TV Review: ‘Forever’

With:
Ioan Gruffudd, Judd Hirsch, Alana De La Garza, Lorraine Touissant, Donnie Keshawarz, Joel David Moore

For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd is likable enough, but the rules of the show — poorly explained though they might be — tend to blunt any emotional attachment. Given ABC’s trio of strikeouts in the timeslot last year, the title seems overly ambitious; for starters, “November” sounds like a more reasonable goal.

Gruffudd’s Henry is working as a medical examiner in New York City, where his secret is known only to his blustery sidekick Abe (Judd Hirsch). More than 200 years ago Henry was struck by lightning, resulting in a condition where no matter how he dies, he immediately comes back — naked, and in water.

Aside from the parallels to the birthing process, this creates some peculiar opportunities, as well as considerable awkwardness when he’s on a subway car that crashes, resulting in multiple fatalities. Working the case brings him into contact with a detective, Jo Martinez (“Law & Order” alumna Alana De La Garza), who is suspicious of Henry, but can only fritter around the edges of what might be weird about him.

Yet once series creator Matt Miller has established the basic premise, Henry’s predicament raises more questions than it answers — starting with why anyone should become invested in his fate when those circumstances allow him to be utterly fearless. As a second episode makes clear, the producers do intend to have some fun with Henry’s rather morbid familiarity with different ways to die, given as he is to cavalierly comparing one to another.

Nor do the threads of an underlying mystery and threat — signaling a deeper mythology — add much zest to Henry’s backstory, beyond offering some hope that this won’t just be a cop drama where the hero periodically gets recycled.

There is, inevitably, the promise of chemistry developing between the central duo, but even that only makes the series feel more mundane than its concept. (Lorraine Touissant does join the show as Martinez’s boss in the second episode — as the show shifts to a regular Tuesday slot in which we scarcely had time to get to know “Lucky 7,” “Killer Women” and “Mind Games” — after a Monday preview.)

Granted, Fox has garnered a fair amount of mileage out of another pairing of a female cop and anachronistic male hero on “Sleepy Hollow” — a series with its own twist on returning after death. But even with that precedent, “Forever” just doesn’t feel built to last.

TV Review: 'Forever'

(Series; ABC, Mon. Sept. 22, 10 p.m.)

Production: Filmed in New York by Lin Pictures and Good Session Prods. in association with Warner Bros. Television.

Crew: Executive producers, Matt Miller, Dan Lin, Jennifer Gwartz, Brad Anderson; producer, Raymond Quinlan; director, Anderson; writer, Miller; camera, Tom Yatsko; production designer, Stuart Wurtzel; editor, Matt Barber; music, Josh Kramon; casting, Barbara Fiorentino. 60 MIN.

Cast: Ioan Gruffudd, Judd Hirsch, Alana De La Garza, Lorraine Touissant, Donnie Keshawarz, Joel David Moore

More TV

  • Scott Koondel CBS

    Why Churn is Good For Butter, But Not for TV (Guest Column)

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • "It Is Game Time Kids" -

    TV Ratings: 'Survivor,' 'Empire' Hit Finale Lows

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • Morgan Freeman

    Morgan Freeman Accused of Sexual Harassment by Multiple Women

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • "Third Year" -- A drug bust-turned-shootout

    'Code Black' Canceled After Three Seasons at CBS

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • Jason Bateman Arrested Development

    Jason Bateman Apologizes in Wake of Backlash Over Jeffrey Tambor-Jessica Walter Comments

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • Is Costume Drama the Next Genre

    Is Costume Drama the Next Genre for Scrutiny By China’s Censors?

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

  • 'Scarface' Slated for 35th Anniversary Re-Release

    Film News Roundup: 'Scarface' Set for 35th Anniversary Re-Release

    For some reason, TV has a bad habit of squandering immortality in the context of pedestrian police procedurals. Fox did as much in “New Amsterdam,” and ABC apes the formula in “Forever,” an oddly uninvolving drama that forces one to contemplate what “Castle” might look like if the lead character couldn’t die. Star Ioan Gruffudd […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content