Film Review: ‘All Things Must Pass’

all-things-must-pass-tower-records
Image Courtesy of Robert Landau

A sentimental yet sharply observed documentary about the rise and demise of retail giant Tower Records.

While focusing on the rise and demise of Tower Records, the fallen retail giant that once billed its flagship location as “The Largest Record-Tape Store in the Known World,” actor-turned-documentarian Colin Hanks also offers glances at the bigger picture of 21st-century recording industry upheavals in “All Things Must Pass.” The movie’s primary audience likely will be baby boomers and Gen Xers who fondly recall the joys of discovery during shopping sprees in brick-and-mortar music stores. But even viewers who have never owned, or even played, a vinyl record may be fascinated by the cautionary tale that Hanks spins beneath the surface of his sentimental celebration.

Hanks and writer Steven Leckart are incalculably fortunate to have at their disposal the colorful commentary of Russ Solomon, the loquacious octogenarian who started selling records in the back of his father’s Sacramento drugstore in 1960, and steadily built a global chain of Tower Records outlets emblazoned with trademark red-and-yellow signage. Each store was a mammoth music marketplace where virtually every recording imaginable was displayed for easy browsing, purposeful shopping and/or impulse buying. Arguably the most famous of the bunch: the legendary Los Angeles location on the Sunset Strip, where everyday people and showbiz superstars rubbed shoulders while traversing the aisles.

Elton John — who considered it “a ritual” to visit the Sunset Strip store during every L.A. visit — proudly states during one of the film’s many interviews: “I spent more money in Tower Records than any other human being.” Another satisfied customer: John Lennon, who actually cut a wacky radio commercial for Tower back in the day.

Solomon shares screen time with several former employees and associates, all of whom wax nostalgic about the wild-and-crazy early days of Tower Records expansion, when sales clerks hired (literally) off the street could work their way up to management positions, and lunch breaks often expanded to allow for excessive consumption of booze and drugs. (One interviewee recalls listing the cost of “handtruck fuel” — i.e., cocaine — in company ledgers.) The opening of the first Tower store in New York was cause for tearful exuberance. The opening of the first store in Japan only served to increase company-wide confidence that the fun — and the moneymaking — would never stop.

But it did. Even before the advent of Napster and other streaming services in the 1990s, Tower Records — much like the rest of the record industry — suffered dearly for its inability (or unwillingness) to adapt and evolve. The artificially high price of CDs, along with the end of the CD single, rankled customers who gradually rebelled against paying for tracks they didn’t care to hear. It didn’t help much when big-box retailers such as Best Buy and Walmart started slashing CD prices in a loss-leader campaign to increase customer traffic. And it helped even less when steadily mounting debt led to management shakeups and draconian layoffs, desperate measures that proved to be too little, too late, to keep Tower Records afloat.

In 1999, the documentary duly notes during its opening minutes, Tower Records recorded $1 billion in earnings. Five years later, the chain entered bankruptcy.

The story of Tower Records is an all-too-familiar one — one frequently told about other once-thriving retail chains that have found themselves on the wrong side of history. (Did somebody say Radio Shack? Borders?) It is much to the credit of Hanks and his collaborators that “All Things Must Pass” makes this particular iteration of the oft-told tale come across as freshly compelling, even poignant.

With the help of lensers Nicola Marsh, Bridger Nielson and Neil Lisk, and editor Darrin Roberts, Hanks has fashioned an interweaving of talking-heads interviews, archival material and retailer history lesson that is soundly constructed, briskly paced and, in the end, affectingly wistful. The apt title, by the way, is the message — drawn from George Harrison’s classic pop song — that appeared on a banner hung outside the original Tower Records store in Sacramento during its final days of operation.

A final irony: “All Things Must Pass” should enjoy a healthy run on the festival circuit, and may even have limited theatrical exposure. But, like the music that used to be Tower Records’ stock-in-trade, it will doubtless reach most people through digital streaming. And so it goes.

Film Review: 'All Things Must Pass'

Reviewed at SXSW Film Festival (24 Beats Per Second), March 19, 2015. Running time: 100 MIN.

Production

(Documentary) A Company Name production. Produced by Sean Stuart. Executive producer, Glen Zipper. Co-Executive producer, Nick Ferrall.

Crew

Directed by Colin Hanks. Written by Steven Leckart. Camera (color), Nicola Marsh, Bridger Nielson, Neil Lisk; editor, Darrin Roberts; music, Bill Sherman; sound, Michael Kool.

With

Russ Solomon, Michael Solomon, Heidi Cotler, Mark Viducich, Stan Goman, Bob Delanoy, Bruce Springsteen, Elton John, David Geffen, Dave Grohl.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 6

Leave a Reply

6 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. A.T. says:

    Thank you for the thoughtful review. From the perspective of an ex-Tower employee from the Books Division who worked my way up from a clerk in Sacramento to a regional manager in charge of book departments in record stores in the Mid-Atlantic/Atlanta/New Orleans/Mexico City, the documentary offers an incisive insider look at the idiosyncratic indie culture that made Tower great, while also offering sobering analyses of what went wrong at the end when untimely over-expansion and cumbersome old-school business strategies collided with nimble-moving, easily-accessible Digital Age technologies. Colin Hanks & Sean Stuart’s documentary is award-caliber, to be sure.

    Another irony beyond that mentioned in the closing paragraph of the review: this documentary would’ve never been made without crowd-source funding via the internet, the very vehicle that played a significant role in Tower’s ultimate demise.

  2. Ann Scott says:

    Read about it in this issue of “Sactown Magazine”!

  3. Gillian says:

    Does anyone know if/when this movie will come out in theaters? I have a group of friends in Sacramento who all used to work for Tower and we are all awaiting its arrival in Sac!!

  4. Bill B. says:

    I miss Tower. I spent a lot of my youth in them. Like bookstores, magazines, newspapers, video rental chains, etc., the Internet eliminated their purpose. I do like the quote about the artificial pricing. I remember when CD’s first came out and they were a shockingly high $13 to $15 each and everyone said that the prices would go down once everyone started buying them. Everyone did buy them eventually, but the price drop never happened. Never really increased all that much over the decades either. The profits must have been enormous the first couple of decades. I feel pretty ripped off, but nevertheless, I still miss them. One could be entertained for hours in them.

  5. jazz says:

    spent many a day and a dollar in tower records…and i am sure i will purchase this documentary on dvd when it comes out…it’s sad how some of the things are described in this, albeit, well written article…first off, walmart and best buy have NOTHING in common with tower records…anyone who shopped at tower would never dare purchase music at either of those locations…also, the cd single had little to do with it as well…more over it was the generation who was came up who ‘think’ they like music, but only breed familiarity rather than totality…true tower shoppers were the ones who really listened to music, and wanted all the album tracks, not just the hits…what killed tower mostly, along with other brick-n-mortar palaces, was simply amazon.com…period…the ease and selection (and price in most cases) made it harder for stores to stock and sell…the experience was still always there and could never be replecated by clicking a mouse, but for a generation who doesn’t remember fondly the moldy smell of a back room with vinyl in cardboard boxes on the floor, clicking a mouse is as far as they go…

  6. John Miller says:

    Tower was so great! Glad that Colin has made this documentary, looking forward to seeing it.

More Film News from Variety

Loading