John Williams Could Land 50th Oscar Nod in Competitive Original Score Race

The Hateful Eight The Force Awakens
Courtesy of The Weinstein Company/Disney/Focus

Other top contenders include 'The Hateful Eight,' 'Spotlight' and the late James Horner for 'The 33'

It’s a pretty good bet that if John Williams has an original score in play during a given Oscar season, he’s going to be Oscar-nominated for it. His 44 nods to date (plus five more for songs) don’t exactly lie. So how can you start a discussion of this year’s score contenders anywhere else but with “Star Wars: The Force Awakens?”

How much original music will be in the film, though, and how much will it distinguish itself from the iconic pre-existing themes? That’s the question. While all three original “Star Wars” films were nominated, none of the prequels made it. This will be just one more mystery held close to the vest until Disney decides to let the cat out of the bag next month. But it could yield a 50th Oscar nomination from the cinema legend.

From one legend to another, there’s Ennio Morricone, providing his first original score for a western — Quentin Tarantino’s “The Hateful Eight” — in 40 years. It was a different process on this one, as the maestro supplied music largely inspired by the screenplay (he still hasn’t seen the film). It’s not the jaunty spaghetti western material one might have expected, but rather, moody, tension-building work with music box nods to the Italian Giallo genre here and there. He’s a titan within the branch and this mixture is sure to be unique in the fray.

Howard Shore’s “Spotlight” score is deceptive. At first listen, it can feel quite minimalist. In reality, though, it’s very complex, a piano-heavy, classical-like composition that uncannily elevates the material. Shore has won three Oscars for his work on the “Lord of the Rings” franchise, very different from the delicacy of this, of course.

The reigning champ in the category, Alexandre Desplat, is a mainstay as of late: He has received eight nominations in nine years, culminating in a win earlier this year for “The Grand Budapest Hotel.” His work on “The Danish Girl” is typically elegant, with a trickling theme that plays up the fragility of the film’s central character.

Another branch favorite is Thomas Newman, though he’s still searching for his first win after landing 11 nominations (plus one for best original song) over the years. He stepped in for Steven Spielberg regular Williams on “Bridge of Spies” and delivered something that features a lot of his hallmarks, but still feels at home in the Spielberg oeuvre, equal parts chilling Cold War and swelling Americana. (His work on “Spectre” is also rather good.)

Elsewhere, Carter Burwell still doesn’t have an Oscar nomination to his name. It’s sort of outrageous at this point. He breathes special life into Todd Haynes’ “Carol” — exemplary across the board in the crafts arenas — with lush piano and woodwinds. (His contributions to Bill Condon’s “Mr. Holmes” also deserve a serious look from the branch.)

“The Revenant,” meanwhile, could be a player across the board. Alejandro G. Iñárritu has tapped Ryûichi Sakamoto to help conjure a percussion-driven piece of work that works in tandem with an immersive sound mix.

In John Crowley’s “Brooklyn,” Michael Brook brings a subtle Irish vibe to the soundtrack. It’s not overwrought when it could have been, given the tale of an Irish immigrant finding her way in America. He hasn’t been recognized by the Academy yet, though his score for “Into the Wild” was nominated for a Golden Globe.

As for sweepers, if we’re to assume “The Martian” is a major Oscar player across the board, then the possibility is certainly there for some interesting coattails. Harry Gregson-Williams doesn’t bore with a standard blockbuster score and in fact it feels quite progressive within the category. He could be a sleeper.

Finally, the branch lost one of its most popular members this year, eight-time score nominee (and two-time song nominee) James Horner, who won in each of those categories for “Titanic.” Horner died in a Santa Barbara plane crash last June, and his swan song is the work he contributed to Patricia Riggen’s trapped coal miners drama “The 33.” It’s exceptional music with an international flare, which often goes over well with this lot. And it might just be too tempting in general to recognize the legend one more time.

There are so many others, though. Michael Giacchino won a Oscar for “Up” and could be back with another Pixar hit, “Inside Out”; Jóhann Jóhannsson borderline terrifies with the brooding of “Sicario”; James Newton Howard, a branch favorite, goes big (some might say too big) in “Concussion”; Patrick Doyle’s “Cinderella” score has a following; Dan Romer’s epic work on “Beasts of No Nation” is truly transcendent; and Tom Holkenborg’s grand compositions on “Black Mass” couldn’t differ more from the mania of “Mad Max: Fury Road,” but both are worthy of being in the conversation.

Keep track of the best original score race all season long at the category’s dedicated Contenders page.

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 16

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. cadavra says:

    Horner still has one more score to come: the remake of THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN.

  2. I feel this is another category that’s basically ruined. The same names year after year, and they just seem bought to me. The public knows the years best score already – it’s the one kids and adults alike are humming in schools and offices. And it’s not something by Desplat.

  3. La_Haine says:

    No mention of Steve Jobs?

  4. Bob says:

    Howard Shore had no business winning three Oscars for his self-referencing LoTR scores … what in the world possessed the Academy to give him nearly as many Oscars as they have Williams whose scores are much more iconic and have spanned the decades?

  5. filmguy78 says:

    I think it’s spot on about all who’s mentioned (Giacchino, Williams, et al) but one that I would hope to get some recognition is Daniel Pemberton. This guy came out of nowhere and delivered a beautiful score for Steve Jobs. I thought the score was one of the highlights of the film. He also did some snazzy work on Man from U.N.C.L.E. A flop I know that won’t get nominated but his score for that reminds me of the great work of Piero Umiliani or Francis Lai. In any case, I think Pemberton’s a composer to keep an eye, or this case an ear, on.

  6. red_wine says:

    John Williams is a god, he is not human. He writes music for the gods.

    There is no way the score will be ineligible due to use of existing material. Williams has never verbatim repeated himself, he always writes plenty of new themes and motifs and all the underscore is new. Just a few statements of iconic themes doesn’t mean he is re-using material.

    You actually heard his first new theme in the ABC one minute TV spot and it pretty much already is the best thing I have heard this year.

    If Abrahms doesn’t drown out the film in Sound FX, I think this has the potential to be another John Williams masterpiece.

  7. Jeff says:

    Unfortunately I think Williams’ score for The Force Awakens will be deemed ineligible, due to the “usage of pre-existing tracks or themes.” I hope I’m wrong though.

  8. Neil Lumbard says:

    Inside Out is probably a top contender for best original score as well. The film is phenomenal and the score is terrific. Giacchino won an oscar for the score to Up, so it seems like he will have a good chance at another Academy Award nomination, possibly even another win.

    • red_wine says:

      I think what helps is the space that Docter affords Giacchino. Like in Up, Inside Out has large sections of silence with only the music playing. This alone helps the music to pop where all other scores are competing with sound effects and dialog to be heard.

  9. Gabe says:

    “Inside Out” needs a mention here, at least. The main melody is a stone-cold earworm.

  10. Christian Shepherd says:

    How on Earth do you fail to mention Michael Giacchino’s score for Inside Out, easily one of the year’s best. He also did excellent work on Jupiter Ascending and Tomorrowland, though the Academy obviously won’t take that work seriously because the films that the scores were in flopped. He also provided solid support for the biggest hit of the year, Jurassic World.

    • Lars says:

      Totally agree. Personally I think Jupiter Ascending is the best score I’ve heard all year, but, as you say, that will never get nominated. Inside Out is much more likely. But hoping for a great SW score from Williams, Oscar nominated or not.

  11. Eli says:

    One day very soon. People will stop going to the movies and will switch off their tv sets. It will come so suddenly that Hollywood will be stunned.

    You put out one crap film after another. Awards go to the few, while talented newcomers are locked out.

    Laugh at us, but the tide is turning….and you’ll never see it coming.

More Film News from Variety