L.A. Times Masthead Massacre Capped a Month of Newsroom Turmoil

Davan Maharaj LA Times Fired

The ouster of four top editors at the L.A. Times on Monday was the result of a month of newsroom turmoil following the publication of an investigation into the former dean of the USC medical school.

Sources familiar with the situation tell Variety that the paper’s top investigative reporter, Paul Pringle, filed complaints with the human resources department about top editors, alleging that the story was being delayed due to cozy relations between the editors and USC officials. Tronc, the paper’s parent company, responded with an internal investigation. The probe did not find any substantiation for the complaint, but did open the floodgates to additional newsroom grievances against the paper’s leadership, culminating with the dismissal of Davan Maharaj, the editor and publisher, managing editor Marc Duvoisin, and two other top lieutenants.

The Times published its blockbuster report on Dr. Carmen Puliafito on July 17, finding that the dean was a methamphetamine user who partied with drug dealers and was present when a 21-year-old escort overdosed in a hotel room. The report was a major coup for the Times, and knocked USC officials back on their heels. But it also kicked up underlying resentment and bitterness within the paper, according to several newsroom sources who spoke to Variety on the condition of anonymity.

The Times was first tipped off to the Puliafito story more than a year ago. Initial drafts were not deemed fit for publication, according to several newsroom sources. As reporting went on over the course of several months, Pringle began to complain that Maharaj and Duvoisin were dragging their feet and trying to quash the story, say these sources.

Pringle, who declined to comment for this story, had filed his complaint earlier this year alleging that Maharaj and Duvoisin were going easy on the university due to the paper’s partnership with USC to put on the Festival of Books. Tronc began to investigate those claims.

The story was published, and widely hailed. USC was forced to launch its own inquiry, and acknowledged that the situation was poorly handled. But the success of the story did not end the hard feelings within the paper. Pringle filed a new complaint with HR alleging that Maharaj and Duvoisin caused an improper delay in publication.

A couple of weeks later, reporters got wind that California editor Shelby Grad was about to be transferred to a new assignment. Pringle and his supporters on the Metro staff interpreted the move as retaliation for Grad’s staunch support for the USC story. Several newsroom sources said that Grad had encouraged the reporters to pursue the story in the face of skepticism from Maharaj and Duvoisin. Grad and Maharaj declined to comment for this story.

In an email to Tim Ryan, the president of publishing at Tronc, a group of 15 reporters expressed concern that Grad’s transfer “shortly after fighting for publication of the USC story” raised concerns about potential “conflicts,” and “possible ethical lapses that could damage the reputation of the Los Angeles Times.” Pringle was not among the 15 who signed the letter.

The email, obtained by Variety, touched off another HR investigation at Tronc. Newsroom sources say that many people have been interviewed in recent weeks. The investigators began to hear many other complaints against Maharaj and his team. For some time, several Metro staffers have grumbled about low pay and the lack of raises in recent years, and talked about organizing a union.

By last Friday, it became clear that the HR investigation posed a serious threat to the top editors. That morning, several editors wrote to Tronc CEO Justin Dearborn and chairman Michael Ferro, requesting an immediate meeting.

“We ask you to meet with us today, as a group, to discuss a Human Resources investigation that has disrupted our workplace for more than a month,” the editors wrote. “We are concerned about the repercussions for the news organization.”

On Monday, those repercussions became clear. Maharaj and Duvoisin were out, along with investigations editor Matt Doig, and digital editor Megan Garvey. Jill Leovy, the founder of “The Homicide Report” blog and author of “Ghettoside,” was also fired. She is Duvoisin’s wife. Ana Mata, Maharaj’s administrative assistant, was also let go.

Tronc concluded there were no improprieties in the handling of the USC story, according to a published report by the Los Angeles Times. The four were not let go for cause, and Tronc referred to the personnel moves as a “restructuring.”

While the newsroom rebellion may have been the catalyst that undid Maharaj and his team, it appears that Tronc’s leadership was already contemplating a change at the top.

Veteran media executive Ross Levinsohn was appointed the new publisher, and Jim Kirk, former editor and publisher of the Chicago Sun-Times, was named interim editor.

In an interview with the Times, Dearborn praised Levinsohn as an “avid reader” and someone who is “passionate about journalism.”

“What we need right now is someone who has broader global vision and someone who can execute on that,” Dearborn told the paper.

At an all-hands meeting at 3 p.m. on Monday at the Times’ community room, Levinsohn and Kirk declined to discuss the firings. Instead, they vowed to “invest in the brand.”

Staffing cuts are a perennial source of anxiety at a newsroom that has seen wave after wave of buyouts. According to sources in the meeting, Levinsohn and Kirk offered assurances that they did not come to the paper to make further cutbacks. However, Times staffers have heard such promises before from new leadership.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 8

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Richard Johnson says:

    Long overdue overhaul for the LA Times… hope real change comes out of this shakeup. Compared to other major papers, the Times seems to have struggled with the transition from print to digital.

    Don’t get me wrong — I support the idea of the paywall system but expect to receive high quality journalism and a good browsing experience in return; the Times provides neither at this point.

    Beyond the USC story, their newsroom feels stalled and unable to deliver much in the way of groundbreaking reporting or meaningful investigative journalism. Luckily, the major local NPR affiliate KPCC fills the void left by the paper’s shortcomings by addressing regionally important issues in detail with reasoned analysis. Moreover, to learn of the apparent publishing delay for the USC exposé is troubling. Sitting on such a bombshell story, clearly backed by video evidence, multiple sources and a police report too, is journalistic malpractice. Then we have the abysmal quality of their localilized efforts, like the Daily Pilot in Orange County, which reads more like a high school news bulletin than actual journalism, but that’s a whole other topic I won’t get into here.

    To top it all off, the Times adds insult to injury when, after paying for online access, you’re still bombarded with full page advertisements constantly popping up while reading through a story on their website. I understand the need to advertise, even with the paywall, but subscribers shouldn’t have to contend with multiple pop ups — many of which contain videos that autostart — while browsing; these ads can make the Times website unworkable by slowing down loading speeds or ultimately overwhelming mobile browsers (can’t begin to tell you how many times my iPhone’s Safari App delivers an error message and has to reload an article on their site).

    There are successful models out there for managing the digital revolution’s effects on print media. For instance, I began subscribing to the Washington Post digitally during the lead up to the election, and their site and reporting are top notch, so much so that I turned in my LA Times subscription, sticking to WaPo, NY Times and the WSJ instead. I would love to have a more West Coast oriented newspaper outlet in my arsenal, but until the Times demonstrates substantial improvement, I will stick to (and financially support) KPCC for my regional perspective.

  2. Maggie Sammons says:

    I’m sure The Newspaper Guild/CWA would love to chat with the news staff.

    • If you’re shocked that the LA Times publishers sandbagged a story that they found damaging to their friends, then you haven’t been paying attention. Only been going on for 100-and-some-odd years. They still refuse to touch the Awan Brothers spy ring and the implications for the Southern California Congressional Delegation. Maybe a change at the top will help.

      Thank you Variety for this story. Job well done.

  3. Fiala says:

    Since when does Variety actually do news stories? They should do more, instead of focusing on all of that celebrity crap. Nice job on this piece.

  4. cowgirldiva says:

    We the People demand TRUTH from all our media outlets…!! We deserve it..!!

    Hopefully, these new changes will bring more TRUTH to the people who depend on the integrity of the media and look to them as an honest reservoir of in-depth TRUTHFULNESS on every level..!!

  5. Adam says:

    Thank you for this excellent reporting. Much more interesting than the usual press release type stories.

  6. suzyfresh says:

    Thanks for excellent reporting on the newsroom turmoil. The Puliafito investigative piece was great journalism that uncovered a tangled web of dangerous and illegal behavior, lies, coverups. Interesting to read about the potential conflicts of interest — a dangerous enemy of the Truth.

  7. paully says:

    I’m guessing Football tickets are the root of some of this.. not sarcasm..

More Biz News from Variety