TV Review: ‘The Comedians’

The Comedians cancelled
Courtesy of FX

It’s surprising to learn “The Comedians” was based on a Swedish series, since the execution feels highly personal and deeply rooted in the here-and-now U.S. Yet another program featuring actors as slightly tweaked versions of themselves, this FX comedy deals with Billy Crystal and Josh Gad being thrown together to co-star in an FX variety show — the twist being that they almost instantly can’t stand each other. Dotted with celebrity cameos, the customary exaggerated Hollywood insecurities and an underlying commentary on the generational divide, the show generates enough solid laughs to overcome its arid patches.

Filled with meta references (the FX network president, played by Denis O’Hare, looks and sounds quite a lot like real-life version John Landgraf), the program begins with Crystal learning that his plans for an FX series — one in which he plays all the parts — won’t fly without including Gad, the Broadway star and part-time snowman. (Embracing failure, Gad keeps a “1600 Penn” poster in his dressing room.)

The two meet for a get-acquainted dinner that proves an unmitigated disaster, so much so that the project seems to be dead. Ultimately, however, both sign on, creating a shotgun marriage where almost every attempt to bond goes completely awry — such as Gad, a basketball novice, dropping by while Crystal watches a Clippers playoff game.

To Crystal, Gad can be boorish: The older man is stupefied when he mentions the legendary Ernie Kovacs, and is met with a blank stare. Meanwhile, Gad can’t grasp Crystal’s neediness given all the success he’s enjoyed, and when he learns they’ll be working together says, “Nobody was more excited than my grandparents.”

Along the way (and nine episodes were made available), there are brief but amusing glimpses of the sketches produced for the show, a Mel Brooks cameo and Dana Delaney as Crystal’s wife. In the best half-hour, Crystal and Gad are supposed to attend what’s obviously meant to be the Kids Choice Awards together, only to get insanely high and take an ill-advised detour to a supermarket.

Within the office, there’s the harried producer (Stephnie Weir), equally harried head writer (Matt Oberg) and blase production assistant (Megan Ferguson), who can’t be bothered to do any of the menial tasks that go with the job description.

Format-wise “The Comedians” simply apes the docu-series-spoof we’ve probably seen too much of since “The Office,” complete with direct-to-camera interviews and plenty of fake showbiz smiles. The program also contains a serialized element, with the fate of the show-within-the-show rising and falling along with the network’s faith in the project.

Given how close this all hews to reality — such as Crystal opening up to Gad about losing his father at an early age — viewer reaction will likely depend in part on their tolerance of the stars in general, and Crystal in particular.

Still, “The Comedians” is likely more commercial than the acclaimed but little-watched “Louie,” with which it will be paired, and could even funnel some viewers in that direction. If the show can manage such a trick, these two comics had better get used to each other — in their real guise, if not their fictional one.

TV Review: 'The Comedians'

(Series; FX, Thur. April 9, 10 p.m.)


Filmed in Los Angeles by Jennilind Prods., Larry Charles Projects, Tamaroa Prods., Flying Glass of Milk Prods., and Fabrik Entertainment in association with Fox 21 Television Studios.


Executive producers, Ben Wexler, Matt Nix, Larry Charles, Billy Crystal, Mikkel Bondesen, Henrik Bastin, Kristen Campo, Carl Molinder, John Nordling; co-executive producer, Josh Gad; producers, Victor Hsu, Samantha Sprecher; director, Charles; writers, Wexler, Nix, Charles, Crystal; camera, Anthony Hardwick; production designer, Charles Breen, Rusty Smith; editor, Steven Lang; casting, Allison Jones. 30 MIN.


Billy Crystal, Josh Gad, Stephnie Weir, Matt Oberg, Megan Ferguson, Dana Delaney, Denis O’Hare, Steven Weber

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. dave merryman says:

    Tell Billy that I am not rich , but if he needs money bad enough to sign on to this crap, I’ll try to help him out. We have decided Crystal never read any of the scrips before signing his contract or he had no idea that his co- “STAR” must have pictures of somebody at FX having sex with a goat or why else would be allowed on tv. No FX for us on Thursday

  2. LMBilly says:

    It’s smart, it’s funny and it’s touching. Like everything, I guess it’s a matter of taste, but check it out, because if you get it, it’ll be one of your favourite new shows!

  3. Ignatz says:

    There’s something almost ghoulish about Crystal’s desperate need to be liked that comes right through his characters failed attempts at ironic self referential humor, which along with his seeming need for our pity at his loss of relevance, while still parading around his past glories and money that makes him seem like a complete schmuck. I resolved to quit watching the series after the “Birthday” episode…no chemistry between any of the actors, Crystal and a waxy-looking Dana Delany and that dressed-up doughnut Josh Gad particularly. I really do hope that FX comes to its senses and cancels this cloying dreck to make room for something worth watching.

  4. Bond1965 says:

    A show about two comedians who can’t stand each other? Well I can’t stand the two comedians so I can skip this.

More TV News from Variety