in spirit, so it might be the perfect subject for him.

    Anyway, I’ll watch this & I will probably buy the 2-Disc-BluRay with “The Room”…

  8. Robbie says:

    Leave it to a hack to praise another hack.

  9. Bill B. says:

    Franco has had the most fascinating career. I don’t think he sleeps he does so much. Speaking of fascinating, that is what this sounds like. Looking forward to it.

    • macd says:

      The only fascinating thing about James Franco’s career is the fact that he still has a career! His last fiasco, “King Cobra”, was beyond embarrassing, as were its miniscule grosses. This jerk has as much of a chance of winning an Oscar as Donald Trump has of being elected POTUS. Oh . . . wait . . .

More Film News from Variety