TV Review: ‘The Affair’

The Affiar TV Review Showtime

The pairing of Dominic West and Ruth Wilson alone would be enough reason for enthusiasm about “The Affair,” a Showtime series that wraps infidelity in a mystery, then spoons out what happened in “Rashomon”-like dueling narratives. Launched behind “Homeland,” this is the kind of conceptually low-key series with which pay cable sometimes struggles to distinguish itself, but meticulously crafted and cleverly introduced, it’s likely to hook a discriminating audience, as well as launch Wilson, in particular, to another level in the U.S. after smaller theatrical roles and arresting TV work in her native U.K.

Why men cheat, of course, is an age-old question, especially when they seemingly have such idyllic-looking lives and so much to lose. In the case of West’s Noah, a schoolteacher and author (having sold a first novel), that includes a pretty wife, Helen (Maura Tierney), he’s still hot for and the four kids who inevitably interrupt them when they try to have sex.

In the premiere (the only episode thus far made available, and currently being offered early via various platforms), Noah and the family are trundling off to spend the summer at the home of her father (the happily ubiquitous John Doman, creating another mini-“The Wire” reunion with West), an extremely successful and imperious writer — and whose company, not surprisingly, Noah dreads.

When they stop to eat, he happens to meet Alison (Wilson), a waitress at the local diner. And this is where “The Affair” really gets interesting, since the show is bifurcated, related on parallel tracks through Noah and Alison, who remember what transpired in subtly different — but significant, and almost always self-serving — ways. (Even the wardrobe changes, a nifty touch.)

Moreover, the two are telling their tales to someone in law enforcement (think “True Detective”), suggesting something has gone terribly wrong. But what?

For her part, Alison is recovering, not very well, from an unimaginable loss, one that has strained her relationship with her husband Cole (Joshua Jackson). Having played a wide variety of roles — a ruthless killer in “Luther” being among the most memorable — Wilson conveys that unhappiness with enormous economy, saying much of it just with her eyes. Unlike West, who experiences occasional lapses, she sounds very much at ease with her Yankee accent.

Created by Sarah Treem, who also wrote the premiere, and Hagai Levy, with whom she collaborated on HBO’s “In Treatment,” “The Affair” makes good use of its framing device, allowing the story to gradually unfold, and creating an overhanging tension to each meaningful glance, along with the intriguing questions of whose account is more trustworthy.

Striking the right balance with such a character-driven construct can be perilous, but with the casting and initial tone, “The Affair” appears well ahead of the game, to the point where many will find further attendance compulsory.

“Everyone has one book in them,” Noah’s father-in-law tells him, before haughtily adding, “Almost nobody has two.”

The same is generally true for topnotch TV series. But if “The Affair” stays anywhere close to its first chapter, Treem and Levi appear destined to buck that trend.

TV Review: 'The Affair'

(Series; Showtime, Sun. Oct. 12, 10 p.m.)

Production

Filmed in New York by Showtime.

Crew

Executive producers, Sarah Treem, Hagai Levi, Jeffrey Reiner, Eric Overmyer; co-executive producers, Kerry Orent, Kate Robin, Melanie Marnich; director, Mark Mylod; writer, Treem; story by Treem, Levi; camera, Steven Fierberg; production designer, Kevin Thompson; editor, Pete Beaudreau; music, Marcelo Zarvos; casting, Julie Tucker, Ross Meyerson, Junie Lowry Johnson, Libby Goldstein. 60 MIN.

Cast

Dominic West, Ruth Wilson, Maura Tierney, Joshua Jackson, Julia Goldani Telles, Jake Siciliano, Jadon Sand, Leya Catlett, John Doman

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 6

Leave a Reply

6 Comments

Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Ross says:

    Why do men cheat? Why not ask “why do women cheat”?

  2. Lola Q says:

    I like ‘The Affair’ and will keep watching. However, I find the American accents of West and Wilson to be very questionable at times.

  3. Greg Finley says:

    Just what did you people like? In the first 10 minutes, the writers saw fit to give us death scares to 2 of the kids, intertwined with lame dialogue about hating the trip to grandpa’s. Once they stop for breakfast, a waitress shamelessly hits on our hunky but brooding star (the second woman to make a play for him in the show’s first 10 minutes as well), then when our restless, brooding star goes for a midnight stroll on the beach, who does he happen upon but his hot-to-trot waitress, who after turning down an invite to a shower, he watches her get raped, never losing eye contact with her. Just exactly what was I supposed to find entertaining? No thanks.

  4. Tinpanannie says:

    Finally a break from all the formula shows in the Fall lineup. The Affairs first episode promises a drama that’s well acted and although the theme is familiar the approach to it is different. It’s too bad we have to wait a week for the next episode. I really enjoy shows when the characters are three dimensional and not the usual glamorous stereotypes that are so often used. Apart from the mock child suicide scene that was unnecessary and over the top this was the best premiere I have seen this Fall so far.

  5. judith barlev says:

    No matter how good is Dominic – he will never be as good as Josh, and Josh will always overshadow him with his talent and his beauty. I don’t like Ruth Wilson, saw her several times and did not like her. I would have liked to see Josh and Anna Torv work together.

  6. doppelganger says:

    Absolutely. This intelligent, well-cast drama isn’t just about cheating; it’s about subjectivity, and how we each see the facts in our own way. The acting is extraordinary, with the mesmerizing setting. This is sort of an escape and breath of fresh air.

More TV News from Variety

Loading