Ex-Universal Exec Brian Mulligan Says LAPD Officer’s Prior Conduct Should Have Been Admitted in Beating Case

Brian Mulligan LAPD Beating Case
Courtesy of Brian Mulligan

Brian Mulligan, the former Universal Pictures chairman who sued the Los Angeles Police Department for excessive use of force and retaliation stemming from a 2012 incident in Eagle Rock, says that the record of one of the officers, recently indicted on unrelated rape charges, should have been allowed in his case.

The officer, James Nichols, was indicted earlier this week on multiple sexual assault charges along with another officer, Luis Valenzuela. They are charged with raping several women while on duty.

Nichols was also the officer who apprehended Mulligan in the 2012 encounter. The LAPD claimed that officers needed to restrain Mulligan after he had shown aggressive behavior toward them that evening. But Mulligan, who was hospitalized after the incident with a broken nose and shoulder blade, and other injuries, contended that he feared for his life and was the victim of rogue officers.

A federal jury in 2014 ruled that Nichols and another officer, John Miller, who were also defendants in Mulligan’s case, had not violated his civil rights and had not engaged in battery. Mulligan and his attorney, Skip Miller, appealed the district court decisions, with oral arguments scheduled for March 7 in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

In a statement, Mulligan said: “I am beyond proud of the women who came forward despite the alleged threats against them. I only wish that the true nature of Officer Nichols had been allowed to be shown to the jury in my civil case, which is on appeal.”

“I applaud the courage of the victims in coming forward and the district attorney in filing the criminal case against the officers,” Mulligan added. “Together these actions may lead to a safer Los Angeles and ethical police force.”

According to county prosecutors, Nichols and Valenzuela allegedly began sexually assaulting four women at various locations, including in their police vehicle. The four women has been arrested at various times by the officers during narcotics-related offenses, prosecutors said. If convicted, they face up to life sentences in state prison.

In his appeal, Mulligan argues that Nichols already had an “extensive, documented history of assaults” at the time of the 2012 incident, but that the LAPD failed to remove him from active duty. Nichols’ record was not allowed to be entered into evidence in the trial.

Mulligan also contends that after he filed a claim against the city and the officers, the LAPD, the police union and the city attorney’s office joined forces in retaliation. That included a press release and the release of an audio tape in which Mulligan admits to using bath salts while talking to a Glendale police officer days before the incident.

Mulligan testified at the trial that it was “just a mistake” that he had used them, but he has contended that he was not under the influence of the synthetic drug the night of the incident.

“Defendants obtained the Glendale audio tape under false pretenses, then colluded to leak it in violation of the LAPD’s confidentiality rules, and then publicly maligned and humiliated Mulligan by way of a vicious press release,” Mulligan’s legal team, led by Skip Miller of Miller Barondess, wrote in an appellate brief.

Mulligan was a vice chairman of Deutsche Bank at the time, but his employer fired him after the Glendale tape was released, his brief states.

Mulligan testified at the 2014 trial that he feared for his life that evening, as the officers, after their initial encounter with him, dropped him off at a nearby motel and threatened him if he left. Mulligan did leave, only to encounter them again, when he was beaten. He claimed that Nichols struck him with his baton, swinging it like a baseball bat, and then used his baton to restrain him by his shoulder blades, breaking his scapula twice.

Mulligan’s appellate brief also says that a jury should be allowed to consider whether it was reasonable for the officers to sequester him that evening in the “crime-ridden Highland Park Motel” and then cause “him to flee in fear, resulting in the use of force on Meridian Street.” His legal team also says that jurors should have been allowed to hear evidence that authorities declined to charge Mulligan with any crime.

According to a report presented by Mulligan’s attorneys, a drug test conducted at the hospital turned up negative for drugs other than sleep aids.

At the trial, attorneys for the officers and LAPD presented a much different story. They portrayed Mulligan as an unhinged drug abuser who was under the influence to the point of frothing at the mouth and threatening the officers with physical harm. At the trial, a city attorney told the jury that officers found two bottles of “white lightning” in Mulligan’s car after they confronted him outside a medical marijuana dispensary on that night — triggering the chain of events leading to the beating.

Nichols’ attorney Jules Zeman, in an appellate brief, argued that when the officers arrived Mulligan appeared “greatly disoriented and incoherent.” After he was uncooperative in contacting relatives or friends who could take him home, they tried to drop him off at a motel to “sleep it off,” but he became “even more erratic,” according to Nichols’ brief.

They encountered him again an hour later “trying to open locked parked cars and trying to enter one car that was being driven by a frightened woman.” When they tried to apprehend him, he “persisted in fighting the officers” as they tried to restrain him.

In the brief, Zeman wrote that because the sexual assault allegations against Nichols were “allegations,” the district court was right to exclude them. He also noted that the trial was bifurcated, with the case proceeding if the jury first found that Mulligan was the victim of battery or assault, which they did not. Had they done so, Zeman wrote, evidence of Nichols’ prior history could have been presented.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Monty Prime says:

    caroline is aguirre has been involved with the LAPD and their unions for decades. She protects bad cops like the two above as does the Union and their paid lackeys. There was no such calls about Mulligan breaking into cars and admitted no such thing. Mulligan was not charged with any crime whatsoever. You would have to be brain dead to believe the cops’ story. Because of Mulligan who had the guts to do the right thing when the LAPD and their Union wouldn’t these cops are finally off the streets and citizens are safer in my opinion. Something the LAPD and Union should have done in 2008 (8 years ago – that’s not the odd part of the story?) and Mulligan wouldn’t have been nearly killed and the additional alleged victims lives wouldn’t have been destroyed. Think if they were your children. Myopic dense people who need a posse don’t get real courage. They are willing to trade their souls to protect the above alleged sickening assaults and tarnish good police officers on the beat. Thus they put good cops in harms way. But they don’t care who they hurt even their own. They protect and serve themselves.

  2. caroline aguirre says:

    What Brian Mulligan has failed to state was that it was the public who called the police 911 calls because a male was attempting to gain entry into parked vehicles. After Mulligan left the motel once again private persons called the police and again they were 911 calls. Mulligan by his own statements had a very serious substance abuse problem.

  3. Jim Mulligan says:

    This entire trial was a joke. On African American person was available for the Jury and she was a corrections officer. Not only was the prosecution aware of the ongoing rapes, one of the prosecutors is a woman and she has four daughters and she fought until thee two Rapists Cops could continue work and rape again. Funny position for a Mother. Not only was the tape of the conversation leaked in court by the prosecution allowed by the judge, the tape entered was spliced and tampered with. Their was nothing the defendant could do. The judge, the prosecution attorneys and the system were all staged against the defendant. Name another jury selection pool that had one African American person in the pool and she worked for the cops. Beck was very involved, the emails will show you, and he fought so hard to keep both of the rapist cops on the beat to rape again, because he couldn’t take a chance at losing this case.. The judge, prosecution attorney’s and the captain of the police force all knew and all work to put the rapists on the street to rape again. They knew, they knew and they all knew. Can you imagine all these people were in their positions to make us safer and they positioned themselves in ways that would allow two rapists with a badge to roam free and prey on your daughters and to beat again and kill if needed. This is my opinion from what I collected from the trial, internet and speaking with some of the parties involved. The judge who attend St. Bede’s in La Canada and pretends his is a man of God pulled all the strings to make sure these rapists could roam free to rape and beat again.

    Beck knew the entire time. He may thinks he’s hid all his emails and covered his tracks, but your leader of the “Protect and Serve” union was leasing by “Neglect and cover your ass.”

    They should make a movie about this situation where everyone knew and the entire leadership that could have kept the beating rapists off the streets including the Captain of the police force, the Judge, all the prosecution team, one with four daughters, the other had a massive heart attack, along with the people in charge of the jury pool knew and were all in on it.

    This is my opinion and it one you will find out is spot on soon enough. This would be a best seller if it was a book or movie, because you just can’t make up this much cover up. O.J. because it was on T.V. had a better chance. Our judge, you guess it, wouldn’t allow camera’s in the courtroom.

More Biz News from Variety