TV Review: ‘Riot’

With:

With: Rove McManus, John Ross Bowie, Jamie Denbo, Brian Palermo, Jordan Black, Jessica McKenna, Meryl Hathaway, Rob Gleeson

If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game group of performers undergo a series of stunt-enhanced physical gags — as if to reinforce how stretched they are for ideas, using one of them twice to begin and end the hour. Despite a few muffled chuckles, there’s nothing here that remotely approaches the title.

Indeed, a more general challenge with improv in almost any setting is how much toil goes into conjuring comedy, and how the fall-back position when a sketch isn’t completely working is just to keep getting louder and more frenetic. Based on decibel level, “Riot” — unnecessarily derived from a French format — makes a pretty strong case for the helping hands of writers.

As with “Whose Line,” there’s no game to speak of (“We don’t care who wins,” the Australian McManus says, echoing, “The points don’t matter”), and despite different celebrity guests — in the opener, Carell and “The Office” co-star Andy Buckley — most of the heavy lifting falls on a team of marginally ready-for-primetime players.

The twice-used set involves a room sloped at a 22% angle, resulting in a lot of stumbles and falls. Another bit is essentially a game of charades, only with a giant swinging ball that bowls over the clue-giver if the riddle isn’t solved fast enough. And so on.

Brevity is usually an asset in these situations, so Fox has done “Riot” no favors by scheduling the program as an hour, to the point where it’s clearly running on fumes, and the “Wipeout”-like obstacles thrown at the comics yield rapidly diminishing returns.

Landing Carell, obviously, and other assorted guests looks like something of a coup, but there’s only so much star power can do to prop up a construct this slight.

Ultimately, improv is always going to be a hit-miss proposition. But despite being inordinately literal about its hits, “Riot” proves too liberal with its misses.

TV Review: 'Riot'

(Series; Fox, Tues. May 13, 9 p.m.)

Production:

Produced by Satisfaction, Carousel Television and Shine America.

Crew:

Executive producers, Steve Carell, Jim Biederman, Paul Franklin, Eden Gaha, Thom Hinkle; co-executive producers, Adam Zuvich, Rich Brown; director, Ron de Moraes; writers, Biederman, Evan Mann, John Plummer, Gareth Reynolds. 60 MIN.

Cast:

With: Rove McManus, John Ross Bowie, Jamie Denbo, Brian Palermo, Jordan Black, Jessica McKenna, Meryl Hathaway, Rob Gleeson

More TV

  • Matt Groening Netflix Series 'Disenchantment' Sets

    Matt Groening Netflix Series 'Disenchantment' Sets Premiere Date

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • Blake Shelton performs at the CMA

    Kelly Clarkson, Blake Shelton, Chris Stapleton to Perform at CMT Music Awards

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • Babylon Berlin

    'Babylon Berlin,' Mainland Europe's Most Expensive Show, Set for Third Season (EXCLUSIVE)

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • UFC

    ESPN Adds Fights to UFC TV Rights Deal, Reaching $1.5 Billion Value (EXCLUSIVE)

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • Colin Callender on 'Cursed Child' and

    Strictly Business Podcast: Colin Callender on 'Cursed Child' and Navigating Co-Productions

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • White Famous' TV show premiere

    TV News Roundup: Jamie Foxx Returns to Host BET Awards

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

  • catastrophe

    Number of Female Writers in British Film and TV at ‘Abjectly Low Levels’

    If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery (and television), those responsible for “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” should be positively red-faced watching “Riot,” Fox’s amped-up, exhausting new improv show. Host Rove McManus bills the premiere as an “utterly ridiculous night of fun,” which is half right, as exec producer Steve Carell and a game […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content