Can Luc Besson’s ‘Valerian’ Succeed Where Recent Space Operas Have Failed?

'Valerian': Luc Besson Discusses the Space
Rob Latour/REX/Shutterstock

SAN DIEGO — As director Luc Besson and his wife Virginie Besson-Silla laid out in meticulous detail a vision for “Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets” — based on the French comic series “Valerian and Laureline” — their passion for the heavy genre material was certainly palpable. But it was difficult to ignore the specter of other attempted franchise launches from respected filmmakers that crashed on the rocks of “unproven intellectual property.”

“Finding Dory” broke Andrew Stanton out of director jail after his 2012 Edgar Rice Burroughs adaptation “John Carter” forced Disney to take a $200 million write-down. Warner Bros. took a hit on the titanically budgeted “Jupiter Ascending” last year from Lana Wachowski and Lilly Wachowski, after holding it over from 2014 to delay the pain. Unless it’s tied to successful preexisting brands (“Guardians of the Galaxy,” “Star Wars: The Force Awakens”), space opera just seems like a difficult sell these days.

“Valerian” stars Dane DeHaan and Cara Delevingne as a pair of 28th century agents who guard against temporal paradoxes at a time when humans can travel through space and time. Footage presented at the San Diego Convention Center Thursday revealed a sci-fi mish-mash reminiscent of movies like “Star Wars,” “Stargate” and Besson’s own “The Fifth Element,” as well as video games such as “Mass Effect” and “Portal.” There were “Blade Runner”-like flourishes as well, with imaginatively opulent design elements recalling the dense Rouge City environment of Steven Spielberg’s “A.I: Artificial Intelligence” (in a sequence featuring Ethan Hawke chewing the scenery as a fast-talking pimp of the future).

Many of those properties were no doubt influenced by “Valerian and Laureline,” so the circle is complete. And the Comic-Con crowd was sold. But the film will depend on that energy stretching far beyond walls of Hall H; a hefty $180 million price tag makes it the most expensive European production to date.


The Walking Dead

Comic-Con 2016 in Photos

Besson-Silla is producing on behalf of EuropaCorp, which is financing, producing and will distribute.

“Basically I grew up with it,” Besson said of the source material, which was created by Pierre Christin and Jean-Claude Mezieres in 1967 and has since sold more than 10 million copies in 21 languages. “It was just not possible [to make a film version]; it’s 10 percent humans and 90 percent aliens!”

Though the mountain seemed unscalable, Besson nevertheless secured the film rights, just in case he could crack it. He also developed a relationship with Mezieres, tapping him for conceptual design duties on “The Fifth Element.” Contrary to recent patterns, that 1997 film — starring Bruce Willis and Milla Jovovich — was a smashing global success for the genre.

Besson said he had a version of the movie that really worked for him on the page, but then James Cameron’s “Avatar” hit theaters in 2009 and caused him to strive for better. “I threw my script in the garbage and I started again,” he said. “Eventually, after a couple of years, I came up with a good script — I think.”


Valerian comic

‘Valerian’: First Look at Cara Delevingne, Dane DeHaan Sci-Fi Epic

Before presenting footage of the film, which is set for release July 21, 2017, Besson was honored with Comic-Con’s Inkpot Award, given to individuals for their contributions to the worlds of comics, science fiction/fantasy, film, television, animation and fandom services. The director held off on accepting right away, however, telling the audience that, if after they saw the footage they still thought he deserved it, then he would take it.

They approved, but the real test for a risky prospect like this will be global appeal. Can “Valerian” succeed where others have failed, or is there just no room for big, ballsy, unfamiliar properties to break through the franchise clutter?

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 25

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. EricJ says:

    When I think of “Big-budget French sci-fi comic adaptations”, I still think of Barbarella.

    Besson, unfortunately, does not let my expectations down. Luc, you’re TOO FRENCH.

  2. Marc Hertogh says:

    Guardians of the Galaxy was not a “successful pre-exiting brand”. Most people knew NOTHING of the characters. I knew nothing of the characters and read a fair amount of Marvel products. Guardians was a hit because Marvel studios has become a trusted name and James Gunn made a fantastic movie.

    • The “preexisting brand” referenced in that graph (i.e., “TIED TO preexisting brands”) is Marvel, a point you go on to prove in this comment by noting “Guardians was a hit because Marvel studios has become a trusted name.” This is rather clear in the text of the piece.

      Read closely, folks.

      • Cass says:

        Misleading title then? First one in everyone’s head is Guardians, which was a hit. A bit clickbaity, nicely done.

      • It’s not misleading at all. Recent space operas from respected directors like the Wachowskis and Andrew Stanton have flopped, full stop. I could have gotten into, say, the epic “Outer Space” script Oscar-winner Eric Roth has been trying to get off the ground for years, too, but I didn’t really need to. The only ones that seem to have clicked with audiences are attached to known brands. This one is not, much like the ones that have flopped.

  3. irwinator1992 says:

    I really want to see Beason succeed, tell a great story and raise the bar for creativity in the space opera genre. He seems to really know what the audience wants (sorry, Wachowskis!) I just hope EuropaCorp can find a good way to release the film properly or else it won’t stand a chance.

  4. Elie says:

    Maybe you Forget Avatar which was an original idea and end up being the most successfull movie in history…

  5. Knuckles Malloy says:

    I hate hearing that property failed because it was an unproven intellectual property. It failed because the story and the characters failed to connect with an audience for whatever reason. We need unproven intellectual properties. It’s how we eventually get proven intellectual properties.

  6. Skeptic says:

    The key detail left out of this story is the US distributor, which will need to flog this hard. Of course that happens to be RED, Besson’s new company, a co-venture with Relativity, the least reliable company out there right now. Regardless of how good this film ends up being and even how fans like it, if they can’t get it into theaters and bring in middle America, this will fail commercially.

  7. alex says:

    Guardians was an unknown existing property

  8. adam says:

    This has domestic box office BOMB written all over it. Think “Jupiter Ascending” kind of bomb. It may have a decent foreign box office take though.

    • Ben says:

      “Jupiter Ascending” looked totally gay. That’s why it flopped. The Wachowski’s used that film (and “Cloud Atlas”) to explore and justify their trans gender agenda, while missing that 90% of the audience doesn’t care for this. If your budget is small and it’s a good film like “Bound”, it makes financial sense to do something like that, but NOT if your budget is BIG. “Valerian” on the other hand is something boys might want to see, too, because of the cool hero, great action, innovative effects and the pretty girl detective. Luc Besson usually has a good instinct for what audiences crave to see.

More Film News from Variety