‘The Walking Dead’ Recap: ‘Knots Untie’ Takes Us on the Road to Nowhere

walking dead hilltop gregory negan 611
Courtesy of AMC

Spoiler warning: Do not read on unless you’ve seen episode 611 of AMC’s “The Walking Dead,” titled “Knots Untie.” 

While most of Hollywood is slogging through three hours of Oscars inanity over on ABC, viewers hoping for some action-packed zombie counter-programming won’t find much to get their pulses racing in this week’s installment of “The Walking Dead,” which served as one of those necessary but tedious episodes where not much gets done but a lot gets talked about. It was a plain old meat and potatoes dish that set the table for an inevitable feast of carnage to come, but despite some interesting character beats, the meal proved particularly hard to swallow after two episodes that did a much better job of balancing thrills with character development.

This week, after escaping his bonds and almost catching Rick and Michonne in flagrante delicto, Jesus convinced our group to take a trip back to his own community, Hilltop, in the hope of establishing trade between the two colonies. Alexandria might be well-stocked with ammunition, but their food situation is apparently growing dire, as evidenced by Maggie’s pre-dawn attempt to build trellises for tomatoes that haven’t begun to grow yet.

Compared to Alexandria’s snazzy solar panels and cozy cul-de-sac layout, Hilltop was positively agrarian, with most of its inhabitants living in beaten up trailers around the colonial mansion at its center — occupied by Gregory, a man with all of the Governor’s arrogance and even less of his charm. Apparently a neat-freak as well as a chauvinist, Gregory refused to talk to our grubby group until they’d cleaned up, and when Rick sent Maggie to negotiate with Gregory in his stead (both because Deanna was rightly grooming Maggie for leadership and because Rick seemed likely to punch the guy if he engaged with him), Gregory was dismissive of Alexandria’s many valuable assets — trying to undermine Maggie with lewd come-ons and condescending pet names rather than actually seeing the value of Alexandria’s resources and her own undeniable strength.

Negotiations were derailed by the return of a supply group who had an unfortunate run-in with Negan, whose reputation has preceded him both on-screen and off this season. After the team dropped off some of Hilltop’s supplies (a tithe that is supposed to stop the Saviors from killing them all), Negan apparently decided that the offering was too light, and retaliated by killing two members of the group and holding a third hostage, offering to release him only if the group delivered a message to Gregory — a knife to the gut (which no one seemed too upset about).


walking dead jesus tom payne rick michonne

‘The Walking Dead’ Newcomer Tom Payne Breaks Down Jesus’ Memorable Introduction, That Surprise Ending

After a bloody scuffle which resulted in one Hilltopper dead, the rest traumatized and Rick once again covered in blood like a wild animal, Jesus offered our group a handy infodump of exactly why Negan is such bad news — highlighting the main shortcoming of this episode, which broke the cardinal writing rule of “show, don’t tell.”

Since the midseason premiere (and arguably before it, given Daryl’s encounter with some of the Saviors and their escapees in the woods before the winter hiatus), we’ve been told that Negan is a scary guy, but aside from some aggressive but ultimately useless thugs who tried to terrorize Daryl, Abraham and Sasha out on the road, we’ve yet to see any evidence of the threat Negan poses. I understand the narrative purpose of building suspense for a villain before he appears, especially since our group is obviously being set up to underestimate how dangerous he is (could Daryl end up as his first victim, in recompense for dismissing him as a “boogeyman” with a good story but no real power?) but I can’t help but feel that Negan’s eventual arrival would’ve packed a far more brutal punch if we hadn’t been told that he introduced himself to the residents of Hilltop by summarily beating a 16-year-old to death just because he wanted the rest of the town to “understand right off the bat.” (Punny!)

Nevertheless, the dead Hilltoppers and Jesus’ handy exposition served their purpose — our group volunteered to take down Negan and his men and rescue the Hilltop hostage, in return for half of Hilltop’s food and medical supplies. Everybody wins! (Except for all the dead people.)

The subplot of hour was about as subtle as a baseball bat to the noggin, too, with Abraham experiencing a love dilemma; despite a seemingly perfect relationship with a still frustratingly underdeveloped Rosita, who makes him romantic necklaces and invites him to shower with her, his attentions have been transferred to Sasha, with whom he’s been obsessed ever since they got stuck in an office together in “Always Accountable.” Sasha hasn’t seemed to reciprocate his interest thus far (she even switched patrol duties, perhaps so that she no longer had to be partnered with Abraham — take the hint, dude), but that didn’t stop the ginger giant from pining for her throughout much of the hour while wondering whether he could possibly settle down and have a future, since everyone seemed to be coupling up around him.

His inner turmoil was illustrated with little nuance by director Michael E. Satrazemis’ lingering close-ups of Abraham’s eyes, and his pensive glances at Maggie and Glenn enjoying their coupledom — shots that were so painfully “arty” they became distracting. All of this would’ve been more compelling if the show had dedicated any time to developing Rosita, Abraham or Sasha beyond the losses they’ve endured — Sasha in particular has mostly been defined by the deaths of the two men in her life, brother Tyreese and partner Bob, and I’m not particularly interested in seeing her being saddled with another plotline that only gives her value because of her relationship with yet another guy. Likewise, Rosita barely exists outside of Abraham’s orbit, and it’s frustrating to see a tough, capable woman being reduced to a lovesick puppy by a man who’s seemingly only staying with her until a better offer comes along. All this emotional insight into Abraham could also signal that Big Red’s time on the show is coming to an end, since “TWD” has a nasty habit of only developing its secondary characters right before it gruesomely kills them off — perhaps Abraham will be Negan’s first casualty?

Despite some satisfying character moments — Carl’s knowing and fond acceptance of Rick and Michonne’s relationship progression, and the sweet intimacy between Glenn and Maggie as they looked towards the future — ultimately, “Knots Untie” unraveled because of its unenviable position as a scene-setter for the plot twists yet to come. Compared to last week’s “The Next World,” which did little to advance the narrative but still managed to be engaging thanks to its deft writing and focus on two of the show’s most fascinating relationships (Rick’s bonds with Daryl and Michonne), this week’s episode couldn’t help but feel like a step backwards.

“The Walking Dead” airs Sundays at 9 p.m. on AMC.

What did you think of the introduction of Hilltop and Gregory? Weigh in below.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 13

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Goodness, the level of commentary here is disturbing (but for a respectful, intelligent few). Spoilers? Name-calling? Yeesh!

    I will agree with you, Laura, that Rosita has been underdeveloped thus far, but I have to disagree about Sasha. I think we got a clear imprint of her pretty early on – the strong sibling with sense and a bit of spark, and they’ve taken that deeper by exploring how loss has affected her. Is there more we could learn? Absolutely – and hopefully we will, about both women.

    Meanwhile, the episode WAS slower, but no less captivating for my money. And since most weeks I’m watching with my heart in my throat, unable to truly enjoy watching until the second airing, I’ll take the reprieve! ;)

  2. tom o says:

    hey- did anyone catch abraham breaking the fourth wall when speaking about rearing a kid, given what goes on “on any given sunday”?

  3. Charles Hyatt says:

    I have to chuckle at how the author bemoans the lack of character development for Sasha, Rosita and Abraham while complaining about the lack of thrills in this episode. I enjoyed this episode precisely because of the balance between action and plot advancement. It is the dynamics among the wonderful cast of TWD which elevates this program above every other violent, action-oriented program on television.

  4. jeff says:

    I normally dont comment but this was bad, i read it blindly as with so many other articles about random thing. As i read the part about rosita being a used woman stereo type i asked myself “this has to be a woman writing this right??” Scrolled up and found, yup it was.

    Author, please in the future try not to let you person issues to cloud your professional work. This was as transparent as could he to anyone who understands basic psycology. You having been used by a man in your personal life has no place in an analysis if a show, or any thing for that matter. Not all men are bad, this is a classic case of reverse sexism. Well done

    • Noel Snow says:

      Jeff- please proofread for typos at least if you are going to criticize someone’s writing. I never took “pyscology” in college. I guess that’s the class where you learn about “person issues”. Please go back to not commenting. You really have no business trolling.

  5. Jesus says:

    Claudia, you couldn’t be more wrong.
    Gregory is no governor.
    Gregory is going to try to kill Maggie later on by trying to poison her, and when she finds out, she kills Gregory and becomes the leader of the Hilltop…but that is way later than where they are at with the show.

    What is going to happen next is that Rick is going to run into Negan, then Negan is going to kill Glenn with a barbed wired baseball bat named Lucille. Abraham will also die as well, but on a separate journey with Eugene.

    I know this because I have read the comics and they are following the storyline to the T so far…

  6. Claudia says:

    Hilltop and Gregory smells like the Governor and Woodbury….sigh….. will Scott Gimple and friends come up with a different story line…………?

    • janissaries1 says:

      I agree. Gregory is no Governor. Gregory is a coward that is full of himself. Governor was no coward. My take is that they gave Gregory the figurehead position of Hilltop, just to give his useless butt something to do and that it’s Jesus that is actually running the show. That’s why they attacked Rick for attacking the guy that stabbed Gregory. The rest of Hilltop have no use for Gregory and I can see Ethan’s frustration in Gregory for putting them into the situationt they are in. Rick didn’t know, even though Rick did the right thing in springing into action to stop Ethan, who suddenly appeared to be unstable and a murderer.

    • Tom says:

      Thats what I was thinking. Some of these seem so poorly constructed

  7. ModeBeast says:

    Anyone notice the volunteer from the Hilltop was wearing a red shirt? Also, Abraham has hope, so he will die soon, same with Glenn, they have “hope” and the “building a future” rhetoric spells doom on this show.

    • Janissaries says:

      That’s the Star Trek syndrome, guy in the red shirt dies. Beware if we see an episode where Daryl is told to wear the red shirt.

  8. Wetcnt says:

    Terrible opinion piece by a horrid pig faced woman.

More TV News from Variety