Relativity’s Demise a Lesson in Over-Reaching: Analysts

Relativity Bankruptcy Evokes Sadness, Caution Among

The collapse of Relativity Media has provoked a sense of shock and dejection — along with a blunt reminder of the brutal bottom-line focus required for survival in Hollywood — among media trackers.

“It seems like another instance of over-reaching,” noted Matthew Harrigan, a media analyst with Wunderlich Securities. “They tried a very clinical approach but at the end of the day, Relativity didn’t have enough scale to compete effectively.”

Thus, Ryan Kavanaugh joins a long list of self-styled Hollywood moguls — with such names as Howard Hughes, Carolco’s Mario Kassar and MGM’s Giancarlo Paretti — who fell short after an initial splash amid promises of a new paradigm for success in the filmed entertainment business.

“I wish it weren’t true, but this filing does have a chilling effect on people being willing to invest,” Harrigan added.

The analyst noted that failures are not uncommon and pointed to the 2010 disappearance of The Film Department, a smaller venture organized by industry veterans Mark Gill and Neil Sacker. The duo attracted investors who were close to ponying up $200 million in new financing to produce, acquire and release five to 10 films a year but pulled its IPO registration statement when the financing evaporated.

“Those are very smart guys with a good plan,” Harrigan recalled. “It just shows how hard this business is to operate when you don’t have access to low-cost funds.”

Jason E. Squire, an associate professor at the USC’s School of Cinematic Arts, told Variety that the filing is a sobering development.

“I think it’s always quite sad when a player is lost,” Squire told Variety. “This is a cyclical and uncertain business that doesn’t need this right now.”

About 75 of 250 Relativity employees were handed pink slips on Wednesday in advance of Thursday’s filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, which disclosed that most of the assets of the 11-year-old company founded by Kavanaugh will be sold at auction.

“It’s very tough for the people for the people who are losing their jobs,” Squire said. “And as a filmmaker, you never want to see your films get caught in this kind of situation.”‘

Longtime media analyst Harold Vogel said that Relativity’s collapse is not singular.

“The road is littered with companies that could not keep the cash flow going,” he noted. “At the end of day, you need big cash in Hollywood. These companies usually start with ambitious people who don’t have deep enough libraries to do that.”

Vogel added that the economics of Hollywood have not gotten any easier in recent years.

“You never have enough cash and a billion dollars doesn’t buy that much any more, given that 50% of your spending is now in marketing,” he asserted. “The competition for the attention of the audience has gotten much more severe, given the shift toward over the top programming and videogames.”

Only the major studios have the scale to absorb the massive losses on tentpoles such as “John Carter” and “Battleship,” Vogel noted. And despite Relativity’s woes, he believes that investors will still be willing to open their checkbooks to back feature films.

“I don’t think Relativity is going to diminish that interest,” he noted. “But it is a reminder of how difficult the business is.”

 

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 3

Leave a Reply

3 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Jack Leder says:

    Eran Creevy’s action thriller “Collide,” which was due for release Stateside by Ryan Kavanaugh’s Relativity on Oct. Relativity Media announced Thursday it has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and is for sale.

  2. holy moly says:

    ANYONE AT RELATIVITY OR IN THE INDUSTRY CAN TELL YOU THAT THE REAL REASON FOR RELATIVITY’S MELTDOWN IS DUE TO RYAN AND TUCKER. NEITHER OF THEM, ESPECIALLY TUCKER, KNOWS HOW TO MANAGE A COMPANY OR PICK/MAKE MOVIES. NO MATTER HOW MUCH THEY WANT TO BLAME THE DOWNFALL OF THE COMPANY ON EXPANSION INTO OTHER BUSINESSES LIKE FASHION, THE REAL REASON IS SIMPLE; THESE GUYS MAKE BAD MOVIES AND DON’T KNOW HOW TO RUN A COMPANY.

  3. Ayu Dyah says:

    i completely agree with this article. Relativity seemed so ambitious at first, but in the end rarely made its movie b.e.p .. 5-10 movies a year will be in vain, if you only have 2-3 films who barely b.e.p

    Still i’m sure Relativity has a big chance with some project in hands. But most of them are not a mass-attracted-typical. Like Jane Got A Gun, may have big chance in Award Season. But it will hardly work at the box office.

    What Relativity needs now a person like Kevin Feige. Someone who really love and understand movies, but also have a good instinct at business.

More Film News from Variety

Loading