Broadcasters Protest FCC Indecency Fine to Roanoke TV Station

The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast.

In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest ever levied against a TV station for a single incident of airing indecent content.

The NAB, in a filing with the FCC, said the fine “improperly intrudes into broadcasters editorial discretion.” The organization said the FCC “inexplicably exacerbated its constitutionally suspect regulatory approach by proposing the highest indecency fine ever against a single station, which had inadvertently aired a fleeting sexual image in a newscast. Levying the maximum possible fine under the law in a case where the broadcast station indisputably did not purposefully air the image at issue is tantamount to imposing a sentence of life imprisonment for petty theft.”

The NAB was joined in its filing by the Radio Television Digital News Assn.

The fine came in response to complaints over the station’s July 12, 2012, newscast that featured a report on a former adult film star who joined a local volunteer rescue squad.

The station argued that it did been aware of the indecent material when it broadcast the screenshot of the adult film website. The images were featured in a small box on the adult film site, which a station photojournalist said he did not notice before the report was broadcast during a 6 p.m. newscast.

Broadcasters’ challenge of FCC sanctions over so-called fleeting expletives and indecent content have twice gone to the Supreme Court. In 2012 the Supreme Court struck down fines against Fox and ABC over fleeting material, finding that the networks were not given a fair notice of a change in policy. It stopped short, however, of revisiting the broader question of regulation of indecent content on the airwaves.

Broadcasters argue that the FCC’s fine was issued even though the agency has taken no action to clarify its indecency policy. They also say that news broadcasts are entitled to a higher level of First Amendment protection.

The NAB said the FCC’s action imperils broadcast coverage of live events, as the agency’s rationale “threatens to turn almost every human error, equipment failure or unpredictable occurrence resulting in the airing of arguably indecent material into a deliberate, intentional violation of federal criminal law and FCC regulation.”

It also contends that the fine “appears to be based, in substantial part, on the FCC’s displeasure with WDBJ’s editorial judgment and choice of news content.”

An FCC spokeswoman had no comment.

More Biz

  • Wilson Cruz Trace Lysette

    Watch Variety's Facebook Live Stream of GLAAD Media Awards Nominations

    The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast. In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest […]

  • PyeongChang Winter Olympics

    To Win Olympics, NBCU Must Lure Big Crowds -- and Small Streamers

    The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast. In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest […]

  • Korean Giant to Emerge from CJ

    Korea's CJ Orders Up Merger of Media and Shopping Units

    The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast. In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest […]

  • Nicolas Winding Refn, Times Bridge Invest

    Nicolas Winding Refn, India’s Times Bridge Invest in MUBI Streaming Service

    The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast. In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest […]

  • Los Angeles Women's March

    Natalie Portman, Allison Janney, Viola Davis Join Women's March Los Angeles Lineup

    The National Assn. of Broadcasters is questioning the constitutionality of a record fine the FCC issued against a Roanoke, Va., TV station for airing a sexually explicit video clip of an adult film website during a news broadcast. In March, the FCC announced its plans to issue to WDBJ-TV a fine of $325,000 — the highest […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content