Snapchat CEO Said ‘This App Is Only for Rich People,’ Ex-Employee Alleges

Evan Spiegel Snapchat IPO
Andrew Parsons/REX/Shutterstock

At a meeting to discuss Snapchat’s user growth in 2015, Anthony Pompliano says he expressed concern that the app was not taking off overseas.

Pompliano, who had just been hired away from Facebook, contends that he presented methods to address the issue, but that Evan Spiegel, the company’s CEO, abruptly cut him off.

“This app is only for rich people,” Spiegel said, according to Pompliano. “I don’t want to expand into poor countries like India and Spain.”

The allegations are contained in Pompliano’s lawsuit, filed in redacted form in L.A. Superior Court in January. On Monday, Snap Inc. — the parent company of Snapchat — dropped its efforts to keep the unredacted complaint under seal and released it in a public filing.

Pompliano’s suit tells a story of his brief, three-week tenure at the company, during which he says he learned that the company was exaggerated its user data and that top executives were “completely misinformed” about key metrics.

Snap had previously argued that Pompliano’s suit contained trade secrets that could damage the company and help its competitors. But in a notice to the court on Monday, Snap said it was dropping the effort to keep the unredacted complaint sealed because it “has nothing to hide” since going public last month. Snap described Pompliano as a “disgruntled employee fired for poor performance” who filed the lawsuit out of thirst for publicity.

“The simple fact is that he knows exactly nothing about Snap’s current metrics,” Snap’s attorneys wrote. “He and his lawyers are — not to put too fine a point on matters — just making things up.”

John Pierce, Pompliano’s attorney, said that Snap withdrew its effort to seal the complaint because the company knew it would lose.

“This attempt to save face by Snap should serve as a reminder that no matter how big you are (or how many billions of dollars you have) in our system everyone has to play by the same set of rules,” Pierce said.

In the lawsuit, Pompliano says that on his second day on the job he met with two data analysts, who confided to him that Snapchat had “an institutional aversion to looking at user data,” and its efforts in that area were marked by “utter incompetence.”

Pompliano says he began looking into Snap’s internal methods for calculating daily active users (DAU’s), and was shocked to learn that the company relied on two crude and inaccurate metrics. The first was based on a program called Flurry, and included push notifications, which resulted in overstated numbers, according to the suit. The second was called Blizzard, and it missed older users, thereby undercounting the user base, Pompliano claims.

Snap had been claiming 100 million DAUs at the time, Pompliano alleges, even though Flurry counted only 97 million and Blizzard recorded 95 million. Pompliano became further concerned when he studied user growth over the previous nine months, and found that it the user base increased only 1% to 4% per quarter — far less than the double-digit month-over-month growth that the company was claiming, the suit says. Pompliano was alarmed that senior executives seemed to be misinformed about the data, so he “dug deeper,” according to the suit.

“What he uncovered was a wide-spread, systemic failure in Snapchat’s internal controls over its user data,” the suit claims.

For one, Pompliano says Snapchat was inflating its registration completion rate, which it claimed was about 87%. In fact, Pompliano says it was less than 40%. The company was also claiming to retain 40% of its users after seven days, when in fact the figure was closer to 20%, Pompliano claims.

Pompliano says he raised concerns that advertisers were being misled with several people, including Jill Hazelbaker, the vice president of communications. According to the lawsuit, Hazelbaker said she had raised similar concerns internally but had been ignored.

Pompliano then prepared a PowerPoint presentation on his findings for Snapchat’s senior management, including Spiegel, the firm’s then-25-year-old CEO. On Sept. 11., 2015, at the end of his second week on the job, Pompliano gave his presentation. It did not go well.

“Mr. Spiegel was inexplicably enraged throughout the meeting and refused to listen to anything Mr. Pompliano said, constantly cutting him off and summarily dismissing his points,” the lawsuit states.

According to the suit, Spiegel flipped through the presentation and summarily dismissed it, saying “Yeah I read those, it doesn’t matter,” and told Pompliano he was wasting his time.

Pompliano brought up the app’s lackluster performance in India and Spain, saying both countries have high mobile penetration and should be ripe for improved growth, at which point Spiegel made the remark about not being interested in “poor countries” and stormed out, Pompliano alleges.

Pompliano claims that Spiegel then met with two other executives and determined that “Mr. Pompliano presented a risk to Snapchat’s IPO.”

Pompliano says he was directed to create a second presentation, specifically addressing Spiegel’s questions about “friending” data. Though he says he offered a “constructive critique” of user data, and offered suggested improvements, this presentation fared no better than the first. Through an intermediary, Spiegel offered his own critique of the report, and Pompliano circulated a response, in which he “systematically dismantled Mr. Spiegel’s misguided criticism,” the lawsuit states.

The next day, he was fired. Pompliano says a security guard handed him a box and escorted him out of the building, and his phone was wiped of Snapchat accounts and data.

Pompliano has alleged that Snap executives badmouthed him to other prospective employers, making it difficult for him to find work. He has also claimed that Snap sought to violate his confidentiality agreement with Facebook by improperly asking him for a detailed Facebook org chart, a request he says he refused.

Snap has filed a motion seeking to force the case into arbitration. In its notice to the court, Snap counters that the details of Flurry and Blizzard have been disclosed to investors in the company’s prospectus.

Pierce, Pompliano’s attorney, argued that the acknowledgement demonstrates that Snap has backed off its earlier blanket denials.

“By the end of this litigation – and rest assured this is only the beginning – we will prove that every claim Mr. Pompliano has made about the long history of misconduct, going to the heart of the astronomical valuation of this now public company, is true,” Pierce said.

Snapchat unredacted lawsuit by gmaddaus on Scribd

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 28

Leave a Reply

28 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Tim says:

    Please name another “rich” country where 6,000 children die every day from preventable diseases. That’s India.

  2. Tim says:

    The Republic of Congo is considered wealthier than India (using the common GDP based on purchasing-power-parity per capita).

    That is damn poor.

  3. cuthbert51 says:

    “Snapchat CEO Said ‘This App Is Only for Rich People”

    Well, this sucks. Guess I have to delete it.

  4. Mark says:

    India is rich at the expense of USA outsourcing. No more foreign aid to countries like India. Obama era is gone.

  5. Santosh says:

    Poor CEO does not know to do business, so gives some reason for his company failure in India.

  6. rahul patil says:

    You lost too many Snapchat users from India 🖕

  7. Kukun Mishra says:

    A shit app just like it’s CEO.

  8. K. C. Soni says:

    We Indians are not poor, your mentality is poor..***

  9. If you think Facebook is evil enough (for also copying Snapchat and for more others things), Snapchat now looks like very very is much evil.

    This type of momentous selfish type of sharing isn’t making the world better or even connecting it further, but it just makes it much fragmented, divisive and the society more selfish and narcissistic that ever

  10. Sonny B says:

    I am going to tell all my friends in USA and around world to uninstall snapchat for stupid comment made by its CEO. I would love to see lawsuit filed against Snapchat and put this company out of business.

  11. sejal says:

    haha the star rating already crashed…good luck😬😂 (India 🇮🇳)

  12. The app rating in Playstore is crumbling down. Good luck

  13. Leo_sk says:

    He isnt wrong. Just tell him to prevent it from appearing in play store in poor countries. Many get mislead downloading the elite app

  14. Abhineet Ranjan says:

    I never used snapchat and I also do Poor rating…. for the Poor snapchat CEO…. Kindly Change your mentality Mr. Evan Spiegel…

    • cuthbert51 says:

      It doesn’t help for you to admit that. All it does is make people question if the rating of a product is about the product or for personal reasons.

  15. sejal says:

    Deleting snapchat from my phone…with love from India 🇮🇳 to the ceo with a pathetic mentality 🖐🏻

  16. Snappychotty says:

    I was living in a poor country and I wasn’t aware!. With love from Spain: A poor country richer than Italy already…

  17. Doctor_Qué says:

    Deleting snapchat from my phone….. with love, from Spain ;)

  18. Sarrianenc says:

    Spiegel look for “List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)” or “List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)” in wikipedia… easy!! Spain is over Canada and Australia!! F* american!

  19. Frank says:

    Pompliano was obviously a mole sent over by his employer Facebook in what has been a continuing effort by Zuckerberg to try and kneecap his successor, Snapchat. Zuckerberg stole his company and was the subject of a movie that revealed his manipulation of others. Shame on Variety for giving publicity to this fake news effort.

    • Losers are still losers says:

      Snapchat has been scamming potential investors with BS figures. Snapchat is actually losing users….And will never admit it with money now on the table.

      • cuthbert51 says:

        That isn’t true. You can claim that there are BS figures being released by Snap, but there are no impartial people making the same claim as you. If there was any validity to your claim, people not named “losers are still losers” would be talking about it.

        It’s losing a TON of money, but not because of losing users. Even this article, which talks about wrong metrics, does not say they are losing users. Just that their increases are not as high as reported. But, they are still increases.

  20. Truvey Taylor says:

    I can’t wait to see this lame app crash and burn. Also, saying your former employee was under-performing after only having been hired for less than a month says more about their short-sighted company.

  21. Rochester says:

    Spain?! One of the world’s largest economies, poor? This guy is a joke.

  22. Bret D says:

    Snapchat is , in my opinion, a complete waste of time. Just like Twitter.It is a stock market scam.

  23. Equipment guy says:

    It’s like the year 2000 all over again, high flying internet company valued at billions of dollars by market that makes or does nothing and is just conning advertisers that their money spent is actually getting the eyeball/looks, total BS! Get ready for tech stock crash 2.0, for some of these companies.

More Biz News from Variety

Loading