SXSW Film Review: ‘Bill Nye: Science Guy’

'Bill Nye: Science Guy' Review: SXSW

The beloved TV host strives to be taken seriously in his battle against anti-science forces.

Bill Nye: Science Guy” is an efficiently thought-provoking study of what it means to be a rational and analytical advocate for science in an age when deniers of evolution and climate-change often seem to have higher profiles, deeper pockets and louder voices. But it’s even more interesting as the story of a beloved celebrity who wants to reinvent himself, to be taken more seriously — by longtime admirers and philosophical adversaries alike — even as he takes advantage of his pop-culture prominence to reach the masses with his messaging.

Directors David Alvarado and Jason Sussberg (“The Immortalists”) offer a sympathetic yet balanced view of their subject, 62-year-old Bill Nye, star of the long-canceled but enduringly popular “Bill Nye the Science Guy,” a kid-friendly TV series that provided informal and entertaining scientific demonstrations for generations of viewers much too young to remember the similarly ambitious “Watch Mr. Wizard.” Although PBS ended the series back in 1998, it has enjoyed a long afterlife in reruns, classrooms, and the minds of nostalgic fans. Illustrative clips of Nye’s appearances at book-signings and other events testify to the warm esteem he continues to elicit from thousands who grew up with him as their televised tutor.

If you look closely at those clips, however, you can’t help noticing Nye isn’t entirely at ease with adulation. (He often responds to selfie requests with an impatience that borders on brusqueness.) “Bill Nye: Science Guy” hardly qualifies as a warts-and-all expose of the private man behind a public persona. But it does suggest the extent of a reflexive standoffishness that, as Nye himself readily admits, stems from memories of his unhappy childhood, and fears that, like his brother and sister, he might be stricken by Ataxia, a crippling neurological disease that runs in his family. So far, he’s shown no sign of the malady — but he identifies it as the reason why he’s never married and fathered children. Well, at least one of the reasons.

On the flip side, Nye often appears positively buoyant whenever he speaks of his work as CEO and official face of The Planetary Society, an organization co-founded by his idol and mentor, the late Carl Sagan, and dedicated to fulfilling Sagan’s dreams for a solar-powered LightSail spacecraft. And although he comes close to losing his temper a couple times during live and televised debates with people he considers dangerously anti-science — like Ken Ham, an aggressive creationist who raised money for a Noah’s Ark theme park by cannily exploiting viral videos of his public exchanges with Nye — he’s by and large a happy warrior when it comes to making the case for his side of the issues.

The catch is, while celebrity scientist Neil deGrasse Tyson definitely qualifies as a pro-Nye guy, others in the scientific community have openly criticized Nye for drawing attention to contrarians such as Ham and Joe Bastardi, the latter a TV weather forecaster (and, oddly enough, champion bodybuilder) who routinely mocks Nye’s dire predictions of global warming. Others pointedly note that the Science Guy isn’t really a scientist at all — he actually holds a degree in mechanical engineering — and accuse him of being a mere pretender who has successfully packaged himself as an affably telegenic expert known for his infectious good humor and snazzy bowtie.

Based on what we see of Nye in this beguilingly absorbing documentary, however, it appears the naysayers have done little to temper his determination. The final portion of “Bill Nye: Science Guy” focuses on faint early signs that he’s starting to bring an outspoken critic around to his point of view. It’s a hopeful sign, to be sure, but the filmmakers don’t push too hard in the direction of a neatly tied-up happy ending. They, and Nye, fully understand that conversion, like self-reinvention, is a process that takes time.

SXSW Film Review: 'Bill Nye: Science Guy'

Reviewed at SXSW Film Festival (Documentary Competition), March 17, 2017. (Also at Hot Docs.) Running time: 101 MIN.


(Documentary) A Complex Corporation, Exhibit A production. (International sales: WME.) Producers: Seth Gordon, Nick Pampenella, David Alvarado, Kate McLean, Jason Sussberg. Executive producers: Mary Rohlich, Henry S. Rosenthal, Walker Deibel, Chad Troutwine. Co-executive producers: Andre Gaines Howard J. Smith.


Directors: David Alvarado, Jason Sussberg. Camera (color): Alvarado. Editor: Annukka Lilja.


Bill Nye, Neil deGrasse Tyson, Ann Druyan, Francis Collins, Ken Ham, Joe Bastardi.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Frank Lee says:

    One has to ask if the study of evolutionary theory is really scientific. If one were to apply the normal definition and measures of the scientific method to the evolutionary field it comes up dramatically short.

    One can do great science whether one believes in evolution or not. One can do great science whether one believes in God, the bible, supernatural creation or in the big bang, abiogenesis and evolution.

    The whole issue at stake here is a battle of worldviews – with those in the evolutionary camp wanting to exclude any viewpoint other than their own and using the argument that anything to do with a belief in God is anti-science. Nothing could be further from the truth. In fact on deeper examination one comes to the conclusion that it’s a belief in spontaneous eruption of life from non-living things and evolution that is pointedly anti-science. Such beliefs completely defy scientific explanations. There are no recorded observations, no ability to repeat the experiment to verify that the statements are true and one cannot even falsify those statements because proponents will always devise another unsubstantiated rescue statement.

    The study of our origins is closely coupled to what one believes about whether there is a supernatural creator or not and in fact whatever or whoever gave rise to our creation is our god. That effectively means that as far as origins are concerned, the pro-evolutionary camp has the big bang, spontaneous eruption of life(abiogenesis) and evolution as creator and therefore as their god.

    So this crusade of the science guy is really to propagate a religious belief – as clearly depicted by the last statement in the article : “They, and Nye, fully understand that conversion, like self-reinvention, is a process that takes time.”

  2. FROM THE CHARLESTON GAZETTE-MAIL: The lawsuit alleges the Bible classes include “Creationism instruction” that involves “having students imagine that human beings and dinosaurs existed at the same time.” It quotes one lesson as saying “So picture Adam being able to crawl up on the back of dinosaur! He and Eve could have their own personal water slide! Wouldn’t that be so wild!”

  3. Lex says:

    ‘science’ is to political now in certain subject matters. 20 years from now Florida won’ t be underwater, an inch higher and if so, they will try to explain it away and that is only a temporary ‘pause’.

  4. John G. says:

    We’re all aware of the dangers of anti-evolution advocates and climate change contrarians, but is there any discussion in the documentary of anti-GMO and anti-vaccine activists, who often come from the opposite end of the political spectrum? If Nye is indeed a valiant pro-science educator, I hope he works to expose science skeptics from all corners of society.

More Film News from Variety