2016 Emmy Ballot Oddities: ‘Doctor Who’ in the Running, ‘Game of Thrones’ Finale Goes Down to the Wire

2016 Emmy Ballot Oddities: 'Doctor Who,'
BBC America

The race for the 2016 Emmys has officially begun. Voting for the TV Academy’s top honors is now open until June 27, and ballots for all categories are available for viewing.

We already knew about some of the season’s more unusual contenders — like Amy Poehler and Tina Fey’s joint submission as guest actress for hosting “Saturday Night Live,” and Johnny Depp’s bid for outstanding lead actor in a limited series or movie for “Funny Or Die Presents Donald Trump’s The Art of the Deal: The Movie.”

But Variety perused some of the top categories to find more inevitable oddities, including surprise inclusions (“Doctor Who”!) and exclusions (sorry, “Manhattan”).

• HBO is cutting it awfully close to the wire with the finales of three of their biggest Emmy favorite shows. The final episodes of the current seasons of Game of Thrones,” “Silicon Valley,” and Veep all air June 26, roughly 24 hours before Emmy voting closes. That’s especially rough in the case of “Silicon Valley,” which has submitted its finale for writing consideration. While “Game of Thrones” and “Veep” did not submit their finales in writing or directing categories, they did submit the penultimate installments airing June 19 — nearly a week after voting started. And “Game of Thrones” did submit its finale in cinematography and costume categories. HBO was unable to confirm if Emmy voters will have a chance to see any of the finales in advance of their debut on the network.

• BBC America’s “Doctor Who” has been submitted for Emmy consideration for the first time ever. Now that the American cabler has come aboard as a co-producer, the venerable Brit series is finally eligible for consideration. Although it was not submitted as a drama series, star Peter Capaldi is on the lead actor ballot, showrunner Steven Moffat and director Rachel Talalay are on the writing and directing ballots for the episode “Heaven Sent” and the series is a possible nominee for costumes, production design, prosthetic makeup, and visual effects.

• The “Portlandia” duo of Fred Armisen and Carrie Brownstein have moved up to lead categories for their IFC sketch series after vying in supporting in the past. Armisen even received a nom for supporting actor in 2014. Sketch series performers were first deemed eligible to enter as lead performers last year.

The stars of Netflix’s sketch entry “W/ Bob & David,” Bob Odenkirk and David Cross, are also contending in the lead categories, while “Documentary Now!’s” Bill Hader is in lead, and co-star Armisen is in supporting.

The stars of Comedy Central’s “Key & Peele,” Keegan-Michael Key (a nominee last year) and Jordan Peele, remain in the supporting categories. Amy Schumer, who last year received the first ever lead nomination for a performer on a sketch series, remains in the lead category for “Inside Amy Schumer.”

• Speaking of Armisen, he’s on the Emmy ballot for comedy guest actor a whopping four times. He may have a shot for hosting the season finale of “Saturday Night Live” or playing Robert Durst on “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt,” but it seems like a stretch to also vie for nominations for playing Jesus Christ on FXX’s “Man Seeking Woman” and turning up on Hulu’s “Difficult People.” (And these are in addition to his bids for “Portlandia” and “Documentary Now!”)

• Meanwhile, the aforementioned Keegan-Michael Key is on the supporting actor ballot three times: for “Key & Peele,” natch, and additional slots for USA’s “Playing House” and the Hulu spoof “The Hotwives of Las Vegas.”

• Despite appearing on the ballot in the past, Sarah Hyland is the sole “Modern Family” regular (over the age of 10) not submitted in the supporting categories for Season 7.

• The struggle to define limited series versus drama series generally seems to be settled, but a few series that theoretically may have had additional seasons in success — Amazon’s “Mad Dogs,” NBC’s “Heroes: Reborn,” ABC’s “The Astronaut Wives Club,” Starz’s “Flesh and Bone” — are on the ballot for limited series. Which is where their producers will surely tell you they belonged all along.

Event series like Fox’s “The X-Files” and “Wayward Pines” (which is currently airing its second season), and The CW’s cancelled “Containment” are in the drama category to no one’s surprise.

• In a sign of how quickly things change, WGN’s “Manhattan” (produced by Lionsgate Television, Skydance Television and Tribune Studios) was not submitted for Emmy consideration for its second season. Last year, the studios and network made a big awards push for the prestige drama’s first season, and it did pick up one nom (for main title design, which it won). But the low-rated show didn’t gain any momentum in its second season and was cancelled. WGN has rallied around stronger performing newcomers, “Underground” and “Outsiders,” in its absence.

• Similarly, the final season of Gaumont International Television’s “Hannibal” for NBC has only been submitted in a handful of categories. Star Hugh Dancy is not on the ballot (possibly because it could conflict with his bid for Hulu’s “The Path”), making Mads Mikkelsen and guest star Richard Armitage the lone acting entries. The show was submitted for drama series consideration and writing, but no directors are on the ballot and it’s MIA in tech categories like cinematography and art direction too.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 6

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Mike Lipystein says:

    Would be nice if the Emmys were still about craft and art instead of who woos voters most. If it were about craft then we might see Matthew Rhys, Aden Young, Bobby Carnevale, or any of the Underground folks in the spots for lead actor, drama. Men like LIev Schreiber, a fine enough actor, but not emmy quality performance in this particular show. Take away his build, sex appeal, and voice and he wouldn’t be able to pull of the role. But look at someone like M Rhys who doesnt have the type-cast look of the part and gives one of the most truthful artistic performances out there.

    Sorry for my horrid spelling.

  2. Doctor Who’s Peter Capaldi is a gem and deserves recognition and an award for his portrayal of the multifaceted Doctor. It’s about time.

  3. Marcella says:

    Peter Capaldi absolutely deserves to be nominated and win this award as does the writer, Steven Moffat in his category. There was no better 45 minutes shown anywhere on television in 2015. Season 9 of Doctor Who is the best in the entire history of the show and Heaven Sent the best episode ever.

  4. MercySeat says:

    Peter Capaldi gave a performance in Heaven Sent which was not only universally hailed as the greatest in the 53 year history of that venerable British show but one which was unanimously praised by critics in the UK as one of the greatest seen on television for many years. Capaldi is a national treasure and thoroughly deserves Emmy consideration for elevating a childrens’ show scoffed at for the pantomime acting from its juvenille leading men to one now boasting the most accomplished and brilliant lead actor anywhere on television.

  5. Christian Shepherd says:

    The Doctor Who episode “Heaven Sent” was not just one of the very best episodes in the 53-year history of that show, it was one of the best episodes of television In the last few years full stop.
    I really do hope that voters give this episode due consideration. The contributions from Capaldi, writer Moffat and director Talalay are all absolutely top-tier. It’s an extraordinary piece of work.

  6. Maria says:

    I hope the Emmy voters will take a look at Peter Capaldi in Doctor Who and seriously consider him for a nomination for the episode Heaven Sent. He amazing performance was highly praised by the critics and fans alike. He deserves the recognition.

More TV News from Variety