Emmy Award Nominations: 10 Things the TV Academy Got Right

Emmy Award Nominations: Tatiana Maslany,' More
Courtesy of Comedy Central

The Emmy Award nominations are out. Unleash the hounds!

What new outrages have the TV Academy committed? Who have the voters overlooked? How can the process ever be taken seriously again after, well, insert your favorite oversight here?

Other than being announced this year at a less-ungodly hour, the annual unveiling has assumed an element of predictability in the digital age. Early-morning phone calls extending congratulations to and soliciting thoughts from the nominees, almost immediately followed by peals of righteous indignation on behalf of the deserving souls who are not, alas, among them.

Both of these are legitimate pursuits, but neither really tells the full story – or, for that matter, exhibits much perspective about the expanded roster of options now available and the increased viability of niche-oriented programming, which can survive on prestige longer than was once feasible in the days of ad-supported broadcast networks and a couple of premium channels. So since the second phase of the process is to skewer the Emmys for what they got wrong, let’s jump ahead to the third iteration, and point out 10 things that the voters got right:

Limited series. The category formerly known as “miniseries” produced an extraordinarily strong field of contenders, one that embraced ABC’s challenging “American Crime” as well as HBO’s splendid “Olive Kitteridge,” PBS’ sumptuous “Wolf Hall,” SundanceTV’s “The Honorable Woman” and FX’s customarily florid “American Horror Story” franchise. The acting nominations are similarly impressive, offering a terrific glimpse of the breadth of first-rate work being done across a variety of channels.

“Empire”/Taraji P. Henson. Although it will be popular to call the omission of “Empire” as best drama series a “snub,” given that several other terrific shows were left out of that field, who exactly would people bump to make room for it? The Fox hit was a force of nature, yes, but hardly a breakthrough drama, with its most salient element being Henson’s work as the quotable Cookie, and she, of course, earned a well-deserved nomination.

Comedy Central. A consistent complaint about the Emmys has been that the TV Academy skews older, and thus has a bias against youth-oriented shows. So the spate of nominations for Comedy Central’s sketch fare, such as “Inside Amy Schumer” and “Key & Peele,” reflects a bit of growth on that front, even if it’s offset, to a degree, by the exclusion of the CW’s “Jane the Virgin.”

Diversity. Despite some rather glaring oversights – Constance Wu and Gina Rodriguez, you was robbed – the Academy did expand its recognition of minority performers. Beyond Anthony Anderson’s nod for “Black-ish,” that included several choices in the supporting categories, as well as the loud splash “Bessie” made in the movie arena.

Variety series. Win or lose, David Letterman and Jon Stewart will each get to take another bow, while sharing the stage with newer voices like John Oliver, not merely providing an element of nostalgia but capturing a moment of generational change in latenight comedy.

Tatiana Maslany. “Orphan Black” is not a great show, but the actress turned her multiheaded work playing a small army of characters into more than just a gimmick, one that cried out for at least some recognition for this BBC America drama.

“Better Call Saul.” Despite the good will that “Breaking Bad” had accrued, this prequel was a much different animal. So it took a bit of imagination, and sticking with it as the series developed and evolved, to honor not just the show but stars Bob Odenkirk – brilliantly stepping outside of his comedy turf – and Jonathan Banks.

Documentary/nonfiction series. What often feels like one of those sleepy categories populated by the likes of “American Masters” has a couple of spectacular, high-profile standouts in its ranks this year, with HBO’s “The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst” going up against Ken Burns’ “The Roosevelts: An Intimate History.” If the former wins, the producers should deliver their acceptance speech on a hot mic in the bathroom.

Boardwalk Empire.” Something of an afterthought, no doubt, and ignored in several key races, it was still welcome to see this landmark HBO drama recognized with a total of 10 nominations, including Timothy Van Patten for directing the series finale.

A banner year for streamers. Amazon’s breakthrough with “Transparent” shouldn’t obscure how Netflix solidified its foundation at the Emmys, including major nominations for “Bloodline” and “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” as well as stalwarts “House of Cards” (a show, frankly, whose inclusion as best series is questionable) and “Orange Is the New Black,” which established its ability to remain a player even when reclassified into the more suitable (and competitive) drama field. And with those outlets now established players, the Emmy pack becomes that much more crowded, meaning the hits – and the “snubs” – will just keep on coming.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 13

Leave a Reply

13 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. “Orphan Black is not a great show, but…”

    You lost me, oh supposed television expert.

  2. Mike M says:

    Still no Dyslexic Black LGBT Amputee Female Lead Actress, Drama category then huh? Oh well, surely next year… it’s a sad commentary on the state of awards ceremonies when the total negative word count they generate outnumbers the positive by three or four to one. But hey, any publicity… right? Contrived, ill conceived, unable to keep up… and that’s before we get to the problems. And so at this point I must stop, and hand off to someone that always had a meaningful solution to hand. Dr. Sidney Freedman: You know, I told you people something a long time ago, and it’s just as pertinent today as it was then. Ladies and gentlemen, take my advice – pull down your pants and slide on the ice.

  3. James says:

    The person writing this article has either never seen Orphan Black, has no taste, is one of those elitist snob critics who hates everything, or a combination of all the above.

  4. SarahBeth Rachel says:

    Excuse me !?! Did you really write, “Orphan Black is not a great show” ???
    Are you kidding? Have you actually watched more that two minutes?
    OB has so many well crafted elements that make for enjoyable TV viewing ~ terrific storyline, great acting, wonderful editing, to name just a few. The characters are interesting, likeable or hate~able, serious and fun, nuanced and real. Seriously, I can’t believe you would write that. Helena is not going to like your comment. Nor Alison. No, not one bit. And I’m not sure which one you should fear most.

    • Mike says:

      AGREED. I actually didn’t even realize that she was playing the blond, English character until half-way through the season, she’s that good.

  5. Ann Terhune says:

    Walton Goggins in Justified was overlooked.

  6. lrg514 says:

    Why is Robert Carlyle as Mr. Gold in OUAT consistently and egregiously overlooked. His performance is multifaceted and always intriguing.

  7. Sorry, Bryan, Maslany is a gimmick actress whose role screams Emmy bait. Mariska Hargitay x a gazillion. A much better choice is Rachel Nichols, who has anchored ‘Continuum’ for 3 spectacularly creative seasons.

    • Sorry, Paul, you are so wrong. Each of the performances for each of the characters is so precise and so believable and to do that in one show is simply amazing. Especially amazing when you think about all this work, it must be exhausting, she does not get the comfort of finding the groove of one character and being able to stay in that groove for the life of the show. She has to switch back and forth from character to character while filming and pretty much almost always being on screen. It would be amazing even if she did not do it so well.

  8. trflanigan says:

    definitely feel that boardwalk empire was snubbed in the actor and actress category. the whole cast did an excellent job in the final season. it was such a fast moving season. i really miss the show.

  9. Lenora Robinson says:

    Mr. Letterman, please join the festivities this September. We will enjoy watching you again!
    You are the best at what you do. Thank you again for all the laughs, emotional moments,
    and just plain darn good ol’ tomfoolery!

  10. lila fowler says:

    Richard Jenkins for Olive Kitteridge! He was left out at other awards, glad he was included here.

More TV News from Variety

Loading