TV Review: ‘Jane the Virgin’

Jane the Virgin TV Review CW

Despite a few problematic aspects with the premise, “Jane the Virgin” contains a secret ingredient that is in short supply, perhaps especially on many of the CW’s recent soaps: Charm. Much of that comes from Gina Rodriguez in a star-making turn as the title character, who through a series of unexpected mix-ups — one a real doozy — finds her life beginning to resemble the telenovelas she watches with her doting grandmother, who has cajoled her to remain chaste. There’s a lot going on in the pilot, almost all of it fun and frothy, bringing genuine effervescence to CW’s soap bubbles.

Rodriguez’s Jane has been raised by her mom (Andrea Navedo), who was very young when she bore her out of wedlock, and the aforementioned grandma (Ivonne Coll). It’s a story told in a cheeky voiceover (“Jane’s life was now the stuff of telenovelas”), as adapted from a Venezuelan series.

Jane has a boyfriend (Brett Dier), but at the ripe old age of 23, she’s thus far managed to keep him sexually at bay. So she has some ’splainin’ to do when a pap smear performed by a love-struck, distracted ob-gyn is mixed up with an artificial insemination, leaving her in a family way that grandma, at least, first wants to embrace as a sign from God.

To make matters sudsier, the sample comes from a dreamy hotel owner, Rafael (Justin Baldoni), who Jane knew and had a crush on. Oh yes, and because of a bout with cancer, he’s no longer able to father a child, which explains why Rafael and his shrewish wife (Yael Grobglas) were relying on the procedure.

As written by Jennie Snyder Urman and directed by Brad Silberling, “Jane” keeps steadily churning out such twists, right up until the end. And if there’s some peril in moving at that kind of speed story-wise, the casting and general amiability of tone suggests viewers might be fairly tolerant of the inevitable missteps.

Understandably, Jane’s boyfriend is not enthused about beginning their life together with his intended carrying someone else’s baby. And while the show largely skirts the thornier aspects of that — or the case to be made for abortion under the circumstances — its nods toward the exaggerated nature of soaps in general and telenovelas in particular create a context that makes such political considerations feel less serious.

CW has scheduled the series behind the vampire drama “The Originals” (the undead and superheroes are very hard to escape in these precincts), and with “The Flash,” the netlet has gone an impressive two for two in terms of developing new dramas that look poised to stick around for a while.

That might not qualify as a miracle, but especially in the context of Rodriguez’s arrival, it is the kind of birth worth celebrating.

TV Review: 'Jane the Virgin'

(Series; CW, Mon. Oct. 13, 9 p.m.)


Filmed in Los Angeles by Poppy Prods., RCTV and Electus in association with CBS Television Studios and Warner Bros. Television.


Executive producers, Jennie Snyder Urman, Ben Silverman, Gary Pearl, Jorge Granier, Brad Silberling; co-executive producer, Lewis Abel; director, Silberling; writer, Snyder Urman; camera, Xavier Grobet; production designer, Stephen McCabe; editor, Shannon Mitchell; music, Kevin Kiner; casting, Alyson Silverberg, Jonathan Clay Harris. 60 MIN.


Gina Rodriguez, Andrea Navedo, Justin Baldoni, Yael Grobglas, Brett Dier, Ivonne Coll, Jaime Camil

Filed Under:

Want to read more articles like this one? SUBSCRIBE TO VARIETY TODAY.
Post A Comment 4

Leave a Reply


Comments are moderated. They may be edited for clarity and reprinting in whole or in part in Variety publications.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. ascendingbutterfly says:

    Kudos, very balanced review. This show to me is much like Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter was a movie, far fetched premise that is so well acted and shrewdly written than you actually find yourself ‘caring’ which is very rare for a series of any genre quite frankly. I am looking forward to watching how this show develops!

    Tracy @

  2. Beth CP says:

    Truth? I was skeptical thinking that the “plot device” of an “accidental insemination” would actually be carried out in a somewhat believable manner. And yeah, it’s a tad far-fetched but considering what is still present on the current remaining network US soaps as well as the Spanish language telenovelas, it (almost) makes sense. What sold me on the show at this first viewing is the warmth and, yes, that secret weapon, charm that seeps through it’s dialogue. Not just from Gina Rodriguez but the whole cast looks to be commited to what they’re portraying. That in itself sometimes makes up for those elements that stretch that believability. Hopefully, this show will “grow legs” and develop some rich storylines that afford it more than a single season pick up. I very much enjoyed it.

  3. I like the review, very fair. I like this show. I don’t want to sit down to vampires and so called dead people after a long day. I want a well told story and this has started out well. I saw the Mexican version on Azteca TV…very dramatic. Thank you Set Designer for the lack of rebozos & pictures of JFK….one “Santo” is OK.

  4. elgianne says:

    HORRIBLE! I think you need an IQ of zero to enjoy this show. Ugh! What garbage.

More TV News from Variety